Journal of the American Chemical Society
Communication
for the cases where Y = OMe at parity for −OR may be
rationalized by stabilization of the [CuOR]2+ core by the
electron-donating methoxide substituent. Monitoring the
room-temperature decays of the four [CuOR]2+ species in
the absence of substrate in THF and DFB revealed
complicated kinetic traces, but trends in the overall lifetimes
paralleled the ttbPhOH reactivity trends (SI; cf. t1/2 ≈ 4 h vs <1
h for LOMeCuOCH2CF3 vs LCuOH in DFB).
from orbitals spanning the Cu center and/or its immediate
environment, as reported for less-reactive complexes LCuZ (Z
= F, Cl, Br).16 Furthermore, the lack of significant structural
changes associated with this redox event agrees with the low
reorganization energy of 0.95 eV previously measured for the
[LHCuOH]−/LHCuOH couple.14
While theoretical calculations support a closed-shell S = 0
ground state for the [CuOH]2+ core (Table S5),8 the only
experimental corroboration has come from a dearth of signal in
the X-band EPR spectrum, an observation consistent with
either the S = 0 or S = 1 ground state. Acquiring NMR spectra,
which would distinguish the two spin states, presents
challenges due to the formation of paramagnetic Cu(II)
decay species. We were nonetheless able to observe sharp
The enhanced stability of the new complexes led us to
attempt characterization by X-ray crystallography. We
discovered that the complex prepared by the treatment of
[NBu4][LOMeCuOH] with FcBArF in DFB could be isolated
4
as suitable deep-purple crystals via the layered diffusion of
pentane at −30 °C. Similar attempts with [NBu4]-
[LYCuOCH2CF3] (Y = H or OMe) failed to give suitable
crystals, likely in part due to the formation of highly intractable
1
peaks in the diamagnetic region of H NMR spectra for both
LYCuOH species in 1,2-dichlorobenzene-d4 at −15 °C (Figure
S28−S29), although broadening due to decomposition was
evident for Y = H. The 1H NMR spectrum of the more robust
complex LHCuOCH2CF3 in THF-d8 at −80 °C (Figure S30)
displayed negligible broadening, but some resonances
were obscured by solvent/byproduct signals. Since
LOMeCuOCH2CF3 could be isolated in neat form as a
crystalline solid, NMR spectra of isolated material were
collected (CD2Cl2, −15 °C), and all expected 1H NMR
resonances and J couplings (Figure 4) as well as 13C{1H}
viscous residues containing [NBu4][BArF ]. To circumvent
4
this issue, we employed reactants that would yield insoluble
inorganic salts as byproducts. Thus, we reacted LCu-
(CH3CN)4 and LOMeCu(CH3CN) with NaOCH2CF3 and
then oxidized the resulting crude materials with AcFcSbF6 in
CH2Cl2 or DFB. After the removal of a light-colored
precipitate (presumably NaSbF6), suitable crystals of the
oxidized products were obtained at −30 °C.
Representations of the X-ray structures of LOMeCuOH and
LOMeCuOCH2CF3 (Figure 3) as well as LHCuOCH2CF3
Figure 3. Representations of the X-ray structures of (a) LOMeCuOH
and (b) LOMeCuOCH2CF3, showing all nonhydrogen atoms as 50%
thermal ellipsoids.
1
Figure 4. H NMR spectrum of LOMeCuOCH2CF3 (CD2Cl2, −15
°C).
(Figure S42) show similar square-planar geometries compared
to their [CuOR]+ progenitors (τ4 = 0.11−0.15), but they are
neutral species as expected for one-electron oxidation
products. Comparison of metal−ligand bond distances
between the oxidized and reduced forms (Table 1) indicates
in all but one case shortening upon oxidation, by as much as
0.127 Å. The average Cu−N/O bond contraction in
LOMeCuOH, 0.102 Å, is in excellent agreement with previously
reported EXAFS analyses of LHCuOH (0.1 Å).8 The
trifluoroethoxides show somewhat less contraction and in
LOMeCuOCH2CF3 the Cu−O bond even lengthens slightly, by
0.011 Å, but disorder in the trifluoroethoxide ligand imparts an
inherent inaccuracy to the O atom’s position. Gas-phase
geometry optimizations (SI) for the S = 0 ground states of the
oxidized species are in excellent agreement with the
experimentally determined values (theory in Table 1). Overall,
the bond length differences between the precursor and
oxidation products are consistent with the loss of an electron
NMR peaks (Figure S32) were observed. The sharpness of the
1
observed H and 13C{1H} NMR features in the diamagnetic
chemical shift region confirms an S = 0 ground state, in
agreement with predictions.8
In conclusion, we prepared and characterized a new set of
complexes with [CuOR]+/2+ cores using a modified supporting
ligand and/or core (R = CH2CF3). Both changes attenuate the
PCET reactivity of the oxidized state, the former by lowering
its oxidizing potential and the latter by lowering the basicity of
the proton-accepting site. While each modification has the
opposite effect on the opposite property (e.g., the less-basic
proton acceptor also leads to a more oxidizing species), the
dominant impact is on electronics for the supporting ligand
and basicity for the core, in line with previously observed
reactivity trends and demonstrating how PCET reactivity can
be tuned. These stabilization effects were sufficient to permit,
for the first time, the successful characterization of complexes
with [CuOR]2+ cores by X-ray crystallography and NMR
3297
J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2021, 143, 3295−3299