74
D. Thiruppathi et al. / Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology A: Chemistry 295 (2014) 70–78
ꢀ
(450 nm) as one of the products of the reaction and a sample
kinetic run is shown in Fig. 2. The spectral changes collected in
Fig. 2 clearly show that during the course of the reaction Ru(III) ion
disappears (the peak in the region 600–700 nm) and Ru(II) ion
appears (450 nm) with isosbestic point at 542 nm. Thus the
reaction Ru(III) ! Ru(II) follows simple kinetics without involving
any complex mechanism. These experimental observations are
strongly in favor of electron transfer (ET) from Met to Ru(III) to
form Ru(II) in the rate determining step. The reaction is first-order
with respect to Ru(III) complex, the oxidant which is evident from
the linear log Abs vs time plot shown in the supporting information
(Fig. S3).
The values of pseudo first order rate constant, k1 plotted as a
function of concentration of peptide containing methionines is
shown in Fig. 3. The linear relationship between k1 and [peptide]
and constant k2 values at different [peptide] point out the first
order dependence in the substrate also. The reaction is thus overall
second order. The k2 values are obtained by dividing the pseudo
first order rate constant, k1 with substrate [peptide] concentration.
The second order rate constant values estimated from the
reaction of six [Ru(NN)3]3+ complexes as the oxidants for the one-
electron oxidation of five peptide containing methionines are
collected in Tables 1 and 2. The kinetic data collected in Table 1
show that the introduction of electron-donating groups like
methyl and tert-butyl in the 4- and 40-position of 2,20-bipyridine of
[Ru(NN)3]3+, 4,40-dimethyl-2,20-bipyridine and 4,40-tert-butyl-2,20-
bipyridine ligands, leads to decrease in the rate of oxidation by
more than two orders compared to unsubstituted 2,20-bipyridine
ligand (Table 1). The change of ligand in [Ru(NN)3]3+ changes the
—SO3 is only 0.02 eV. Thus the slightly high k2 value observed
with [Ru(dspphen)3]3+ compared to [Ru(dpphen)3]3+ may be
attributed to the change in the
When we look at the oxidation potential values of peptide
containing methionines (Tables 1 and 2) it is seen that the potential
values vary by 0.01–0.05 V with the change of the structure of the
D
Gꢇ value.
peptides. Comparison of kinetic data and
conclude that apart from the
D
Gꢇ values compels us to
D
Gꢇ value other parameters, polar
and steric effects, may change the rate constant value with the
change of structure of peptide. If the polar effect of the alkyl group
present in the peptide alone is the predominant factor in this
reaction, then the change of alkyl group should increase the rate
constant value in the order methyl (2) < isopropyl (4) < tert-butyl
(5) because
D
Gꢇ value remains almost constant for these three
peptides. Interestingly the same trend is observed on the rate
constant values for the electron transfer reaction of these three
peptides (Tables 1 and 2). The conclusion from this trend is that
steric effect plays little role on the electron transfer reaction when
the structure of peptide is changed.
In order to understand the influence of other parameters on the
rate of the reaction, the kinetics of the reaction has been followed
at different solvent (CH3CN–water) composition and the results are
collected in Table 3. Generally the increase in water content favors
the reaction when charge development takes place in the
transition state of the reaction. As the title reaction involves
electron transfer from methionine sulfur atom to Ru(III), positive
charge is developed on the sulfur center of the substrate in the
transition state. Our research group established the fact that
increase in water content increases the rate of the reaction
between organic sulfur compounds and Ru(III)–polypyridyl com-
plexes [25a]. Thus the solvent effect supports the operation of
electron transfer in the rate-controlling step.
D
Gꢇ value by 0.16 eV. Thus the main reason for the decrease in k2
values in the order [Ru(bpy)3]3+ > [Ru(dmbpy)3]3+ ꢆ [Ru(dtbpy)3]3+
may be attributed to the change in the
D
Gꢇ value. When
we compare the k2 values observed with [Ru(dmbpy)3]3+ and
To study the effect of temperature on the reaction rate, kinetics
of reaction of [Ru(NN)3]3+ with peptide containing methionines
were carried out at four different temperatures 293, 298, 303 and
[Ru(dtbpy)3]3+ the former complex has slightly more k2 value than
the latter though
D
Gꢇ values are almost equal. This may be
attributed to the steric effect of tert-butyl group present in the
complex [Ru(dtbpy)3]3+. Similar results were observed by us when
we used the excited state [Ru(NN)3]2+ complexes for the oxidation
of several phenolate ions [36]. On the other hand the introduction
of the electron-withdrawing group, disulfonate, in the ligand
1,10-phenanthroline increases the rate of reaction slightly com-
pared to the parent 1,10-phenanthroline ligand (Table 2). This is
308 K. The rate constants were found to increase with increase in
¼
temperature as presented in Table 4. The enthalpy (
D
H ) and
¼
entropy (
D
S ) of activation evaluated using the Eyring’s plot of log
¼
k2/T vs 1/T is summarized in Table 4. The negative
D
S
value
indicates the compactness of transition state. The thermodynamic
¼
¼
parameters
DS and DH values, collected in Table 4 show that
with the change of structure of peptide containing methionines as
well as the ligand in the Ru(III) complex there is little change in the
because the change in
D
Gꢇ value due to the introduction of
¼
¼
D
H as well as DS values. This little change in the thermodynamic
parameters with the change of structure of reactants also supports
the operation of electron transfer mechanism of the reaction.
3.1. Formation of Met sulfur radical cation
In this work we propose that the reaction of [Ru(NN)3]3+ with
methionylglycine produces Met-sulfur radical cation. Ruthenium
Table 3
Effect of varying solvent composition on the reaction of [Ru(NN)3]3+ with peptide
containing methionines at 298 K.
Solvent composition CH3CN:H2O (v/v)
k2, Mꢀ1 sꢀ1
[Ru(bpy)3]3+
[Ru(phen)3]3+
Met-Gly
Met-Ala
80:20
70:30
60:40
50:50
40:60
20:80
5.3 ꢅ 0.16
6.5 ꢅ 0.18
7.2 ꢅ 0.20
9.7 ꢅ 0.29
12.1 ꢅ 0.32
13.5 ꢅ 0.41
11.8 ꢅ 0.35
13.0 ꢅ 0.36
14.3 ꢅ 0.43
16.1 ꢅ 0.43
18.5 ꢅ 0.56
20.8 ꢅ 0.60
Fig. 3. Plot of k1 vs [peptide] for the oxidation of peptide containing methionines
with [Ru(bpy)3]3+ in oxygen saturated aqueous CH3CN (1:1, v/v) solution in the
presence of 2.3 M HClO4 at 298 K. (The points 1–5 refer to the peptide containing
methionine given in Table 1).
General condition: [Ru(NN)3]3+ = 2 ꢃ10ꢀ5 M, [Peptide] = 5 ꢃ10ꢀ4 M and [H+] = 2.3 M.