M. Hronec, K. Fulajtarová / Catalysis Communications 24 (2012) 100–104
101
purchased from BASF. The CoMnCr catalyst was prepared according
to the US Patent no. 5 210 335. The resulting solid was calcined at
effect on the distribution of products of furfural hydrogenation.
When water was used as the solvent, the main products were not
products from hydrogenation of the carbonyl group or the furan
ring. Unexpectedly, cyclopentanone was obtained from the furan
ring rearrangement.
5
00 °C in air. Before reaction, the catalyst was activated in hydrogen
atmosphere at 480 °C for 5 h.
2
.3. Catalytic tests
The transformation of furfural to cyclopentanone is the result of
the effect of water, which plays a key role in the ring rearrangement,
whereas it is strongly influenced also by other factors. To avoid the ef-
fect of solubility of reaction products in the aqueous phase, i.e. their
homogeneity, only 2.4–4.8 wt.% solutions of furfural were used for
the reaction. Table 2 shows the effect of heterogeneous metal cata-
lysts on the selectivity of furfural transformation to cyclopentanone
or cyclopentanol, as the product of consecutive hydrogenation of
cyclopentanone. The evaluation of metal catalysts on the basis of
the yields of cyclopentanone was done at two reaction conditions.
As it is evident from experimental results, the influence of reaction
temperature and hydrogen pressure on the yield of cyclopentanone
is significantly different for each catalyst studied. Influenced is also
the ratio of reaction products which are produced by furan ring rear-
rangement and by hydrogenation of the furan ring and the aldehyde
group. For example, at lower reaction temperature and hydrogen
pressure, palladium catalyst affords higher yields of cyclopentanone
than platinum or ruthenium catalysts. However, at higher reaction
temperature and hydrogen pressure the preferred reactions in the
presence of Pd/C catalyst are hydrogenation of the furan ring and
the aldehyde group, while in the presence of Pt and Ru catalysts it is
the furan ring rearrangement. At these reaction conditions and even
Catalytic transformation of furfural was performed in a 100 ml
stainless steel reactor equipped with a stirrer, an electric temperature
controller and a sample port for liquid samples. For a typical reaction,
2
0 ml of water, 1.0 g of furfural and a given amount of metal catalyst
were added to the reactor vessel. After sealing, the reactor was sever-
al times flushed with low pressure hydrogen and then pressurized
with hydrogen, usually to 30–80 bar (at ambient temperature). The
reactor was then heated to the desired temperature and the stirring
speed fixed to 1500 rpm to eliminate the diffusion effects. After an
appropriate reaction time, the reactor was quickly cooled down, the
reactor content was then poured out to a vial and the catalyst was
separated from the aqueous phase by centrifugation. The aqueous
phase was analyzed using gas chromatography (Hewlett Packard
5
890 Series II, with FID detector) with a 1.4 m×3 mm glass column
packed with 5% C20M+5% SE. The quantitative determination of
the reaction products was done by the external standard method
using aqueous solutions of each product with known concentration
and response factor. A gas chromatograph–mass spectrometer combi-
nation (GC/MS QP 5000 Shimadzu with HP-1, 50 m×0.2 mm capil-
lary column) was used to identify the organic compounds. Prior to
GC/MS analysis, the aqueous phase saturated with NaCl was several
in the presence of half
a concentration of platinum catalyst
times extracted with dichloromethane. In selected reaction samples
76.5 mol% yield of cyclopentanone was obtained after 30 min of
reaction.
the presence of cyclopentanone was also verified by the 1H and
13
C
NMR analysis (Varian VNMRS-600) [Supplementary data]. The com-
position of the gas phase was determined using gas chromatography
At the applied reaction temperatures and hydrogen pressures the
keto group of cyclopentanone can be hydrogenated to hydroxyl
group. In the literature there are no published data concerning the
equilibrium concentrations of cyclopentanone–cyclopentanol in the
liquid phase at the conditions of the presented experiments. Some in-
formation about the equilibrium concentrations of the cyclopenta-
none–cyclopentanol mixture in water provides the experiments
with cyclopentanone and cyclopentanol conducted at the tempera-
ture of 175 °C and hydrogen pressure of 30 bar in the presence of Pt
and Ru catalysts (Table 3). From these results it is evident that
under the given temperature and hydrogen pressure the hydrogena-
tion–dehydrogenation equilibrium is shifted toward cyclopentanol.
Although the hydrogenation–dehydrogenation equilibrium is a func-
tion of temperature and hydrogen pressure it is clear that within the
range of our experimental conditions and at reaction time, cyclopen-
tanol and not cyclopentanone should be the dominant product of the
furan ring rearrangement. As it is evident from Fig. 1a, the prolonga-
tion of the reaction time decreases the yield of cyclopentanone and
almost proportionally increases the yield of cyclopentanol. To deter-
mine the accurate reaction time and to avoid the reaction of furfural
during heating of the reaction mixture to the desired temperature
(usually it lasts 15–20 min), in these experiments the catalyst was
(
Shimadzu GC-17A equipped with TC and FID detectors). We found
only trace amounts of carbon oxides, methanol and light hydrocar-
bons in the gas phase. The yields of all reaction products were calcu-
lated on the amount of furfural charged into the reactor. The mass
balance of carbon was estimated as the sum of the yields of products
determined by using standard compounds and unconverted furfural.
The mass loss is ascribed to other not identified compounds analyzed
by GC and mostly to the water soluble oligomers formed during the
reaction.
3
. Results and discussion
Both the gas-phase [3,18] and the liquid phase hydrogenation of
furfural in the absence of solvent [9,10] or in alcohol as solvent [5,6]
lead to the reduction of the C_O group and/or the furan ring. Our
study of the liquid phase hydrogenation of furfural in an aqueous so-
lution has led to the finding that under specific reaction conditions
and the presence of certain heterogeneous metal catalyst furfural
can be converted to cyclopentanone with a very high selectivity.
The results given in Table 1 show that the solvent has significant
Table 1
Effect of solvent on the transformation of furfural.
Solvent
Conversion,
%
Yield, mol%
∑
C
PON
C
POL
FAL
THFAL
2-MeF
2-MeTHF
Water
n-Butanol
n-Butanol/water
100
99.3
99.7
40.23
0.08
10.13
36.23
0.19
2.44
0
0.29
5.87
7.27
5.02
40.43
30.84
9.44
1.85
0
91.15
96.98
51.67
47.86
0.69
(1:1 vol)
n-Decanol
Tetrahydrofuran
94.5
99.4
0.18
0.24
0.13
0.10
26.34
19.28
4.78
4.62
23.17
0
1.09
0
61.10
24.84
Reaction conditions: 1.0 g FA, 0.1 g 5% Pt/C, 20 ml solvent, reaction temperature 175 °C, hydrogen pressure 80 bar, reaction time 30 min; FA — furfural, CPON — cyclopentanone, CPOL
cyclopentanol, FAL — furfuryl alcohol, THFAL — tetrahydrofurfuryl alcohol, 2-MeF — 2-methylfuran, 2-MeTHF — 2-methyltetrahydrofuran, ∑ — the sum of the yields and
unconverted FA.
—