Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
Strong Acids
1,1,3,3-Tetratriflylpropene (TTP): A Strong, Allylic C–H Acid for
Brønsted and Lewis Acid Catalysis
Denis Hçfler, Manuel van Gemmeren, Petra Wedemann, Karl Kaupmees, Ivo Leito,
Markus Leutzsch, Julia B. Lingnau, and Benjamin List*
Abstract: Tetratrifylpropene (TTP) has been developed as
a highly acidic, allylic C–H acid for Brønsted and Lewis acid
catalysis. It can readily be obtained in two steps and
consistently shows exceptional catalytic activities for
Mukaiyama aldol, Hosomi–Sakurai, and Friedel–Crafts acy-
lation reactions. X-ray analyses of TTP and its salts confirm its
designed, allylic structure, in which the negative charge is
delocalized over four triflyl groups. NMR experiments, acidity
measurements, and theoretical investigations provide further
insights to rationalize the remarkable reactivity of TTP.
carbon allows the introduction of up to three electron-
withdrawing groups, the negative charge can be more
extensively delocalized in C–H acids than in O–H and N–H
acids, resulting in higher acidity of the former.
To increase the number of electron-withdrawing groups
beyond three, vinylogous acids can be designed and synthe-
sized. Inspired by the work of R. Kuhn and others,[9,10] we
were intrigued in assessing an allylic C–H acid carrying four
triflyl groups. This resulted in the design and development of
tetratriflylpropene (TTP, Scheme 1), which we present herein.
Strong organic acids and their salts are of fundamental
importance as charge carriers in fuel cells (e.g. electrolytes),
as stabilizers of highly reactive species, and as reagents or
catalysts in chemical synthesis.[1] Developing a strong organic
acid fundamentally means designing the corresponding
anion: its negative charge should be as delocalized as possible
to reduce its basicity. The most successful strategy to reducing
anion basicity involves the utilization of strongly electron-
withdrawing groups,[1a,2] among which the trifluoromethane-
sulfonyl (triflyl or Tf) group is particularly powerful and
frequently used.[3] Introducing triflyl groups to organic
molecules increases the acidity of the neighboring a-hydro-
gens, an effect that rises with the number of triflyl groups. As
a result, the maximum possible number of triflyl groups often
confers highest acidity to a molecule.[3b,4] Examples for strong
acids containing triflyl moieties are triflic acid (TfOH),[5]
triflimide (Tf2NH),[6] and tris(triflyl)methane (Tf3CH)[7] with
pKa values (in dichloroethane, relative to picric acid) of À11.4
(TfOH), À11.9 (Tf2NH), and an estimated À16.4 (Tf3CH).[1b]
Triflimide and to a lesser extent also tris(triflyl)methane have
been employed in Lewis and Brønsted acid catalysis, either in
their protonated form, silylated, or as salts.[8] The observed
Scheme 1. Design of tetratriflylpropene (TTP).
The anion of TTP was designed to be highly symmetric
and such that the negative charge can be delocalized over four
triflyl groups, each containing two oxygens (leading to a total
of eight conjugated oxygen atoms). In comparison to Tf3CH,
the scaffold of our allylic C–H acid is expanded by two carbon
atoms. The four CF3 groups of TTP are also presumed to
stabilize the anion through their field-inductive properties.
The high stabilization of the anion should minimize its Lewis
basicity thereby limiting protonation and coordination to
Lewis acids and increasing the Brønsted acidity of TTP.
In analogy to our previous synthesis of chiral allyltetra-
sulfones,[11] TTP can readily be obtained via a two-step
synthesis (Scheme 2) starting from commercially available
bistriflylmethane (1). Disulfone 1 is first converted essentially
quantitatively to enol ether 2,[11] which is then treated with
bistriflylmethane (1) and TMP base (solution of 2,2,6,6-
tetramethylpiperidinylmagnesium chloride lithium chloride
complex) to give the TMP·TTP salt 3. While ammonium salt 3
could be conveniently isolated, finding suitably acidic con-
ditions to obtain pure and reasonable quantities of TTP
proved to be rather challenging. All tested aqueous acids and
many organic acid solutions gave none or only traces of TTP.
Finally, we found that satisfying amounts of clean TTP could
be obtained upon workup with pure concentrated sulfuric
acid. Isolated in pure form, TTP is very hygroscopic and
readily decomposes in the presence of water. Both salt 3 and
TTP could be crystallized successfully and their crystal
structures are shown as ORTEP drawings (Scheme 2).
À
pKa trend is remarkable, as C H bonds are often intrinsically
unpolarized and proton dissociation is usually less facile than
À
À
that of O H and N H bonds. However, as the tetravalency of
[*] D. Hçfler, P. Wedemann, Dr. M. Leutzsch, J. B. Lingnau,
Prof. Dr. B. List
Max-Planck Institut fꢀr Kohlenforschung
Kaiser-Wilhelm-Platz 1, 45470 Mꢀlheim an der Ruhr (Germany)
E-mail: list@kofo.mpg.de
Dr. M. van Gemmeren
Westfꢁlische Wilhelms-Universitꢁt Mꢀnster
Correnstrasse 40, 48149 Mꢀnster (Germany)
Dr. K. Kaupmees, Prof. Dr. I. Leito
University of Tartu, Institute of Chemistry
Ravila 14a, Tartu 50411 (Estonia)
Supporting information for this article can be found under:
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2016, 55, 1 – 6
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
1
These are not the final page numbers!