unknown. However, several hypotheses have been proposed
in the literature to explain this phenomenon. Formation of
ThT micelles in the environment of the amyloid fibril have
been proposed by Khurana et al.[23] Groenning et al.[24] have
proposed that the formation of ThT excimers in the excited
state is mainly responsible for the observed fluorescence en-
hancement, though the formation of excimers by a charged
species is always a topic of debate. Very recently, by using
optical microscopic measurements, Kitts and Vanden
Bout[25] have shown that the observed enhancement in the
emission of the ThT in amyloid fibril is due to the associa-
tion of the monomeric form of the dye to the protein rather
than the formation of their micelles or excimers.
Detailed studies in several confined environments, like in
amyloid fibril,[2,12,15,19–22] polymer,[26] glass matrix,[27] nano-
confined water pool,[18] etc., clearly indicate that the high
local viscosity of the microenvironment around the dye is di-
rectly related to the observed fluorescence enhancement of
the ThT dye in these systems. However, understanding the
basic molecular process that is associated with the observed
fluorescence enhancement of ThT in the above microenvir-
onments remains elusive. Considering the molecular struc-
ture of ThT, it is hypothesized that in bulk water, due to the
low viscosity of the medium, some intramolecular bond
twisting process takes place in the excited state of the ThT
molecules. This bond twisting process effectively introduces
a very fast nonradiative decay channel for the excited ThT
molecule, which leads to its extremely low emission yield. In
contrast, in a highly viscous medium, like in amyloid fibril,
the bond twisting process in the dye is substantially retard-
ed, reducing the nonradiative decay channel in its excited
state. This results in a remarkable increase in the emission
yield of ThT in a highly viscous medium. It is also proposed
that the bond twisting process is associated with the large in-
tramolecular charge transfer from the aniline moiety of ThT
to the benzothiazole moiety.[28,29] Such a charge transfer, as-
sociated with the bond twisting in the dye, effectively results
in the formation of a twisted intramolecular charge transfer
(TICT) state in the excited ThT molecules.
well as from theoretical calculations, it was shown that the
twisting of the amino group as well as of the anilino group
contribute significantly towards the nonradiative decay
channel of this molecule in its excited states.[32] Very recent-
ly, Saha et al.[33] have shown that in dimethyl-aminostyryl-
benzothiazole, having a close structural relation with ThT,
only the twisting of the amino group is responsible for the
fast nonradiative decay in its excited state.
Based on these literature precedents, it is expected that
for ThT twisting of either of these two bonds (see
Scheme 1) can be responsible for the ultrafast nonradiative
decay channel in its excited state. In order to use ThT or
some of its derivatives as an efficient sensor for different mi-
croenvironments, including that of amyloid fibril, it is very
essential to identify the bond, which is responsible for its ul-
trafast nonradiative decay channel. This information might
also help to develop much better sensor based on the ThT
structure. In order to disentangle this issue, we designed and
synthesized two ThT derivatives, Ia and Ib (Scheme 1), with
the premise that the lack of a methyl group in the benzo-
thiazole, as is present in ThT, would not change the fluores-
cence properties, compared to ThT. For the two dye mole-
cules, twisting around both bonds is possible in Ia, but the
presence of a julolidine group in Ib would prohibit twisting
ꢀ
of the Ph NR2 bond and allows twisting around the central
ꢀ
ꢀ
C C bond (benzothiazole aniline) only. Subsequently, we
carried out detailed steady-state and time-resolved photo-
physical studies of Ia and Ib in different solvents to identify
the bond that is responsible for the sensory activity of the
ThT class of molecules. The experimental results are also
substantiated by quantum chemical calculations.
Results and Discussion
Steady-state absorption and fluorescence studies: The
ground-state absorption and the steady-state fluorescence
spectra of the ThT derivatives Ia and Ib in aqueous solution
are shown in Figure 1. As indicated in the Figure, both ab-
sorption and emission spectra of Ib are significantly red
From the molecular structure of ThT (see Scheme 1), it is
clearly evident that there are two possible bond twistings,
ꢀ
one occurring around the C N single bond (i.e., twisting of
the amino (NR2) group) and/or the other occurring around
ꢀ
the central C C single bond (i.e., twisting of the anilino
(PhNR2) group). Twisting around any one of these bonds
can introduce the nonradiative decay channel in the excited
state of ThT, causing a very low emission yield. There are
several reports in the literature on organic dyes with an N-
alkylated anilino group where it is shown that the twisting
of either the N-alkylated amino group or of the anilino
group can cause the enhanced nonradiative decay of the ex-
cited dye that results in a large reduction of their emission
yields. For example, in several triphenyl dyes with amine
substitution, it is reported that the twisting of the anilino
group in their excited state is responsible for their low emis-
Figure 1. Ground-state absorption and steady-state fluorescence spectra
of Ia (c) and Ib (a) in aqueous solution. Absorption and emission
spectra of ThT in water (g) are also shown for comparison.
sion yield.[30,31] For para-(N,N-dialkylamino)benzylidene
ononitriles, however, based on experimental evidence as
ACHTUNGTNERmNUNG al-
ACHTUNGTRENNUNG
9258
ꢁ 2010 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Chem. Eur. J. 2010, 16, 9257 – 9263