Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
the amido group in 7 must have been transformed into an
Examination of energy differences at various computational
imido group, and the simplest way to achieve this trans-
formation is a tautomeric equilibrium between the imido and
amido groups as shown for oxo/hydroxo derivatives.[13] With
such a process going on, the eventual labeling of the product
in the two reactions is dependent on the kinetic competition
between the proton exchange and the nitrene transfer.
Indeed, as shown by UV/Vis experiments the intramolecular
nitrene transfer to the benzyl group occurs on the minute time
scale, slow enough to allow for the tautomeric equilibrium to
be fully established explaining that both 14NTs and 15NTs
groups are transferred equally. By contrast, the nitrene
transfer to thioanisole occurs in the millisecond time scale,
faster than the proton exchange, explaining that only the
labeled nitrene 15NTs group is transferred since the tauto-
meric equilibrium has not yet progressed.
levels pointed to only two low energy geometries, one with
NTs trans vs. the phenoxide group (denoted OPh below) and
NHTs cis (denoted below Nt_NHc) and one with NHTs trans
and NTs cis (denoted below NHt_Nc). The energy differences
between these two isomers are within a 0.3 eV range,
depending on the theoretical level (Supporting Information,
Tables S6, S7). This value can be considered as a reasonable
uncertainty at this level of computation, thus both isomers
must be considered as isoenergetic. Their geometries are
represented on Figure 1.
ꢀ
As expected FeB N distances (from NTs and NHTs) vary
slightly for the different electronic configurations but cluster
around a representative value (Supporting Information,
ꢀ
Tables S4, S5). For both isomers the FeB NTs distance is
about 1.77 ꢀ, similar to the values already obtained for the
mixed-valent species 3 (1.8 ꢀ) and to the distance found by
EXAFS by Klinker et al.[7c] for the [(N4Py)FeIV(NTs)] com-
To substantiate this mechanistic scheme, we reasoned that
slowing down the intermolecular transfer to thioether sub-
strates should allow for increased transfer of the 14NTs group.
This can be achieved by using less reactive sulfides and/or
performing the reaction at lower temperature. Indeed both
factors lead to an increased content of the 14NTs isotopomer
attesting the progress of the tautomeric equilibrium (Sup-
porting Information, Table S2 and Figures S7, S8). We
obtained the ultimate confirmation for the latter by evidenc-
ing a kinetic influence of H/D substitution within 4-Cl
ꢀ
plex (1.73 ꢀ). The FeB NHTs distances are longer (1.89 to
1.97 ꢀ), and perfectly consistent with the ones reported for
[15]
FeIII NHTs complexes
and that found in the binuclear
ꢀ
complex 4 (1.94 to 1.97 ꢀ).[8]
Examination of the spin densities of both Fe ions and NTs,
NHTs, and OPh ligands (Table 1; Supporting Information,
Tables S6, S7) reveal remarkable features. First, the spin
densities for FeA are always between 4 and 4.13, typical of
III
III
III
III
ꢀ
[Fe Fe (-NHTs)]. Reacting D-labeled 4-Cl [Fe Fe (
NDTs)] with ArI 15NTs in the presence of PhSPh(NO2) at
=
Table 1: Spin densities of FeB, NTs, NHTs, and OPh groups from SP
B3LYP in the gas phase for NHt_Nc and Nt_NHc isomers, in the low
energy spin configuration identified through total spin projection
Sz=5.[a]
ꢀ308C as before led to a diminished 14NTs transfer, as
expected (Supporting Information, Figure S8). This weak
effect is significant and reproducible and consistent with very
recent observations made on oxo/hydroxo exchange.[14] All
the above observations thus establish that aliphatic amina-
tions involve a second catalytic cycle (Scheme 2B), of which
the active species 7 is generated by activation of 4 and exists
as an equilibrium of two tautomers.
FeA FeB NTs NHTs Oph
Electronic configuration
ꢀ
NHt_Nc 4.08 2.72 1.09 0.24 0.85
Nt_NHc 4.13 3.23 1.05 0.59
FeIII, FeIV COPh, NTs
ꢀ0.01 FeIII, FeIV OPh, CNTs
ꢀ
[a] Other hybrid functionals (B3LYP*, PBE0, M06, TPSSh) or solvent
phase calculations give very similar results within a 0.2 eV energy range
(see the Supporting Information).
In the absence of any possible spectroscopic character-
ization of 7 due to its transient nature, we relied on DFT
theoretical calculations to get insights into its molecular and
electronic structures. We followed a similar protocol as in our
previous study of 3 and 4,[8] exploring several initial structures
and spin state configurations (see the Supporting Information
for more details). The most reasonable model involves
binding of the two N(H)Ts groups on the same Fe ion (FeB,
Figure 1), concurring with the tautomeric equilibrium.
a high spin FeIII ion, and similar to those found in complexes 3
and 4, showing that FeA is not affected by the redox change
from 4 to 7. Second, by contrast, the FeB ion exhibits much
lower values close or lower than 3. Third, in all cases, a full
radical character is present on OPh and/or NTs ligands.
Thorough examinations of the Kohn–Sham orbitals combined
with these spin density values lead to a consistent picture of
the electronic structures of both tautomers. For the NHt_Nc
isomer, the LUMO is localized on an OPh p orbital
supporting the oxidation of the phenoxide (Supporting
Information, Figure S9, S10). In contrast, for Nt_NHc
isomer the LUMO is localized on an imido p orbital
(Supporting Information, Figures S11, S12). Finally, in both
cases, FeB is a high spin d4 FeIV ion, although its spin density
values are highly depleted compared to an expected value
close to 4, owing to strong donation effects. Hence a clear
picture emerges for the activated species 7. Its generation by
the two-electron oxidation of 4 occurs through a one-electron
oxidation of FeB to give an FeIV ion and a one-electron
oxidation of one ligand. Owing to the strong trans effect of the
Figure 1. Optimized geometries (top) of the two lowest energy config-
urations for the two models of 7 Nt-NHc (left) and NHt-Nc (right). H
atoms are not represented except the H in the NHTs ligand (in ball-
and-stick mode).
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017, 56, 1 – 6
ꢀ 2017 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
3
These are not the final page numbers!