2430
Journal of the American Ceramic Society—Aguilar-Santilla´n et al.
Vol. 85, No. 10
Table II. Density and Porosity of Samples
Sintered at 1600°C
aluminum and silicon ions in and out of the transforming regions
in the parent grains until the chemical composition of mullite is
reached.
Bulk density
(g/cm3)
Open porosity
The attrition-milled kyanite exhibits a very high sinterability.
This is a consequence of the submicrometer particle size of the
milled mineral coupled with the liberation of a silica-rich liquid at
high temperatures. The latter enhances the densification via
liquid-phase sintering. This improved sinterability also contributes
to the reduction of the transformation expansion that is observed in
the dilatometric curves of the attrition-milled kyanite. The high
degree of shrinkage that creates this increased sinterability com-
pensates for the transformation expansion of the kyanite. The
intermediate plateau that appears in the dilatometric curves when
the decomposition of kyanite is complete can be explained by the
formation of mullite and cristobalite as these two phases possess
reduced sintering characteristics at low temperatures.27 Also, the
low-temperature liquid viscosity might have increased signifi-
cantly if it dissolved at least part of the SiO2 expelled during the
decomposition of the kyanite. The presence of TiO2 impurities in
the kyanite can account for the resumption of shrinkage at higher
temperatures, because this oxide favors the formation of a liquid at
a temperature close to 1400°C.20 The consequence is that it is
possible to attain relative densities for kyanite-based ceramics in
excess of 99% by relatively simple and inexpensive ceramic
processing methods based on attrition milling.
Milling time (h)
(%)
As-received, unmilled
1.9
2.8
3.0
3.1
59.3
7.3
4.6
1.9
1
6
12
Attrition milling causes (i) a narrowing of the decomposition
temperature interval of kyanite, (ii) an acceleration of the decom-
position rate of kyanite, (iii) a significant reduction of the volume
expansion associated with the decomposition, and (iv) a greatly
enhanced sinterability. These effects make it possible to obtain
high-density ceramic bodies at relatively low firing temperatures
from kyanite.
The high-energy input of attrition milling is directed toward the
creation of more particle surface area via particle size reduction. It
also creates defects and cracks, as well as extensive deformation of
the crystal lattice, as the XRD peak broadening indicates (Fig. 2).
Several researchers have shown that the decomposition of the
sillimanite minerals starts at the grain surfaces and cracks.13–15
Therefore, it is likely that the attrition milling activates the thermal
decomposition of kyanite, because there is an increased concen-
tration of nucleation sites (particle surface area and cracks) where
mullite formation can initiate. In addition, the growing mullite
grains do not have to maintain a restrictive crystallographic
relationship with other contiguous mullite grains, as is the case
when mullite grows within large grains of kyanite. As a conse-
quence of these factors, the formation rate of mullite is increased
by attrition milling.
The formation of a liquid at high temperatures and changes in
its distribution within the microstructure are additional factors that
help to understand the high mullite formation rate in the attrition-
milled kyanite. The dilatometric curves suggest that a liquid is
formed near 1000°C in the attrition-milled kyanites, as the shrink-
age starts and before the kyanite decomposes. The alkali and the
excess of silica present in the raw kyanite can account for the
formation of this liquid. This primary liquid does not crystallize
during cooling because the XRD patterns of the samples fired
below 1300°C do not have peaks of any crystalline silica. The
lowest liquid formation temperature in the Al2O3–SiO2–Na2O
system is at 1050°C and can be as low as 985°C in the presence of
K2O. Such a liquid can probably activate the formation of mullite
by a solution-precipitation mechanism similar to the one that
operates during the transformation of kaolinite to mullite and
silica.25,26 It is evident that this liquid is more effective in the
attrition-milled kyanites because the solubility of solids in liquids
increases at smaller particle sizes and the solid–liquid interface
reaction area increases.
At higher temperatures, the kyanite decomposes and rejects the
excess silica, part of which might dissolve in the liquid. The XRD
patterns indicate that some of it crystallizes as cristobalite. This
phenomenon is more prevalent when the kyanite particle size is
smaller. Two possible mechanisms could account for the greater
crystallization of cristobalite in the attrition-milled kyanites. First,
a higher density of nucleation sites exists as a result of the smaller
particle size and defects created in the attrition-milled minerals.
Second, the low-temperature liquid may be enriched in silica as the
silica expelled from the kyanite dissolves into it, and this favors the
crystallization of cristobalite.26
V. Conclusions
Attrition milling is an effective process to enhance the thermal
decomposition of kyanite to mullite and silica. The decomposition
temperature interval of attrition-milled kyanite is reduced nearly
100°C relative to that for the as-received mineral. The large
expansion associated with the decomposition of unmilled kyanite
is drastically reduced in kyanite that has been attrition-milled.
Attrition milling also enhances the sinterability as dense glass–
mullite ceramics are formed after firing the attrition-milled
kyanite.
References
1L. Lu and M. O. Lai, Mechanical Alloying; pp. 1–90. Kluwer Academic
Publishers, Dordrecht, Netherlands, 1998.
2K. Izumi, K. Kudaka, D. Maezawa, and T. Sasaki, “Mechanochemical Synthesis
of Chromium Borides,” J. Ceram. Soc. Jpn., 107 [5] 491–93 (1999).
3J. Subrat, L. A. Pe´rez-Maqueda, J. M. Criado, C. Real, J. Boha´cek, and E.
Vecern´ıkova, “Preparation of Nanosized Hematite Particles by Mechanical Activation
of Goethite Samples,” J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 83 [2] 294–98 (2000).
4J. Kano, Y. Yoshizawa, and F. Saito, “Reduction in ␣-Transformation of
Aluminum Hydroxide by Mechanochemical and Seeding Methods,” Ceram. Jpn., 34
[5] 383–87 (1999).
5J. M. Herrera-Ram´ırez, J. G. Caban˜as-Moreno, T. Tsuchiya, M. Umemoto, H.
Balmori-Ram´ırez, and R. Reta-Trigo, “Fe–TiN Composites Prepared by Mechanical
Alloying and Spark Plasma Sintering”; pp. 402–407 in Proceedings of the Powder
Metallurgy World Congress and Exhibition (Granada, Spain, 1998). European
Powder Metallurgy Association, Shrewsbury, England, 1998.
6C. Go´mez-Ya´n˜ez, C. Ben´ıtez, and H. Balmori-Ram´ırez, “Mechanical Activation
of the Synthesis Reaction of BaTiO3 from a Mixture of BaCO3 and TiO2 Powders,”
Ceram. Int., 26 [3] 271–77 (2000).
7H. Balmori-Ram´ırez, E. Torres-Torres, and R. C. Bradt, “Decomposition and
Sintering of Attrition-Milled Andalusite”; pp. 233–47 in Advances in Refractories for
the Metallurgical Industries III. Edited by C. Allaire and M. Rigaud. The Metallur-
gical Society, Montreal, Canada, 1999.
8J. Grofcsik and F. Tamas, Mullite, Its Structure, Formation and Significance; p.
45. Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary, 1961.
9Y. M. Chiang, D. Birnie III, and W. D. Kingery, Physical Ceramics; p. 282.
Wiley, New York, 1997.
10I. Peretz and R. C. Bradt, “Andalusite Derived Mullite-Matrix Refractories”; pp.
613–33 in Ceramic Transactions, Vol. 6, Mullite and Mullite Matrix Composites.
Edited by S. Somiya, R. F. Davis, and J. A. Pask. American Ceramic Society,
Westerville, OH, 1990.
Although liquid also forms in the unmilled kyanite, both at low
temperatures and when the kyanite decomposes, it may be isolated
in small regions within the parent kyanite grains, or expelled and
segregated at the surface. Large kyanite particles do not dissolve in
the liquid as effectively as the small ones. Besides, any isolated
liquid may achieve saturation in a short time and will not
contribute much to the solution-precipitation mechanism. There-
fore, the decomposition of large kyanite grains is slower, because
it relies more on a solid-state diffusion mechanism to transfer the
11H. Schneider, K. Okada, and J. A. Pask, Mullite and Mullite Ceramics; pp.
108–12. Wiley, New York, 1994.
12H. H. Wilson, “Mullite Formation from the Sillimanite Group Minerals,” Am.
Ceram. Soc. Bull, 48 [8] 796–97 (1969).
13D. C. Jain, J. J. Brown Jr., and C. B. Kay, “Study of Thermal Decomposition of
Kyanite Using Density Measurements,” Am. Ceram. Soc. Bull., 53 [9] 650–53 (1974).
14H. Schneider and A. Majdic, “Kinetics and Mechanism of the Solid-State
High-Temperature Transformation of Andalusite (Al2SiO5) into 3/2 Mullite
(3Al2O3⅐2SiO2) and Silica (SiO2),” Ceramurgia Int., 5, 31–36 (1979).