Pharmaceutical Research, Vol. 17, No. 3, 2000
Research Paper
appeared to occur; however, with the sucrose system, the origi-
nal white cake became progressively colored and eventually
collapsed to a very small volume. Based on previously reported
studies with acidic solutions of sucrose (1), and particularly
with freeze-dried sucrose at acidic pH conditions and in the
presence of residual water (2–4), it was concluded that sucrose
most likely had undergone acid-catalyzed inversion to glucose
and fructose, both reducing sugars. The coloration during this
process was believed to be the result of additional reactivity
between the drug and reducing sugars that produced non-enzy-
matic browning (5,6). The acidity needed to catalyze this reac-
tion most likely came from the acidic nature of the drug.
That such a reaction can occur in the presence of acidic
species for amorphous sucrose at low levels of water, as most
likely observed above, was shown by Karel & Labuza with
lyophilized formulations of sucrose, citric acid, and microcrys-
talline cellulose stored at 55ЊC with a water content as low
as 0.22% w/w, in the weight ratio of sucrose:microcrystalline
Acid-Catalyzed Inversion of Sucrose
in the Amorphous State at Very Low
Levels of Residual Water
Evgenyi Y. Shalaev,1 Qun Lu, Maria Shalaeva,
,2
3
1,2
and George Zografi1
,4
Received July 28, 1999; accepted December 7, 1999
Purpose. Factors affecting the solid-state acid-catalyzed inversion of
amorphous sucrose to glucose and fructose in the presence of colyophi-
lized citric acid, with less than 0.1% w/w residual water, have been
studied.
Methods. Samples of citric acid and sucrose were lyophilized at a
weight ratio of 1:10 citric acid:sucrose from solutions with initial pH
values of 1.87, 2.03, and 2.43, as well as at a weight ratio of 1:5, at
an initial pH of 1.87. Glass transition temperatures, Tg, were measured cellulose:citric acid of 30:2:1 (6). In the absence of citric acid
by DSC and the presence of any possible residual water was monitored negligible reaction took place at 55ЊC over the same time period.
by Karl Fischer Titrimetry. The inversion of sucrose was measured by It was concluded that at amounts of residual water well below
polarimetric analysis after reconstitution of solid samples stored at
the so-called “BET-monolayer” level, as estimated from water
5
2 5
0ЊC under P O .
vapor sorption isotherms (7), water still played an important
role in the reaction mechanism. How this might occur at such
low levels, and how citric acid might be mechanistically
involved was not considered further.
Results. Samples of 1:10 citric acid:sucrose at an initial pH of 1.87,
.03, and 2.43 exhibited the same Tg. The initial rate of reactivity was
2
affected at a 1:10 ratio by the solution pH before lyophilization in the
order: 1.87 Ͼ 2.03 Ͼ 2.43 and by citric acid concentration at pH 1.87
in the order 1:5 Ͼ 1:10.
Water in such an amorphous system can be expected to
Conclusions. Sucrose, colyophilized with an acid such as citric acid, have at least 3 important functions in this reaction. It can act
undergoes significant acid-catalyzed inversion at 50ЊC despite the very as a reactant, as a plasticizer to increase molecular mobility
low levels of residual water, i.e., Ͻ0.1% w/w. At the same ratio of and as a medium supporting acid-base reactions involved in
citric acid to sucrose (1:10), and hence the same Tg, the rate of reaction
correlates with the initial solution pH indicating that the degree of
ionization of citric acid in solution is most likely retained in the solid
not have expected that such an extensive chemical change could
state. That protonation of sucrose by citric acid is important is shown
by the direct relationship between maximum extent of reaction and
citric acid composition. It is concluded that colyophilization of acidic
substances with sucrose, even in the absence of residual water, can
produce reducing sugars capable of further reaction with other formula- even in the presence of 0.1–0.2% water, storage at 50ЊC would
the overall chemical mechanism (8). Given the very low levels
of water in our system, Ͻ0.1%, relative to sucrose, one might
occur due to reaction with water over a relatively short time
period, i.e., 2–4 weeks at around 50ЊC. Given that amorphous
sucrose has a glass transition temperature of about 74ЊC (9),
tion ingredients susceptible to reaction with reducing sugars.
be at a temperature well below the glass transition temperature,
Tg, (spirapril HCl has a Tg of about 85ЊC and would be expected
to slightly raise the Tg in a mixture with sucrose (10)). Thus,
we would not expect a significant role of water at such low
levels as a plasticizer. This suggests that “pH” effects at such
low levels of water in these systems are most likely the most
important factors. This suggestion is supported by the work of
Richards who reported studies on the thermal degradation of
sucrose in the melt over the temperature range of 120ЊC to
KEY WORDS: amorphous; sucrose; acid-catalyzed; residual water;
solid-state degradation.
INTRODUCTION
During the course of carrying out experiments with rela-
tively dry (Ͻ0.1% w/w water) freeze-dried amorphous mixtures
of an organic drug molecule, spirapril HCl, (1,4diatha-7-
azaspirol[4,4]nonane-8-carboxylic acid, 7-[2[[1-ethoxycarbo-
nyl)-3-phenylpropylamino]-1-oxopropyl]-monohydrochloride)
and either sucrose or trehalose in a 1:10 weight ratio of drug
to sugar, certain interesting observations were made after storing
these samples at 50ЊC for up to about one month. In the case of
the trehalose system, no apparent physical or chemical changes
180ЊC for a period of about 400 minutes in the complete absence
of water (11). It was concluded that traces of initial degradation
reactions produced acidic substances, such as acetic, formic, and
levilinic acids, which in turn protonated sucrose and facilitated
degradation. Thus, it seems reasonable that in the present case
the role of any acid present might be enough to explain the
results of studies carried out in the range of 50Њ–55ЊC in the
absence of any significant amounts of water, if there was suffi-
cient molecular mobility of sucrose and acid at the temperature
of the reaction.
1
School of Pharmacy, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 425 N. Char-
ter St., Madison, Wisconsin 53706.
Present address: Pfizer, Inc., Groton, Connecticut.
Present address: Pharmacia & Upjohn, Co., Kalamazoo, Michigan.
To whom correspondence should be addressed. (e-mail: catalyzed inversion at 50ЊC under the conditions of very low
2
3
To examine the tendencies of sucrose to undergo acid-
4
gzografi@facstaff.wisc.edu)
water content and to examine the role of any acid present,
0
724-8741/00/0300-0366$18.00/0 ᭧ 2000 Plenum Publishing Corporation
366