Table 4 M (SEC), DP (NMR) and % conversion data for polymerizations catalyzed by TBO
n
% Secondary
hydroxy
end groups
Reaction
temp./ °C
M
g mol−1
(SEC)/
DP
(NMR)
% Conversion
1H
% Conversion
13C
n
Diol
PD
BD
HD
PD
BD
HD
120
120
120
80
80
80
477
1690
1660
642
1390
1028
4.7
12.1
11.0
5.8
10.8
11.2
34
100
100
29
80
100
56
100
100
50
93
100
n.a.
10.0
12.7
n.a.
8.6
14.0
Tetrabutoxy titanium (TBO) catalysis
integral when compared with that of the primary oxymethylene
peak at d 3.60 indicated that only 12.7% of chain ends could
be accounted for in this manner. Table 4 indicates the fraction
of secondary hydroxy end-groups formed in the polymeriz-
ations incorporating BD and HD. It can be seen from this
table that, in BD polymerizations, ca. 10% of the end groups
were formed from secondary residual BD units. Also,
consistently higher secondary hydroxy contents were found in
polymerizations involving HD than in those with BD.
Tables 4 and 5 contain the data derived from polymer systems
formed via catalysis using TBO. The first observation to be
made from these data is that none of the polymerizations
attain degrees of polymerization (DPs) that are close to the
theoretical value of 23. Secondly, both the DP and the final
conversion of CL appear to be a function of the choice of
diol. PD in particular is a rather poor choice of diol for these
polymerizations. Both the degree of polymerization and final
conversion of CL are significantly reduced at both reaction
temperatures. No significant differences in DPs or in rates of
polymerization were observed when the polymerizations were
conducted in the presence of either BD or HD. The data imply
that the PD–Ti complex, which forms as a result of transfer
from the propagating PCL chain, is a less efficient initiator of
CL polymerization than the similar complexes formed from
transfer to either BD or HD. PD in these systems should in
fact be regarded as a degradative chain transfer agent.
DBTO catalysis
The results from DBTO catalysis are shown in Tables 6 and
7. DBTO catalysis data echoed the results with TBO. Thus,
in polymerizations involving PD, at a polymerization tempera-
ture of 120 °C, although the final conversion was high (in fact
significantly higher than in the TBO catalyzed system), the
degree of polymerization and M , as measured by SEC, was
n
low. This again indicates that the PD–DBTO complex may
Table 5 shows the relative peak sizes of components in the
carbonyl region from the PCLs polymerized by catalysis with
TBO. The degradative behaviour of PD in these systems is
again noteworthy. At neither of the polymerization tempera-
tures, 80 °C or 120 °C, are resonances due to esters adjacent
to the diol unit observed. This again implies that initiation,
following transfer to PD, by the PD–Ti complex is inefficient.
The data imply that the majority of the PCL chains present
are initiated by some process other than insertion into a PD
alkoxide–Ti bond. The second point of note is that only one
resonance due to carbonyls attached to HD units is observed.
The spectra of all the polymerizations that include BD in the
reaction mixtures show two peaks in this region of equal
intensity. From reference to the spectra of the model diesters
it is clear that two resonances should be present. It can thus
be concluded that both the primary and secondary hydroxy
groups of BD are active in transfer and in reinitiation. Two
explanations are possible for the absence of the second peak
in the polymerizations involving HD. Firstly, the down-field
resonance due to a carbonyl attached to oxymethylene, derived
from transfer to primary hydroxy, may be hidden within the
dominant main chain resonance (C3). Alternatively, transfer
may occur only to primary hydroxy sites leaving the secondary
hydroxy group as a chain end. In the latter case it should be
possible to observe the secondary alcohol end group. For
example, in the product from a reaction conducted at 120 °C,
a peak which could be assigned to the secondary alcohol
oxymethylene protons was observed at d 3.76. However, its
not be an efficient reinitiator of polymerization. The high
conversion and low degree of polymerization in this system
may indicate the existence of a chain-breaking side reaction in
this system. Significantly, when the reactions were carried out
at the lower temperature of 80 °C, but for longer reaction
times, much improved results were obtained. Thus the degrees
of polymerization (as measured by NMR) and M s (SEC)
n
were much higher. The DPs were still, however, well removed
from the theoretical value. Examination of the 13C spectrum
showed that both of the expected oxymethylene and oxyme-
thine ester carbonyls arising from esterification of both the
secondary and primary hydroxy groups were present.
Interestingly, the 1H spectrum of the product from the PD
polymerization carried out at 120 °C also showed resonances
that could be attributed to free PD. The polymerizations
involving BD and HD proceeded to high conversion and gave
polymers of degrees of polymerization between 9 and 13,
which are again below the expected value. With this catalyst,
as with TBO, polymerizations involving HD appear to give a
significantly higher fraction of secondary hydroxy. Also, the
concentration of secondary hydroxy sites found in these poly-
merizations appears to be lower than in equivalent TBO
polymerizations. No resonances that could be assigned to
secondary hydroxy sites from the PD residue were observed.
Table 7 shows the results of 13C spectroscopy in the carbonyl
region. In the case of the PD (carried out at 80 °C) and BD
containing polymerizations the carbonyls attached to both
oxymethine and oxymethylene groups of the residual diol were
observed. In each case both resonances were observed to have
equal intensity. In the case of the HD containing polymeriz-
ation only one resonance was observed. However, as discussed
above for the TBO catalyzed polymerizations, this resonance
is derived from an oxymethine carbonyl and therefore the
second resonance must lie underneath the main chain reson-
ance, C3. Thus, as with the TBO catalyzed polymerizations,
both primary and secondary hydroxy groups are active in
transfer and reinitiation. However, reference to the 1H spectra,
discussed above, indicates that, as in the TBO catalyzed
system, the primary alcohol is more reactive in the transfer
Table 5 C1–C4 integrations for TBO catalysis
Reaction
temp./ °C
Diol
C4
C3
C2
C1
PD
BD
HD
PD
BD
HD
120
120
120
80
80
80
n.a.
0.06
0.08
n.a.
0.08
0.05
n.a.
0.04
n.a.
n.a.
0.08
n.a.
0.58
0.70
0.78
0.71
0.68
0.67
0.42
0.20
0.14
0.29
0.16
0.19
1074
J. Mater. Chem., 1999, 9, 1071–1076