J.E. Varghese et al.
Chemical Physics Letters 761 (2020) 138014
energy 1065.87 kJ/mol is found to be the most important highest energy
interaction. The large value of the interaction energies (49.45 kJ/mol)
1
π
|∇
ρ
ρ
(r)
(r) |
RDG(r) =
(7)
4/3
2
(3
2)1/3
corresponding to n3 (Cl25) →
interactions within 4MBAC. In this system stabilization occurs by
intermolecular interactions of orbital overlap among and * orbitals,
13), (C 10) and
13) and *(C
10) which results in intermolecular
σ
* (O22 H23) is due to the charge transfer
–
where
point r, can be used to examine weak interactions in real space based on
the electron density. RDG and sign (λ are two important functions
which are together employed in non covalent interactions method (NCI)
38]. Sign (λ is the sign of the second largest eigen value of electron
density Hessian matrix at position r.
gives information about the nature and
ρ
(r) is the electron density and ∇
ρ
(r) is the gradient of
ρ
(r) at the
π
π
8
π
(C
*(C
5
–
5
C
6
) and
π
*(C
(C
(C11
8
–
C
10),
10) and
13) and
π
(C
*(C11
*(C
5
–
C
–
C
6
) and
13),
π
*(C11
–
C
π
–
C
2
)
ρ
π
–
C
6
),
π
8
–
–
C
π
C
π
(C11
–
C
π
5
–
C )
6
as well as
π
C
π
–
8
[
2
)
ρ
charge transfer (ICT). Since ICT makes molecule more polarized, it adds
to the enhanced NLO properties of molecule [36].
The RDG(r) versus sign (λ ρ
2
)
strength of the interactions analysed using RDG surfaces. Strong
4
.5. Hirshfeld surface analysis
attractive interactions such as dipole–dipole or H-bonding interactions
are characterised by large negative values of sign (λ
2
) , while strong
ρ
Hirshfeld surface analysis can be used to quantitatively depict the
repulsion interactions like steric interactions are characterised by large
positive values of sign (λ . Vander Waals interactions are identified
with values close to zero. The plot for 4MBAC as shown in Fig. 10(a)
shows two peaks with sign (λ close to zero, which is due to the Vander
Waal’s attraction produced by the Cl25… .… H12 interaction, as evident
from the Hirshfeld finger print plots. Two sharp spikes in the sign (λ
positive region corresponds to the strong hydrogen/halogen bond
attraction involving O22 21 and Cl25 23 interactions. The major
contribution of the positive sign (λ values come from the benzene
C, H H and C H interactions. Visualisation of the RDG isosurface
intermolecular interactions in 4MBAC [37]. Hirshfeld surface has been
mapped from dnorm, d , d , surface index and curvedness. The transparent
2
)
ρ
i
e
surface as shown in Fig. 8 allows determining the orientation and in-
teractions of the functional group inside the surface. The circular deep
2
)
ρ
red colour indicates the hydrogen bond contacts due to N
H… Cl, O H… Cl and N H… Cl inter molecular interactions and
other spots are due to H H contacts [39].
–
H … O,
2
)
ρ
C
–
–
–
–
–
H
–
H
The 2D finger print plots measure inter and intra molecular contacts
experienced by the molecules in the crystal. The total Hirshfeld surface
area of the molecule is shown in Fig. 9(a).
2
)
ρ
C
–
–
–
for 4MBAC was Multiwfn 3.6 package and was plotted by the VMD
program [41,42]. Color indices from blue to red for stronger attractive
interactions to stronger repulsion interactions, is employed in the visu-
alization of the gradient isosurface. The 3D RDG isosurfaces of 4MBAC at
the B3LYP/cc-pVTZ) level is showed in Fig. 10(b), which clearly depicts
the nature and strength of the interactions present.
The H-H interactions in Fig. 9(b) covered most area in the 2D
fingerprint plots which covers 52.2% of the total Hirshfeld surface while
the C-H interaction as shown in Fig. 9(c) contributes to 16.3% to the
total Hirshfeld surfaces. The sharpest spike in the finger print plots is due
to O… .… H/H...O contacts as seen in Fig. 9(d) with a significant
contribution of 7.3%. This mapping dnorm indicates the O...H contacts of
the water molecule with two ammonium anions and two Chlorine cation
with ionic distances 1.894 Å, 1.820 Å, 1.836 Å and 2.057 Å respectively,
that are within the Van der Waals radii, which shows that the O...H
interactions are prominent in 4MBAC. Two other sharp peaks are
visualised in the 2D finger plots due to the H...Cl/Cl...H contacts with
contribution of 24.0%, which indicates the interaction of the chlorine
cation with the water molecule with ionic distance 2.141 Å, with two
ammonium cations with ionic distances 2.145 Å and with H12 atom with
4
.7. AIM analysis
The electron densities at the bond critical points (BCP) were
analyzed using the atoms in molecules (AIM) approach using the
AIMALL package [41] and the various Bond critical points and ring
critical points were identified as shown in Fig. 11(a).
The theory of atoms in molecule (AIM) measures the strength of the
intermolecular hydrogen bond and is analysed using the values of
distance 2.805 Å. Thus the C11
–
H
12....Cl25 exhibits itself as a weak van
2
electron density (
ρ
), their Laplacians (∇
ρ
(r)
) and total electronic en-
(
r)
der waals interaction [40].
ergy density (H) at the Bond Critical Points (BCPs) [43].
2
The positive values of both Laplacians, ∇
ρ
and H at their critical
(r)
4
.6. Reduced density gradient (RDG) analysis
points as shown in Table S2, for the H12
–
Cl25 interaction with H value=
2
+
0.000996 and ∇
ρ
=+0.020193, clearly implies that an electrostatic
(r)
The Reduced Density gradient given by the equation
type of interaction exists between them, which is in accordance with the
2
results of the Hirshfeld analysis [44]. The values of ∇
critical points H21 Cl25 and H20
interactions are also prominent within the structure. The relief map in
Fig. 11(b) shows the Laplacian electron density in N18 22 plane
which indicates the concentration of charge on and around the water
molecule. The O22 24 bonds show maximum electron density and
charge transfer which exceeds all other regions.
ρ
and H at the
(r)
–
O
22, H23
–
–
Cl25 shows that shared
21
H O
– –
–
H
4
.8. Molecular docking studies
Molecular docking is a very powerful tool to predict the preferred
orientation and interaction of a ligand to a macromolecule when bound
to each other to form a stable complex in three-dimensional space
[
45,46]. The docking procedure identifies the most energetically
favourable conformation of ligands in the binding pocket of a protein
and predicts the affinity between the ligand and protein.
Quaternary ammonium compounds and benzylamines being highly
important building blocks in pharmaceutical and polymer industry, the
anticancer, antibacterial, antifungal, anticoagulant docking activity was
tested for proteins following literature survey. 5 cancer targets CDK2,
CHK2,1HSG,CHK1, 1W6R, 5 antibacterial targets 3FCD, 3M8W, COX2,
Fig. 8. Hirshfeld dnorm surfaces for 4MBAC showing interaction distances.
8