2704
W. Tuo et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 26 (2016) 2701–2705
Table 2
Calculated CLogP values of 10 representative compounds bearing a 3-substituted phenyl ring
Compounds
15
17
21
25
26
28
30
32
38
40
CLogPa
5.73
4.80
6.21
5.72
6.04
6.60
4.92
5.48
4.58
3.71
a
CLogP was calculated by SYBYL-X 2.0 (Tripos).
7.000
6.500
6.000
5.500
5.000
4.500
4.000
3.500
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
3.000
26
25
28
21
15
30
32
38
40
17
Compounds
CLogP
Activity
Figure 3. Lipophilicity–activity relationships of 10 representative compounds bearing a 3-substituted phenyl ring.
group at the 5-position of the terminal phenyl ring of compound 23
brought about an obvious recovery of inhibitory potency to 42%
(24). Moreover, the replacement of the methylene function
appended to the terminal phenyl ring of compounds 26 (69% inhi-
bition) and 28 (63% inhibition) by a carbonyl function led to a sub-
stantial attenuation of the inhibitory activity to 49% (30) and 44%
(32), respectively. Overall, a phenyl group is more favorable than
other aromatic groups (such as pyridinyl, quinolinyl, and furanyl
groups) for the design of FAAH inhibitors. Substituents at position
3 are more favorable than substituents at position 4. Specifically,
acetyl, morpholinomethyl, cyano, methoxy, and 4-methyl-1-piper-
azinylmethyl substituents are preferred rather than a carbamoyl
An investigation of the lipophilicity–activity relationships of
compounds with substituents at the 3-position on the terminal
phenyl ring was performed. Lipophilicity is an important property
in drug discovery and the prediction of bioavailability.27 The loga-
rithm of the octanol/water partition coefficient (LogP) is widely
used to assess the lipophilicity of molecules. In terms of different
calculation rules, LogP values can be calculated by atomic methods
(such as ALogP and XLogP), which consider the contribution of
each atom; fragmental methods (such as CLogP, ACD/LogP and
KowWIN), which consider the contribution of each small fragment
in a molecule; or property-based methods (such as MLogP), which
is based on the three-dimensional (3D) structures of the molecules
and topological approaches.27 Actually, CLogP was identified to
display more accurate prediction of LogP in a wide range of 108
compounds, in comparison with ACD/LogP and KowWIN,28 Hence,
LogP values of our compounds were calculated by CLogP method
(Table 2). As represented in Figure 3, our 5 most potent FAAH inhi-
bitors (15, 21, 25, 26, and 28) possessed high CLogP values ranging
from 5.5 to 6.6. Conversely, compounds with a low FAAH inhibitory
capacity (17, 30, 32, 38, and 40) possessed CLogP values below 5.5.
This result indicates that compounds with substituents at the 3-
position of the terminal phenyl ring conferring higher LogP values
(such as acetyl, methoxy, and cyano group) showed better FAAH
inhibition potency. Hence, the low inhibitory capacity of com-
pound 17 (CLogP = 4.80) with a carbamoyl group might be attrib-
uted to its weak lipophilicity. The replacement of the methylene
linker of compounds 26 (CLogP = 6.04) and 28 (CLogP = 6.60) with
a carbonyl linker (30, CLogP = 4.92, 32, CLogP = 5.48) and the
replacement of the phenyl ring of compound 15 (CLogP = 5.73)
by a pyridine ring (38, CLogP = 4.58) led to a substantial attenua-
tion of the FAAH inhibitory activity probably because of the
decrease of lipophilicity.
group. Notably, compound 15 (IC50 = 0.59
FAAH inhibitory capacity in comparison with compound
(IC50 = 0.46 M), a previously identified potent FAAH inhibitor in
lM) possessed similar
4
l
our group. The replacement of the acetyl group of compound 15
by a cyano group (25) brought about an impressive improvement
of inhibitory potency against FAAH. Compound 25 is approxi-
mately 2 times more potent against FAAH than compounds 4 and
15. This compound manifests a moderate efficacy (maximum effect
that a drug can produce, 64% inhibition at 10
but a good potency (amount required to produce a given effect,
IC50 = 0.24 M). It shows a similar inhibitory potency against FAAH
lM concentrations)
l
than the positive control URB597 (IC50 = 0.26
lM), one of the most
potent FAAH inhibitors to date.
Cytotoxicity of these compounds was determined at 10 lM
using a cell proliferation assay on human colorectal adenocarci-
noma cells HT29 and human embryonic kidney cells HEK293. This
test is based on a colorimetric method, which measures the activity
of cellular enzymes that reduce the tetrazolium dye (MTS, uncol-
ored) to its insoluble formazan giving a purple color. This assay
measures cellular metabolic activity via NADPH-dependent cellu-
lar oxidoreductase enzymes and reflects, under defined conditions,
the number of viable cells. No cytotoxicity was observed for our
new compounds on HT29 cells except for compounds with a piper-
azinyl moiety (28, 29, 32, and 33). These 4 compounds inhibited
also proliferation of HEK293 cells.
In conclusion, a series of new 3-carboxamido-5-aryl-isoxazoles
was designed, synthesized and screened for their inhibitory
potency against FAAH. Their cytotoxicity was determined and their
lipophilicity was calculated. Compounds bearing a 3-substituted
biphenyl moiety with high LogP values displayed a good inhibitory