Reviews - Clomiphene citrate and ovulation induction - H Sovino et al.
such as intracytoplasmic sperm injection, makes it very
expensive for many infertile couples needing IVF. In view of
this situation, it is necessary to reassess ovulation induction
schemes, to reduce costs while avoiding any negative impact,
to the greatest possible extent, on success rates. Clomiphene is
cheaper to use and it is safe, but its usage in the new IVF
schemes requires complete evaluation. Some investigators
believe that the use of clomiphene in IVF schemes is not
justified, in view of its adverse effects on the endometrium,
which could influence the outcomes of treatment. At present,
clomiphene is used in some IVF programmes in combination
with human menopausal gonadotrophin (HMG), prior to the
use of GnRHa.
the discontinuation of oral contraceptives (Branigan and Estes,
1999). This observation enabled researchers to design the
‘minimal stimulation study’, using clomiphene at 100 mg/day
for 8 days starting on day 3 of the cycle in a group of 36
candidates for IVF. These patients had undergone down-
regulation with oral contraceptives 2 months prior to ovulation
induction. No LH surge was observed in this group of patients.
Their average number of mature oocytes recovered was 3.2,
with a 90% fertilization rate and an average number of 2.5
embryos transferred, and a 32.8% pregnancy rate per
aspiration. These outcomes were similar to those obtained in
IVF stimulated cycles, and this schedule has the advantages of
being cheap and simple, while presenting low risks for the
patients (Branigan and Estes, 2000).
The theoretical advantages of combining HMG and clomiphene
are the strength of the luteal phase supported by clomiphene, a
lesser need for HMG and higher concentrations of progesterone
in the luteal phase, which often renders luteal support
unnecessary. Table 1 shows the results obtained from IVF
cycles between 1983 and 1990, at the New Orleans Fertility
Institute, comparing HMG/clomiphene, HMG alone and
GnRHa/HMG (Dickey et al., 1998). Clinical pregnancies and
birth rates were higher with HMG/clomiphene than with HMG
alone, and the results were similar to those obtained with
GnRHa/HMG. The main advantage seen with GnRHa/HMG
was that fewer cycles were cancelled, which is probably related
to the beneficial effect of GnRH agonists, in reducing premature
luteinization caused by an early LH surge. As a result, more
oocytes are obtained, and that in turn makes it possible to
generate more cryopreserved embryos with this therapy.
Association with other drugs
There is a group of patients, estimated as between 10% and
20%, in whom doses of 150 mg clomiphene citrate per day for
5 days do not result in ovulation after three or more attempts,
and/or who fail to conceive after 4–6 months of this induction
protocol. This group of patients is said to be clomiphene
resistant. When this phenomenon occurs, clomiphene may be
administered with other drugs, after evaluating the individual
patient characteristics (body mass index, hirsutism, acanthosis
nigricans, galactorrhoea), together with a baseline functional
assessment including ultrasonography, total testosterone, sex
hormone binding globulin, free androgen index, DHEA-S,
prolactin and progesterone in the luteal phase. This is followed
by the evaluation of the cervical mucus, endometrial thickness
and follicular size during the follicular follow-up.
As clomiphene is only used at doses between 50 and 150
mg/day, more than one follicle may progress to the
preovulatory state, and an average number of two or three
oocytes are aspirated from each woman (Marrs et al., 1984).
The combination of clomiphene and gonadotrophins yields a
better ovarian response, with more oocytes and with better
morphology, as compared with clomiphene alone (Quigley et
al., 1984). This observation could be explained by several
mechanisms. When clomiphene is administered for 5 days
during the early follicular phase (days 3–7 of the cycle), it not
only stimulates the secretion of FSH, but also LH, which may
result in relatively high concentrations of LH during the
follicular phase (Messinis and Templeton, 1986). This could
cause early luteinization of granulosa cells, and so alter the
outcomes of pregnancy (Stanger and Yovich, 1985).
Depending on the aetiology of the condition, several drugs can
be administered with clomiphene citrate, including the
following. The first is human chorionic gonadotrophin (HCG),
which is used when anovulation persists in spite of good
follicular development and adequate oestrogen production. It
is administered at doses of 5000–10,000 IU, when the
dominating follicle reaches a diameter of ≥18 mm and the
concentration of oestrogens exceeds 200 pg/ml. HCG can also
be added in cases of luteal failure.
Corticosteroids are especially indicated in hyperandrogenic
chronic anovulation, preferably of adrenal origin, using
0.5–1.0 mg dexamethasone q.h.s, which leads to a 70–90%
increase in the ovulation rate. Dopaminergic agonists are
indicated in chronic anovulation associated with
hyperprolactinaemia. Pituitary gonadotrophins are used when
ovulation does not occur, but moderate follicular development
is achieved.
A new strategy for the use of clomiphene in combination with
GnRH antagonist for ovulation induction has been proposed
recently (Olivennes et al., 2000; Reissmann et al., 2000). The
physiological rationales supporting this association are mainly
based on the ability of GnRHa to reduce high concentrations
of LH generated by clomiphene. Antagonists, contrary to the
action of GnRHa, competitively block GnRH receptors at the
pituitary level, preserving the post-receptor mechanism of the
latter intact. Nevertheless, it is necessary to conduct further
studies, including an adequate number of patients, in order to
validate the bases of these new schemes.
It is possible to administer clomiphene and HMG sequentially,
which permits substantial reductions in the dose of HMG
required to produce ovulation. Progesterone is indicated when
the administration of clomiphene produces a deficient luteal
phase. It is used as pure progesterone in the luteal phase (72 h
after ovulation) at doses of 12.5 mg i.m. or 25 mg b.i.d. as
vaginal suppositories, or orally in the form of micronized
progesterone. Ethynyl oestradiol is used at low doses to
improve the quality of the cervical mucus and the endometrial
thickness, with a consequent increase in pregnancy rates (Gerli
et al., 1999).
A
study
using
the
down-regulation
of
the
hypothalamus–pituitary–ovarian axis with oral contraceptives
in patients with clomiphene-resistant PCOS showed that the
LH surge can be prevented or reduced in the cycle following
308