M.J. Ardolino, J.P. Morken / Tetrahedron 71 (2015) 6409e6413
6411
from a three-coordinate complex, while the branched isomer might
arise from a complex involving two phosphine ligands.
96:4). Assuming that Dt-BPF is able to act as a hemilabile ligand in
this reaction as well, these results suggest that the lowered regio-
selectivity could arise from a competition between palladium
complexes in which one or both of the phosphines of the bidentate
ligand are coordinated.
2
.2. Bidentate ligands
Having established a tenable explanation for the linear selectivity
observed with monodentate ligands, the effect of bidentate ligand
bite-angle on regioselectivity was explored. We had originally pro-
posed that small-bite-angle bidentate ligands gave high branched
0
selectivity by separating the 1 and 1 carbons, effectively slowing the
0
0
1
,1 -elimination pathway and allowing the 3,3 -path to prevail. In
contrast, a larger bite-angle ligand might increase the proximity of
0
0
the1 and1 carbons, allowingthe1,1 -reductive elimination toensue.
To probe this hypothesis computationally, the activation free energy
Scheme 3. Effect of Bis(phosphino)ferrocene ligand on allyl-allyl coupling.
0
0
barriers for both the 3,3 - and 1,1 -reductive elimination pathways
were calculated for four of the ligands shown inTable 1. Interestingly,
the calculations provide little correlation between elimination bar-
riers and ligand bite-angle (Fig. 3). Each of the ligands showed DD
values favoring the 3,3 -pathway by >11 kcal/mol relative to the
,1 -path. These results fail to provide a link between ligand bite-
angle and the variability in regioselectivity observed experimen-
tally, and suggest that an alternate explanation is required.
Considering other pathways that could lead to the linear cou-
pling product, we considered whether large-bite-angle ligands
might allow reaction through three coordinate ‘arm off’ complexes
To explore computationally the ability of larger-bite-angle li-
gands to act as hemilabile ligands (Fig. 4), xantphos (53:47 b:l,
entry 8, Table 1) was chosen as a model ligand due to its structural
rigidity and nonselectivity in coupling reactions. Overall, these
computations indicated that xantphos may be able to access
z
G
0
0
1
a similar pathway leading to linear diene formation as that pro-
1
posed for triphenylphosphine. Starting from bis-ligated, bis(
h
-al-
0
lyl) GS
F
, 3,3 -reductive elimination through TS
H
to give branched
product occurs with an activation free energy barrier of 12.6 kcal/
0
mol. The 1,1 -pathway (TS
I
) is almost 15 kcal/mol higher in energy,
and remains an improbable source of linear product. As an alternate
to bond formation, GS can instead dissociate one arm of the
phosphine ligand to give mono-ligated GSG, which lies only
F
akin to TS as proposed for monodentate ligands. In this context,
factors other than bite-angle such as ligand flexibility could also
play a role in regiocontrol. As flexibility is often unrelated to ligand
bite-angle,6 this feature might explain the nonlinear correlation
between bite-angles and branched to linear ratios (e.g., entries 5e8,
Table 1). To examine this effect, the experiment shown in Scheme 3
was carried out.13 While structurally similar to bidentate dppf, di-
tert-butylphenylferrocene (Dt-BPF) has been shown to act as
a hemilabile or monodentate ligand in Pd-catalyzed cross-cou-
plings.14 Accordingly, when employed in the allyl-allyl coupling of
cinnamyl electrophiles and allylB(pin) (Scheme 3), Dt-BPF gives
a nearly opposite branched to linear ratio relative to dppf (15:85 vs
F
,12
3
.4 kcal/mol higher in energy. From this three-coordinate complex,
0
z
3,3 -reductive elimination through TS
also furnish the branched diene product.
J
(DG ¼10.0 kcal/mol) would
C E G
As seen with triphenylphosphine (GS to GS , Fig. 2), GS can
I
alternately isomerize to give GS , which lies 3.1 kcal/mol higher in
energy than GS , presumably due to increased steric interactions
G
between the adjacent phenyl substituent and the dissociated arm
0
of the ligand. From this complex, 3,3 -reductive elimination (TS
K
) to
form linear product showed a relatively small barrier of only
z
4
.4 kcal/mol, giving DDG values of ꢁ1.7 and ꢁ2.5 kcal/mol relative
to TS
Curtin-Hammett control, these calculations point to reaction
through the mono-ligated TS as not only possible, but preferred. It
H J
and TS , respectively. Assuming that the reaction is under
K
should be noted that the relative calculated energies predict a much
lower branched to linear ratio than is observed experimentally;
however, the actual product ratio values are likely within the error
H J K
of the calculated energy values, as TS , TS and TS all lie within
2.5 kcal/mol of one another. These calculations serve as qualitative
evidence that large-bite-angle, flexible ligands may behave as
hemilabile structures and allow reaction through three-coordinate
complexes. This proposal could also explain why dppb, a flexible
ꢀ
ligand with a bite-angle (98 ) smaller than that of the more-rigid
ꢀ
ꢀ
DPEphos or xantphos (102 and 109 , respectively) furnishes less
branched product (entries 6e8, Table 1).
3. Conclusion
Overall, this study provides insight into how ligands control
regioselectivity in allyl-allyl couplings. Although previous pro-
posals considered small-bite-angle bidentate ligands to promote
0
0
high branched selectivity by controlling rates of 3,3 - versus 1,1 -
reductive elimination, the present study provides evidence of an
alternate pathway. We now propose that the linear diene product
0
is instead formed through a 3,3 -reductive elimination from
a mono-ligated complex (F, Scheme 4) in which Pd sits at the
substituted carbon of the allyl fragment. This explanation accounts
for the high linear selectivity observed with monodentate ligands,
and also provides a rationale for why large-bite-angle bidentate
2
Fig. 3. Calculated reductive elimination selectivity from L Pd(allyl)(cinammyl) com-
plexes with varied ligand bite-angle.