1
80
S.S. Laev, V.D. Shteingarts / Journal of Fluorine Chemistry 96 (1999) 175±185
with benzene, and the solubility factor are responsible for
the observed polyde¯uorination. The same is probably true
for the more facile de¯uorination of poly¯uoroarene func-
tional derivatives as compared with per¯uoroarenes.
Clearly, the addition of organic solvents to aqueous ammo-
nia considerably diminishes the role of the solubility factor,
thus facilitating the reaction. The ammonia concentration
in¯uence is most likely associated with the electron extrac-
tion rate from the metal as depending both on the activation
of the zinc surface and the solvation of the ensuing zinc
cation, thus affecting the redox potential of the zinc.
In the framework of the mechanistic concept outlined
above, the regioselectivity of this process should be
undoubtedly assigned to the fragmentation of poly¯uoroar-
ene RAs. According to rationalization based on a pseudo-
Scheme 12.
of RA with the removal of ¯uoride ion to produce an aryl
radical [12], its reduction and ®nal protonation of the
ensuing aryl anion (Scheme 12).
The elimination of ¯uoride ion from poly¯uoroarene RAs
generally proceeds quite fast and is unlikely to be the rate
limiting stage. This is con®rmed by the high fragmentation
rate constants of RAs of poly¯uorinated benzonitriles in
DMF [24], penta¯uoroacetophenone, penta¯uorobenzalde-
3
� 1
hyde (ꢂ10 s ), penta¯uorophenol, penta¯uoroaniline
6
� 1
[
H O. However, the lifetime of a RA tightly associated with
25] and poly¯uorinated benzoates [19] (ꢂ10 s ) in
*
Jahn±Teller effect [27], the decrease in the ꢀ±s energy gap,
2
a positive hole on the zinc surface could be much longer
than for a free RA in the solution. On the contrary, the low
solubility of an aromatic compound, which is typical for the
aqueous medium, can considerably slow down the reduc-
tion. Finally, electron extraction from zinc to form a RA is
probably the slow step that is suggested by the relatively
long duration of hydrode¯uorination of 1, 3, 11 and 12 in
this study, of some poly¯uoroaromatics by Zn(Cu) in DMF±
brought about by the multiple ¯uorine substitution, is
favorable for the pseudo-ꢀ-state of poly¯uoroarene RAs
with both the out-of-plane deviation of a C±F bond and the
fragmentation rate through a certain position being con-
trolled to a ®rst approximation by the energy gap between
*
the ꢀ-state, inherent in a planar RA, and the s -state of RA
with an odd electron density located mainly on a C±F bond
to be broken. This criterion is most favorable for a position
with the maximum spin density. The ESR spectra of RAs of
19 [28] and 9 [29] show that the principal electron density is
located just on the carbon atom para to a position with no
¯uorine, in agreement with the regioselectivity observed in
the hydrode¯uorination of these compounds. On the basis of
ESR spectra of poly¯uorinated benzonitrile RAs with ¯uor-
ine in the para position [30], the same should be expected
for penta¯uorobenzonitrile RA. For other poly¯uoroben-
zene derivatives under study (compounds 1, 3, 5, 7, 16, and
22) there is a lack of ESR data, but, nevertheless, there is no
doubt that their RAs should have the electron structure
which provides the observed regioselectivity. The INDO/
UHF calculations predict an odd electron in planar RAs of
19, 9, and penta¯uorobenzonitrile [27,30,31] to occupy the
b1-type (in terms of C2v group) ꢀ-MO located primarily in
the para and ipso positions.
H O [7,8] and of 1 by zinc in aqueous alkali [10] or liquid
2
NH [11], in spite of the absence of a dissolving problem. It
3
seems unlikely in this connection that the electron passes
out from metallic zinc into a solution, as in liquid ammonia
the blue color typical for solvated electrons is not observed
and the reduction process is prolonged to yield selectively a
monode¯uorination product, unlike the fast and deep
de¯uorination with removal of three or more ¯uorine atoms
observed with sodium [11]. In this connection, it is con-
ceivable that electron capture by poly¯uoroarene occurs
directly from the metal surface. Overall, the results with
compounds 1, 2 and 3 con®rm that the electron passing from
zinc into solution is not responsible for their reductive
de¯uorination, otherwise all the substrates and their de¯uor-
�
ination products, trapping e at practically the same rate
aq
constant [26], should undergo ¯uorine removal. The rate of
the substrate reaction with the metal to give a RA is
probably controlled by the substrate redox potential and,
since the removal of a halogen atom renders the redox
potential as a rule more negative [12,24], a monodehalo-
genation product is reduced more slowly than the starting
compound. Evidently, under the conditions used in most
cases the threshold of substrate ability for the electron
extraction from zinc, suf®cient for the reaction to proceed,
lies between a starting poly¯uoroarene and its monode¯uor-
ination product providing the observed monode¯uorination
selectivity. By contrast, the solubility of a monode¯uori-
nated product seems unlikely to be much lower as compared
with the starting compound and to account for this selec-
tivity. Evidently, for poly¯uorosubstituted naphthalene and
biphenyl derivatives both the higher electron af®nities,
inherent in the respective aromatic systems as compared
The ESR data for the RA of 20 [32] testify that the
electron density is greater in the a positions, while the
difference as compared with the b positions is not large.
Thus, the observed selective ¯uorine removal from the b
positions in the course of the reaction of 20 with zinc in
aqueous ammonia does not correspond to these data. Per-
*
haps, the involvement of an excited ꢀ -state with the
principal electron density located in the b positions, rather
than of a ground ꢀ-state, in the pseudo-Jahn±Teller inter-
action, takes place upon the greater out-of-plane deviation
and stretching of C±F bonds inherent in a transition state.
Also the presence of two neighboring ¯uorine atoms is
possible to facilitate the elimination of a ¯uorine atom from
the b position of RAs of 20 and 2-H-hepta¯uoronaphtha-
lene. Such an in¯uence of neighboring ¯uorine atoms on the
RA stability was noted for poly¯uorobenzoates [19]. The