Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
Figure 2. a) Probes optimized for iCP: PSEs 7, 8, and 9. b) In vitro IC50 assays against the chymotrypsin-like (ChTL) b5 activity of human iCP and
cCP after 1 h incubation with various concentrations of PSE 6, 7, 8, and 9 using a luminogenic Suc-LLVY-aminoluciferin substrate assay. The data
were normalized to DMSO-treated controls and are presented as relative activity with standard deviation. c) Time course of the fluorescence
À1
increase when using PSEs 6, 8, and 9 at 1 mm concentration at 308C in the presence of 50 mgmL iCP. It is of note that the reaction between iCP
and the respective PSE does not saturate. The data shown in parts (b) and (c) are depicted as the meanÆSD of triplicates.
convergent synthesis strategy yielded the PSEs 1, 2, and 3
Figure 1). The potency of PSEs 1, 2, and 3 against the
chymotrypsin-like (ChTL) activity of subunit b5c was deter-
similar mechanism is used by fluorescently-quenched activ-
ity-based probes, a variation of activity-based protein profil-
(
[
14]
ing. In this case, a fluorescence-quenching LG is directly
released after protease inactivation, thus retaining the
mined by using a fluorogenic 7-amino-4-methylcoumarin
[15]
(
AMC) substrate assay with purified human cCP. The non-
fluorescent inhibitor bound to the target.
fluorinated PSE 1 and the tri-fluorinated PSE 2 did not block
ChTL activity (IC > 1 mm). Notably, PSE 3 substantially
Based on the aforementioned finding that a pK range
a
between 4 and 6 is favorable, we utilized methylumbellifer-
ones (MU) as small reporter LGs (PSE 4–6, Figure 1). MUs
are easily tuneable in their pKa values through simple
fluorination and are synthetically accessible through Pech-
mann condensation to yield 6-fluoro-4-methylumbelliferone
5
0
inhibited subunit b5c (IC = 1.12 mm, Figure 1 and Figure S1
5
0
in the Supporting Information), but with at least 40-fold
decreased potency compared to its sulfonyl fluoride counter-
part (IC = 0.028 mm). To investigate the binding mode of
5
0
PSE 3 with CP, we soaked Saccharomyces cerevisiae CP
crystals with the compound for X-ray analysis. Structure
elucidation revealed a mechanism analogous to that of
PSFs: 1) After adduct formation at Thr1 through sulfonyl-
ation, the inhibitor is displaced by intramolecular attack of
the amino function in Thr1 to form an aziridine intermediate
(FMU; pK = 6.4) and 6,8-difluoro-4-methylumbelliferone
a
[16]
(DiFMU; pK = 4.7). Additionally, they feature favorable
a
photophysical properties, including a high quantum yield
[8a]
(F = 0.89), linear fluorescence over an appropriate range of
F
concentrations (Figure S3), and high resistance to photo-
[
16]
bleaching . Moreover, MUs and their derivatives are
relatively small in size, which is favorable in view of the
limited space at the proteasomal active site. Conveniently,
DiFMU bound to sulfonate ester groups (DSE) is non-
fluorescent and is widely used in substrate assays for several
(
2.5 ꢀ resolution, Rfree = 21.9%, PDB ID: 5LAI, Figure S2
and Table ST1). 2) Subsequent nucleophilic aziridine-opening
by the base Lys33 results in irreversible crosslinking of the b5
subunit (2.9 ꢀ resolution, Rfree = 20.1%, PDB ID: 5LAJ,
Figure S2 and Table ST1). The structural data thus confirm
release of the PFP LG as an integral part of the inhibition
mechanism. Since the steric requirements are similar for all of
the phenyl systems used here, the increasing potency suggests
[
17]
enzyme classes.
As a control, we prepared the non-
[
16]
fluorinated PSE 4 (MU; pK = 7.8;
Figure 1). The IC50
a
values against purified human cCP were determined by
using a luminogenic aminoluciferin substrate assay, which is
orthogonal in its readout to the released MU fluorophores. In
line with our previous results, PSE 6 with a DiFMU LG was
over 400-times more active (IC = 0.236 mm, Morrison K =
a direct correlation between the pK value of the leaving
a
groups and the reactivity of the electrophiles.
Since the release of the LG is an integral part of the
inhibitory mechanism, this led us to design PSE probes that
emit a signal upon inhibition. To this end, we employed easily
detectable fluorophores as LGs for the quantification of CP
5
0
I
0.062 mm, K as a function of K = 0.18 mm; Figures S4–S6)
I
Obs
than the monofluorinated PSE 5 (IC > 100 mm) and non-
5
0
fluorinated PSE 4 (IC > 1 mm). No inactivation of b1c
5
0
(
PSE 4–6). In contrast to fluorescent assays, in which peptidic
(caspase-like, IC > 1 mm), b2c (trypsin-like, IC > 1 mm),
5
0
5
0
substrates are constantly cleaved, PSE probes would liberate
a single fluorophore molecule per active site upon inhibition.
As such, these probes could be used for the direct estimation
of proteasome activity without downstream analysis. A
or several other proteases was observed (Figure S7). These
findings demonstrate that the designed PSEs require LGs
with a pK less than 5 for inhibition in the nanomolar range.
a
To rank the DSE head group in comparison with other
2
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2016, 55, 1 – 6
These are not the final page numbers!