Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
with two plasmid systems showed very poor protein expres-
Surprisingly, whereas meso-5 was formed in the case of
sion for P450 (see Figures S2B and S2C). The designed whole
cells with one plasmid system were then tested in the
conversion of 3 into 5. Under these conditions, the cofactor
is provided by the E. coli host cells using glucose as an energy
source. As shown in Table 1, all three stereoisomeric diols 5
were obtained with high enantio- and diastereoselectivity on
an optional basis. Thus the E. coli (P450ATC06 + BDHA)
cells that combine the R-selective P450-BM3 mutant and R,R-
selective BDHA provided (R,R)-5 (Table 1, entry 1) whereas
E. coli (P450ATD04 + BDHA) or E. coli (P450ATC06 +
BUDC) containing the S/R-selective P450-BM3 mutant and
the R,R/S,S-selective ADH favored meso-5, the former being
more selective (Table 1, entries 2 and 3). The exclusive
formation of (S,S)-5 was achieved by E. coli (P450ATD04 +
BUDC) co-expressing the S-selective P450-BM3 mutant and
the S,S-selective BUDC (Table 1, entry 4). (S,S)-5 was also
obtained using the E. coli (P450ATD04 + LBDHA) strain
that harbors the S-selective P450-BM3 mutant and LBDHA
(Table 1, entry 6). This ADH is known to accept (S)-2-
hydroxybutanone with formation of (S,S)-2,3-butanediol.[12c]
The remaining combination of P450ATC06 with LBDHA
failed to show acceptable levels of enantio- and diastereose-
lectivity. In control experiments, it was shown that both
BUDC and LBDHA catalyze the reduction of 3, whereas
BDHA does not. Therefore, a trace amount of 2 was detected
in the whole-cell systems that contained BUDC or LBDHA.
At this point, mixtures of two E. coli cells, one harboring
a P450-BM3 mutant and the other one an ADH, or two cell
lysates, were tested, but all led to inacceptable results (20–
50% conversion; see the Supporting Information for details).
Next, we tested whether the two best P450-BM3 mutants
ATC06 and ATD04 were capable of catalyzing the sequence
2!3!4 (see Table S7), which proved to be the case.
mutant ATC06, it was not detected when 3 was used as the
substrate in the respective control experiment. This indicates
that the ATC06 variant is also able to catalyze the direct
hydroxylation of 2 into meso-5. The best whole cells were then
tested in the three-step cascade sequence 2!3!4!5. Using
the best cell systems, it was possible to obtain all three
stereoisomeric cyclohexane-1,2-diols 5 as the major products
with high enantio- and diastereoselectivity (Table 2). In
contrast, E. coli (P450ATC06 + BDHA) cells gave a mixture
of trans- and meso-5 with reduced selectivity (85:15) owing to
the competing direct oxidation of 2 into meso-5.
Finally, the utility of the two best mutants P450ATC06 and
P450ATD04 was tested in the cascade sequence of 1!2!3!
4. Unfortunately, only low conversions into 3 were observed
(Table S8). This may come as a surprise but we postulated
that these P450-BM3 variants, although highly regio- and
stereoselective, are not active enough to smoothly catalyze all
three reactions 1!2!3!4. Indeed, the E. coli whole cells
(Table 1) failed to function well in the longer cascade
sequence 1!2!3!4!5. We therefore turned our attention
to the mutants generated in the initial library (Table S1), and
discovered that the two enantiocomplementary P450 mutants
A82F and A82F/A328F catalyze the sequence 1!2!3!4
with good selectivity (Table S8). These variants are consid-
erably more active than ATC06 and ATD04 in the hydrox-
ylation of 3, although a little less selective. Consequently, four
additional whole cells were engineered according to the best
combinations. These were then used in the cascade sequences
starting from 1 with final formation of cyclohexane-1,2-diols 5
(Table 3). Good results were obtained in the case of the
enantiomeric diols (R,R)- and (S,S)-5, these being the major
products with enantiomeric ratios ranging between 96:4 and
> 99:1 and diastereoselectivities of 85–93%. When aiming for
Table 1: Conversion of 3 into stereoisomeric diols 5 using E. coli cells co-expressing P450-BM3 mutants and ADHs.
Entry
Catalyst
Conv. [%][a]
trans/meso
e.r. [%][c]
Favored stereoisomer
Product distribution[b] [%]
2
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
6
E. coli (P450ATC06+BDHA)
E. coli (P450ATD04+BDHA)
E. coli (P450ATC06+BUDC)
E. coli (P450ATD04+BUDC)
E. coli (P450ATC06+LBDHA)
E. coli (P450ATD04+LBDHA)
90
98
84
98
91
97
98:2
5:95
8:92
95:5
51:49
96:4
>99:1
(R,R)
meso
meso
(S,S)
N.A.
(S,S)
0
0
17
3
29
8
1
1
1
0
2
1
99
99
82
97
69
91
[d]
–
–
[d]
>99:1
[d]
–
98:2
[a] Conditions: 10 mm substrate, 308C, 200 rpm, 5 h. The conversion was determined by GC analysis and is based on the amount of converted
substrate. For detailed conditions see the Supporting Information. [b] Relative amounts based on the peak areas in the GC chromatograms.
[c] Determined for trans-cyclohexane-1,2-diols 5. [d] Values not determined. N.A.=not available.
Table 2: Conversion of 2 into stereoisomeric diols 5 using E. coli cells co-expressing P450-BM3 mutants and ADHs.
Entry
Catalyst
Conv. [%][a]
trans/meso
e.r. [%][c]
Favored stereoisomer
Product distribution [%][b]
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
E. coli (P450ATC06+BDHA)
E. coli (P450ATD04+BDHA)
E. coli (P450ATC06+BUDC)
E. coli (P450ATD04+BUDC)
E. coli (P450ATD04+LBDHA)
96
20
97
99
99
85:15
4:96
19:81
95:5
>99:1
(R,R)
meso
meso
(S,S)
(S,S)
4
35
3
2
2
1
0
1
1
0
95
65
96
97
98
[d]
–
–
[d]
>99:1
97:3
96:4
[a] Conditions: 5 mm substrate, 308C, 200 rpm, 5 h. The conversion was determined by GC analysis and is based on the amount of converted
substrate. For detailed conditions see the Supporting Information. [b] Relative amounts based on the peak areas in the GC chromatograms.
[c] Determined for trans-cyclohexane-1,2-diols 5. [d] Values not determined.
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2016, 55, 1 – 5
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
3
These are not the final page numbers!