Susceptibility to hydrolysis of phenylboronic pinacol esters at physiological pH

Article abstract of DOI:10.2478/s11532-012-0159-2

Boronic acids and their esters are highly considered compounds for the design of new drugs and drug delivery devices, particularly as boron-carriers suitable for neutron capture therapy. However, these compounds are only marginally stable in water. Hydrol

Full text of DOI:10.2478/s11532-012-0159-2

Cent. Eur. J. Chem. • 11(2) • 2013 • 137-139
DOI: 10.2478/s11532-012-0159-2
Central European Journal of Chemistry
Susceptibility to hydrolysis of phenylboronic
pinacol esters at physiological pH
Short Communication
1
1
2
Cesare Achilli , Annarita Ciana , Maurizio Fagnoni ,
1
1*
Cesare Balduini , Giampaolo Minetti
1Laboratories of Biochemistry, Department of Biology and Biotechnology
Lazzaro Spallanzani”, University of Pavia, 21–27100 Pavia, Italy
“
2Department of Chemistry, University of Pavia, 12–27100 Pavia, Italy
Received 27 April 2012; Accepted 15 October 2012
Abstract: Boronic acids and their esters are highly considered compounds for the design of new drugs and drug delivery devices, particularly
as boron-carriers suitable for neutron capture therapy. However, these compounds are only marginally stable in water. Hydrolysis of
some phenylboronic pinacol esters is described here. The kinetics is dependent on the substituents in the aromatic ring. Also the pH
strongly influences the rate of the reaction, which is considerably accelerated at physiological pH. Therefore, care must be taken when
considering these boronic pinacol esters for pharmacological purposes.
Keywords: Phenylboronic acid esters • Hydrolysis • Boron-carriers • Boron neutron capture therapy
©
Versita Sp. z o.o.
1
. Introduction
on the cell surface. The covalent interaction with cell-
surface carbohydrates may be the cause of the toxicity
Boronic acid compounds have received increasing and inflammatory properties of several phenylboronic
attention in the field of medicinal chemistry, as potential acid compounds [6].
pharmaceutical agents: development of enzyme
The esterification of boronic acids with diols may
inhibitors, controlled drug delivery polymers, saccharide restrict their reactivity with carbohydrates in vivo.
sensors, and boron neutron capture therapy (BNCT) [1]. Pinanediol, propanediol and pinacol are common diols
BNCT is a non-invasive approach for the destruction of used for the protection of boronic acids. However, the
10
cancer cells, based on the selective accumulation of B- corresponding boronic esters are not completely stable.
containing compounds into malignant cells. Subsequent In fact, they may be subject to transesterification with
10
irradiation with low-energy neutrons promotes B decay other diols, with the possible binding to carbohydrates,
4
7
to He and Li atoms, which can both exert a localized and to hydrolysis. The kinetics of hydrolysis is strongly
cytotoxicity for the tumour cell [2].
dependent both on the substituents of boron and on
Boronophenylalanine, boronic acid derivative the type of diol: there are compounds that are more
a
of phenylalanine, is the best boron-carrier presently susceptible to hydrolysis than others, and some are
used in BNCT, but its selectivity and biocompatibility relatively stable in water [5,7]. Concerning the stability of
are not completely satisfactory [3,4]. Many other phenylboronic pinacol esters, early works described full
phenylboronic acids could be potentially efficacious as stability in aqueous solutions [8,9] while, in more recent
boron-carriers but, unfortunately, they are very reactive publications, evidence of pronounced susceptibility to
with carbohydrates, with which they produce a series of hydrolysis of some phenylboronic pinacol esters has
5
- or 6-membered cyclic esters [5]. Carbohydrates are been presented [10,11].
present at high concentrations in biological systems, as
In the attempt to rationalize the discrepant reports
free molecules or bound to proteins and lipids, especially of the literature, we have studied here the kinetics of
*
E-mail: minetti@unipv.it
1
37

Susceptibility to hydrolysis of phenylboronic
pinacol esters at physiological pH
Figure 1. The picture summarizes the interconversion between phenylboronic acid plus pinacol and the corresponding pinacol ester (A). The
stability of different phenylboronic pinacol esters in water (B) and in 50 mM sodium phosphate pH 7.4 buffer (C) was assayed by
detection of the formed phenylboronic acid using reverse-phase HPLC (see the “Experimental” section). The diagrams show the
percentage of residual phenylboronic ester as a function of time (min).
hydrolysisinwaterandinphysiologicalbufferedsolutions and was detected at 280 nm. The retention times
of phenylboronic pinacol esters, para-substituted with were (mean±standard deviation, n=10): 6.3±0.07 min
hydroxyl, acetamide or amine groups.
for para-hydroxy-phenylboronic acid, 7.8±0.2 min for
para-acetamido-phenylboronic acid, and 5.3±0.4 min for
para-amino-phenylboronic acid.
2
. Experimental procedure
Phenylboronic acids, the corresponding pinacol esters, 3. Results and discussion
and the other main reagents were from Sigma-Aldrich
(Milan, Italy).
The conversion of phenylboronic pinacol esters to the
The phenylboronic pinacol ester stock solutions corresponding boronic acids in aqueous solvents, whose
(100 mM) were made in anhydrous ethanol, diluted to reaction is schematised in Fig. 1A, was monitored in
0.5 mM in deionised water or 50 mM sodium phosphate time by HPLC analysis, until completion of hydrolysis.
pH 7.4 buffer, incubated for different times at room The kinetics of hydrolysis for the three compounds in
temperature, and then analysed by reverse-phase water (Fig. 1B) and in a 50 mM sodium phosphate buffer
HPLC with a Supelcosil LC-18-T (25×0.46 cm, 5 µm at pH 7.4 (Fig. 1C) are shown.
particle size) column (Supelco). The eluents were water/
Hydroxyl- and acetamide-substituted compounds
methanol, both supplemented with 0.1% (v/v) formic have a similar rate of hydrolysis in water: the half-time
acid. The gradient elution program was: 20% methanol of this reaction is about 10 min, and the hydrolysis is
for 5 min, from 20% to 70% methanol in 5 min, 70% complete in 1 h. Conversely, the amine-substituted
methanol for 5 min, from 70% to 20% methanol in ester display a slower rate of hydrolysis: the half-
1
min, and then equilibration for 14 min (flow rate: time is of 3 h and the hydrolysis is complete within
-1
1.2 mL min ). For each analysis 250 µL of sample were 8 h. The observed differences could be justified by
loaded. The elution was performed at room temperature the mechanism proposed for the hydrolysis of boronic
138

C. Achilli et al.
esters, which occurs as a nucleophilic attack to boron
by water: electron-donor substituents on the aromatic
4
. Conclusions
ring decrease the electrophilic character of the boron, In conclusion, we have shown that the rate of hydrolysis
by accumulating a partial negative charge on the boron for different phenylboronic pinacol esters is slower
itself, thus disadvantaging the reaction [12]. In fact, the when strong electron-donor groups, rather than mild
amine group has a higher electron-donor character than electron-donor groups, are linked in para position
the hydroxyl or acetamide groups, as indicated by the to the boronic moiety on the aromatic ring, and that
sigma values of Hammett (amine: -0.66, hydroxyl: -0.37, at physiological pH the reaction is markedly faster.
and acetamide: -0.15) [13].
These factors should be taken into consideration when
Similar to what observed in water, in a buffered designing new phenylboronate derivatives for use in
system at pH 7.4 the kinetics appears to be influenced medicinal chemistry as boron-carriers for BNCT or
by the same electronic effects, but the reaction is much for other purposes.
faster: for the amino-substituted ester the half-time of
hydrolysis is 5 min, and the reaction is complete in
1
h, while for the hydroxyl- and acetamide-substituted Acknowledgements
compounds the reaction is complete within 5 min.
The kinetics of hydrolysis is also influenced by pH: at This work has been funded by the CARIPLO Foundation,
pH values above the pKa of the boronic acid the reaction Project N. 2009-2440 “Development and safety
is favoured. The theoretical pKa values of boronic acids assessment of nanostructured compounds applicable to
analysed here are: 9.0 for acetamide, 9.5 for hydroxyl, boron neutron capture therapy”.
and 10.1 for amine [14]. The pH of the solutions obtained
by dissolving the various compounds in water was found
to be approximately 5.4, thus explaining the lower rates
observed in the unbuffered, slightly acidic solutions.
References
[
[
1] W. Yang, X. Gao, B. Wang, Med. Res. Rev. 23, 346 [7] R. Bernardini, A. Oliva, A. Paganelli, E. Menta,
(
2003)
M. Grugni, S. De Munari, L. Goldoni, Chem. Lett.
38, 750 (2009)
2] A.H. Soloway, W. Tjarks, B.A. Barnum, F.G. Rong,
R.F. Barth, I.M. Codogni, J.G. Wilson, Chem. Rev. [8] H.G. Kuivila, A.H. Keough, E.J. Soboczenski,
8, 1515 (1998)
J. Org. Chem. 8, 780 (1954)
3] A.K. Asbury, R.G. Ojemann, S.L. Nielsen, [9] R.A. Bowie, O.C. Musgrave, J. Chem. Soc. 3945
9
[
[
[
W.H. Sweet, J. Neuropathol. Exp. Neurol. 31, 278
1972)
(1963)
(
[10] T.I. Lazarova, L. Jin, M. Rynkiewicz, J.C. Gorga,
F. Bibbins, H.V. Meyers, R. Babine, J. Strickler,
Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 16, 5022 (2006)
[11] S.R. Inglis, A. Zervosen, E.C. Woon, T. Gerards,
N. Teller, D.S. Fischer, A. Luxen, C.J. Schofield,
J. Med. Chem. 52, 6097 (2009)
4] K. Taniyama, H. Fujiwara, T. Kuno, N. Saito,
H. Shuntoh, M. Sakaue, C. Tanaka, Pigment Cell
Res. 2, 291 (1989)
5] D.G. Hall, Structure, Properties, and Preparation
of Boronic Acid Derivatives, in Boronic Acids:
Preparation and Applications in Organic Synthesis, [12] R.D. Pizer, A.A. Tihal, Polyhedron 15, 3411 (1996)
Medicine and Materials, 2nd edition (Wiley-VCH [13] C. Hansch, A. Leo, Substituent constants for
Verlag GmbH & Co., Weinheim, 2011)
6] I. Dasgupta, E.A. Tanifum, M. Srivastava,
correlation analysis in chemistry and biology
(J. Wiley and Sons, New York, 1979)
[
S.S. Phatak, C.N. Cavasotto, M. Analoui, [14] J. Yan, G. Springsteen, S. Deeter, B. Wang,
A. Annapragada, PLoS One 7, e29585 (2012)
Tetrahedron 60, 11205 (2004)
1
39