Angewandte
Chemie
is only an estimate as Pd can also be distributed deep in the
graphitic layers, reducing the effective fraction of “surface
cage” occupation. Comparatively, in a 10 nm nanoparticle,
6% of the Pd atoms would be located on the surface.[8b] From
a thermodynamic point of view, the aggregation of Pd atoms
to form dimers, trimers, or larger clusters is not favored
(Figure S3). Furthermore, considering the low palladium
loading and quite large number of nesting positions, entropic
contributions dominate, clarifying the stability of the atomic
sites. Only at high Pd contents, the six-fold cavities are
saturated with atomic species, and metal agglomeration starts.
This explains, for instance, the presence of nanoparticles of
approximately 3 nm when 20 times higher palladium loadings
were employed and the same preparation procedure was
followed.[6c]
The structure of [Pd]mpg-C3N4 can be compared with that
of three benchmark catalysts that are commercially available
and widely utilized in industry: ligand-modified Pd-
HHDMA/TiS (HHDMA = hexadecyl-2-hydroxyethyl-dime-
thylammonium dihydrogen phosphate), Lindlar-type Pd-Pb/
CaCO3, and Pd/Al2O3 (Figure 1 and Table 1). Although
[Pd]mpg-C3N4 has the same metal loading as Pd-HHDMA/
TiS, the latter material contains particles with an average
diameter of approximately 8 nm deposited on titanium
silicate (SBET = 229 m2 gÀ1). Not all of the surface atoms in
the HHDMA-modified nanoparticles take part in the reac-
tion: In fact, the ligand blocks about 75% of the metal
surface, leading to ensembles with a size of approximately
0.8 nm.[2f] The reference Pd-Pb/CaCO3 catalyst contains
significantly more palladium as well as lead (5 wt% Pd,
3 wt% Pb, surface Pd/Pb ratio = 1.3). The catalyst exhibits
a total area of 10 m2 gÀ1 and a pore volume of 0.03 cm3 gÀ1. The
Pd-Pb nanoparticles are homogeneously distributed over
CaCO3 and have an average diameter of 14 nm (metal
dispersion: 6–8%). Similar to the role of HHDMA, Pb
isolates the Pd sites, leading to ensembles with a size of
approximately 1 nm. Finally, Pd/A2O3 contains uniformly
sized bare palladium nanoparticles with average diameters of
about 3 nm. The particles are deposited on porous alumina
(Vpore = 0.64 cm3 gÀ1) with a total surface area of 170 m2 gÀ1. In
material structure were obtained by X-ray photoelectron
spectroscopy (Figure 2b). A single Pd 3d5/2 binding energy of
335.5 eV, corresponding to Pd0, was observed for Pd-
HHDMA/TiS and Pd/Al2O3. The signal is broader in the
case of Pd-Pb/CaCO3 owing to the presence of Pd2+ Pb
À
species. In contrast, the XPS signal was not very intense for
[Pd]mpg-C3N4, likely because the detection of isolated Pd
species at low concentrations is below the detection limit of
the instrument. Sputtering with an Ar+ beam was conducted
to remove surface layers in a stepwise fashion to gain access to
the bulk composition of the material. In this case, an increase
in the palladium content with depth could be observed
(Figure S6), from a Pd content of 0.15 at.% in the surface to
0.5 at.% in the bulk. This finding confirms that part of the
palladium phase is homogeneously incorporated between the
graphitic layers of the support, in agreement with the DFT
calculations. Furthermore, during sputtering, the Pd 3d5/2 peak
is slightly shifted to higher binding energies (336.4 eV). This
could be due to quantum effects that appear for “particles”
smaller than 2 nm, although a Pd2+ contribution cannot be
excluded.
To illustrate the benefits of single-site catalysis, the
[Pd]mpg-C3N4 catalyst was used for the hydrogenation of 1-
hexyne (Figure 3a), a reference compound that well repre-
sents typical alkynes employed for the manufacture of high-
added-value compounds in the fine chemical and pharma-
ceutical industries. The rate of reaction at 303 K and 1 bar is
three orders of magnitude larger than that of other catalytic
systems (based on Ag, Au, CeO2).[9] This demonstrates that
the single-site catalyst can be applied in the manufacture of
fine chemicals and pharmaceuticals. Furthermore, below
363 K and 2 bar, the selectivity to 1-hexene is nearly 100%,
pointing to the resistance of the material towards the
formation of b-hydrides. These results can be appreciated
when they are compared to the performance of benchmark
Pd-based hydrogenation catalysts (see also Figure S7). For
the hydrogenation of 1-hexyne at 343 K and 5 bar, [Pd]mpg-
C3N4 and Pd-HHDMA/TiS display similar activities (1.41
103 and 1.38 103 molproduct molPdÀ1 hÀ1, respectively) and high
olefin selectivities (90%). In contrast, while the Lindlar
catalyst shows an excellent degree of selectivity to the
À
all these cases, XAS analyses detected only Pd O (1.8–2.0 )
À
and Pd Pd (2.5–2.7 ) bonds (Figure 2a and Figure S4).
terminal
alkene
(90%),
its
activity
(0.34
To confirm the various degrees of metal dispersion in the
four samples, CO chemisorption studies were conducted.
During pulse chemisorption, [Pd]mpg-C3N4 showed no
adsorption of the probe molecules, whereas the other
reference materials showed a quantifiable CO uptake, in
accordance with the degrees of dispersion determined by
microscopy (Table 1). The absence of CO uptake over
[Pd]mpg-C3N4 was confirmed by infrared spectroscopy in
transmission mode (Figure S5). This result indicates that
individual Pd atoms behave differently than those in a conven-
tional nanoparticle, in line with the recent work by Schlçgl
and co-workers.[8c] As the Pd atoms lay below the plane
formed by the six-fold cavities, the cage is enriched in electron
density, and this prevents carbon monoxide from getting close
to the palladium atoms. This shield is very effective, and CO
cannot adsorb (the DFT-calculated adsorption energy is
largely endothermic, by 0.86 eV). Further insights into the
103 molproduct molPdÀ1 hÀ1) is much lower in spite of the high
Pd content (5 wt%). The non-promoted Pd/Al2O3 catalyst is
fairly active (0.96 103 molproduct molPdÀ1 hÀ1), but poorly selec-
tive to the corresponding olefin (69%), yielding various
isomers and the alkane as side products. The resistance of
[Pd]mpg-C3N4 towards metal loss (a possible deactivation
pathway for single-site catalysts) was assessed in a catalytic
run at 343 K and 5 bar for 20 h (Figure 3b). No decrease in
alkyne conversion and alkene selectivity could be observed,
pointing to the absence of any metal aggregates (Figure 3c).
This catalytic performance was confirmed for the hydro-
genation of 2-methyl-3-butyn-2-ol to 2-methyl-3-buten-2-ol
and 3-hexyne to cis-3-hexene, demonstrating the chemo- and
stereoselectivity of the catalyst in alkyne hydrogenation (cis/
trans ratio > 20), and finally applied to the hydrogenation of
nitrobenzene to aniline (Figure S8; see the Supporting
Information for the reaction conditions).
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2015, 54, 11265 –11269
ꢀ 2015 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim