NoN-Noble Metals iN Catalysis
CHIMIA 2020, 74, No. 6 485
Fig. 3. Conversion profile for the hydrosilylation of different 4-substituted
benzaldehydes with complex 1b.
Fig. 4. Linear correlation of the Hammett parameter (σP) with turnover
frequency at 50% conversion (TOF50), TOF50 = –488σp + 197, R2 = 0.98.
Table 3. Substrate scope for hydrosilylation with complex 1b.a
turnover numbers and frequencies of hydrosilylation using 4-anis-
aldehyde as the substrate. When using 2 mol% of the catalyst pre-
cursor 1b, the reaction is completed at 40 °C within 12 min (Table
4, entry 1). This reactivity is three times faster when compared
to runs using unsubstituted benzaldehyde as substrate (Table 3,
entry 4). Quantitative formation of the product alcohol was al-
so observed upon reducing the loading of complex 1b to 1 and
0.5 mol%, although reaction times were slightly longer to reach
completion under these conditions (14 and 18 min, respective-
ly, entries 2 and 3). The reaction time is considerably shortened
when the reaction temperature was increased to 60 °C, affording
full conversion within 6 min with 2 mol% loading of complex 1b
(entry 4). Successively decreasing of the precatalyst to 0.02 mol%
does not compromise the yield of the reaction (entries 5−10). Full
conversion at this low loading implies turnover numbers as high
as 5,000, and maximum turnover frequencies of 27,000 h−1 (entry
10). When the loading of complex 1b was lowered even further to
0.01 mol%, conversions were incomplete even when the reaction
was run for extended periods of time, yet these conditions allowed
to determine the maximum turnover number TON = 7,400 (60
min, 63%; entry 11). In the absence of nickel complex 1b no con-
version was detected also at these slightly elevated temperatures
(entry 12).
The TOFmax values accomplished with complex 1b are higher
than other known nickel-based hydrosilylation catalyst with[10] or
without a NHC ligand,[11,12] and similar to those of the best-per-
forming iron complexes,[13] yet about two-times lower when com-
pared to the best-performing manganese-based catalyst.[14] The
high catalytic performance of 1b in terms of turnover numbers and
frequencies suggests a marked influence imparted by chelation
of the triazolylidene ligand when bound to nickel. Its key role is
confirmed when comparing complex 3 as the best nickel catalyst
reported so far with the Ni-O(NHC) system 1b (Fig. 5). Under the
same catalytic conditions, the O-chelated nickel complex 1b out-
performs the N-chelated system 3 and reaches higher TON (7,400
vs 5,500) and higher TOF50 values (27,000 vs 23,000 h–1).[10]
OH
O
1) 1b, PhSiH3
H
H
2) NaOH
R
R
entry R–PhCHO time
conv yield
TOF50
[h–1]
σp
[min] [%]b [%]c
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
4-NMe2
4-OMe
4-Me
4-H
6
99
98
99
97
98
96
98
13
95
95
96
95
93
92
92
n.d.
-0.83 730
-0.27 340
-0.17 210
12
30
36
0.00
0.06
0.23
0.54
0.78
150
95
32
6
4-F
48
4-Br
120
180
180
4-CF3
4-NO2
n.d.
aReactions were carried out with benzaldehyde (0.5 mmol), PhSiH3
(0.6 mmol) and complex 1b (2 mol%) in 1,2-dichloroethane (0.4 mL)
with C6Me6 (0.05 mmol) as internal standard at 40 °C; bconversion
determined by 1H NMR spectroscopy. cYield determined by 1H NMR
spectroscopy after treatment with NaOH (1 M) in MeOH; n.d. = not
determined.
Comparison of the reaction rates as TOF50 values with the
Hammett parameter σp shows an inverse correlation, with a lower
Hammett parameter inducing faster turnover (Fig. 4). The correla-
tion is satisfactory (R2 = 0.98) and the considerable slope suggests
a strong influence of the substituent’s electronic properties on the
reaction rate, which provides a rationale also for the very low
conversion of nitrobenzaldehyde (Table 3, entry 8). The inverse
correlation between the Hammett parameter (σp) and the turnover
frequency indicates that positive charge is built up in the transi-
tion state. This observation is reminiscent of related carbene Cp
nickel complexes and consistent with a turnover-limiting step that
involves a hypervalent Si centre.[10] Notably, acetophenone is not
a suitable substrate for hydrosilylation with nickel complex 1b
and essentially no conversion was observed even after 3 h. The
low activity of these complexes toward ketone hydrosilylation in-
dicates a clear selectivity for aldehydes vs ketones, which may be
attractive in multifunctional substrates.
2.2 Stoichiometric Experiments
In order to better understand the observed activities of cata-
lyst 1b and more generally the potential role of oxygen chelation
during hydrosilylation, a set of stoichiometric experiments was
performed. Adding a slight excess (1.2 equiv) of phenylsilane to
complex 1b in a CD2Cl2 solution containing SiMe as an internal
standard resulted in an immediate change in colour4of the solution
1
and different sets of new signals appeared in the H NMR spec-
trum, suggesting the formation of new species. The resonances
of complex 1b disappeared and no triazolium salt formation was
detected, while two singlets appeared in the hydride region at δ
= –7.19 and –8.21 ppm in a 1:1 relative ratio and accounting foHr
The catalytic potential of complex 1b was further investigated
by variation of the catalyst loading in order to identify maximum