22
M. Zheng et al. / Journal of Organometallic Chemistry 817 (2016) 21e25
Fig. 2. Selected bis-pyrazolyl ligands 4~7.
carboxyl-containing 4 or the hydroxy-containing 5 and 6 didn’t
show reactivity toward ethylene oligomerization, although all of
them have a reactive hydroxyl group. Compared with the carboxyl-
containing ligand 4, the catalyst supported by the ester-containing
ligand 7 showed lower activity and similar selectivity (Table 1,
entries 4 and 7).
Fig. 1. Selected bis-pyrazolyl ligands for selective ethylene oligomerization.
Ligand 3 having a thiopheneyl group achieved the highest ac-
tivity with a considerable total selectivity toward 1-hexene and 1-
octene, and were then selected for further investigation under
different reaction condition to improve the catalyst performance.
Increasing the Al/Cr molar ratio from 600 to 800 enhanced the
activity and produced slight more total selectivity toward 1-hexene
and 1-octene, with a similar amount of polymer formed (Table 1,
2
. Results and discussion
Avoiding the use of dangerous phosgene, we have synthesized
the new ligands 1~3 in 39e75% yields, by a modified method [13],
from a condensation reaction of the corresponding aldehydes with
0
ꢀ
ꢀ
(
Pz )
2
S¼O (from thionyl chloride) (Scheme 1). The hydroxy-
entries 3 and 8). Increasing temperature from 60 C to 80 C led to a
slight increase in activity and a decrease in selectivity toward either
1-hexene or 1-octene (Table 1, entries 3 and 9). Same trend was also
containing ligands 4~6 and were known compounds and pre-
pared by the literature methods [14e16]. For comparison, the
ligand 7 having a third ester donor was also synthesized according
to the known procedure [17] (Fig. 2).
The ligands 1~7 were examined for ethylene oligomerization in
conjunction with chromium source upon activation with MAO, and
the results are summarized in Table 1.
ꢀ
observed when keeping the reaction temperature at 80 C and
increasing the Al/Cr molar ratio from 600 to 800 (Table 1, entries 3
and 10).
In order to establish the coordination mode of the hetero-
scorpionate ligands, the complexation reaction of carboxyl-
containing 4 with Cr(THF) Cl has been exploitation. The reaction
ꢀ
At 35 bar ethylene and 60 C and in the presence of 600 M excess
3
3
of MAO, all of the Cr precatalysts supported by the dipyrazolyl li-
gands (1~7) were reactive in ethylene oligomerization reaction.
Among the ligands 1~3 bearing a third heteroaryl groups, 3 having
a thiopheneyl group achieved better result, exhibiting the highest
activity with a 55.4% total selectivity toward 1-hexene and 1-octene
3 3
of 4 with Cr(THF) Cl and followed treatment with DMSO led to a Cr
complex 8 (Scheme 2). Single crystals, suitable for X-ray diffraction
study, were obtained by slow evaporation of a DMSO solution of 8,
and the structure is illustrated in Fig. 3, which revealed a HCl
elimination occurred during the complexation reaction. Complex 8
displays a distorted-octahedral geometry, with the Cr atom facially
capped by the anionic tridentate heteroscorpionate ligand and with
coordination of all three donor atoms.
In the previous work of one of our group, treatment of a related
tris(pyrazolyl)methane Cr(III) complex 9 with AlMe3 resulted ul-
timately in reduction to a Cr(II) complex 10 and cation formation
(Scheme 3). The Cr(II) complex, 10, was likely formed through the
methyl-chromium(III) intermediate 11, a methylation product ob-
tained from the reaction of 9 with MAO.
The selective formation of 1-hexene and 1-octene using the Cr
catalysts supported by the bis-pyrazolyl ligands 1~7 could be
explained by the commonly accepted metallacycle mechanism [1a]
(Scheme 4). Based on the previous observation of the formation of
related Cr intermediates 10 and 11, we speculate that upon the
activation of MAO, the Cr catalyst supported by the bis-pyrazolyl
ligand underwent methylation, followed by reduction, and gener-
ating a Cr active intermediate I (Scheme 4). Active Cr species I co-
ordinates with two ethylene molecules, and undergoes oxidative
coupling of them to produce a metallacyclopentane complex III.
Insertion of further ethylene into the metallacyclopentane III pro-
duces larger ring metallacycles. At any point, decomposition of the
metallacycle occurs via the formation of a chromium alkenyl hy-
dride species, which undergoes reductive elimination to product
(Table 1, entries 1e3). Furanyl-containing 2 achieved a highest total
selectivity of up to 68% toward 1-hexene and 1-octene, but gave a
low activity (Table 1, entry 2). It is notable that the Cr catalysts
supported by the ligands 1~3 show much lower selectivities toward
ethylene oligomerization than those bipyrazolyl Cr catalysts
bearing a pyrazolyl, pyridyl, or imidazolyl group, which implies
subtle differences in the ligand structure dramatically influences
the catalytic behavior.
Compared with the hydroxy-containing ligand 5, the carboxyl-
containing ligand 4 exhibited higher activity and similar selec-
tivity toward 1-hexene and 1-octene (Table 1, entries 4 and 5).
Introduction of two phenyl groups in the hydroxy-containing 5
resulted in a dramatic decrease in activity (Table 1, entry 6).
Disappointedly, upon activation with triethylaluminium either the
the corresponding linear a-olefins and the active catalytic species I
again. The selectivity of the transformation is controlled by relative
stability of the different sized metallacycles, which is dramatically
influenced by the supportive ligand.
Scheme 1. Synthesis of bis-pyrazolyl ligands 1~3.