RESEARCH
in a streamlined approach that obviates an
alkynylation–Al reduction–iodination sequence.
Among the atom transfer catalysts investigated,
several photocatalysts afforded new, redox-
neutral coupling adduct 3 preferentially over
the classic, reduced coupling product 4. These
catalysts included complexes of earth-abundant,
first-row metals (e.g., Mn, Fe) as well as more
reducing photocatalysts (e.g., Ru, Ir; see table
S1 for further details). Ultimately, a Mn2(CO)10
catalyst was found to provide excellent selec-
tivity for redox-neutral coupling (3:4, >20:1)
along with high Z:E diastereoselectivity (>20:1).
The latter feature is notable, as there are few
methods to access vinyl iodides with high Z-
selectivity (27). Although Mn-mediated reactions
are typically associated with oxidative mech-
anisms, atom transfer pathways are accessible
via Mn2(CO)10 (28–30). Unlike typical photo-
catalysts, a photon is not necessary for turnover
of the Mn catalyst. However, we observed that
continual irradiation is necessary to access high
efficiency and selectivity, likely due to an equi-
librium between the precatalyst dimer and the
active catalyst. Given the high chemo- and stereo-
selectivity afforded by the Mn catalyst, we de-
cided to further explore its synthetic potential
in this redox-neutral mechanism.
In our mechanistic proposal, shown in Fig. 1D,
Mn2(CO)10 precatalyst is homolyzed to Mn(CO)5
(5, Mn•) by irradiation with a blue LED. This 17-
electron species is a competent ATRA catalyst
that can abstract I• from the weak C-I bond
[bond dissociation energy (BDE), 58 kcal/mol]
(31) of in situ–generated a-acetoxy iodide 6.
Combination of the resultant ketyl radical 7
with alkyne 8 affords vinyl radical 9. This
open-shell intermediate is formally oxidized by
Mn(CO)5I (10, [Mn]-I) via atom transfer to re-
generate the Mn• catalyst (5), while also forming
vinyl iodide 3′ in a redox-neutral mechanism
(32). The net conversion of 6 to 3′ is exothermic
because of the formation of a strong vinyl C-I
bond (BDE, 61 to 68 kcal/mol). An observed
post-reaction isomerization of the vinyl iodide
products—from 1:1 to >20:1 Z:E selectivity—is
also thermodynamically favored by up to 3 kcal/
mol (33). This Mn-catalyzed isomerization likely
occurs via an intermediate vinyl radical, which is
consistent with reports of photoinduced, single-
electron reduction of aryl iodides for sp2 radical
generation (34, 35). This Mn-catalyzed ATRA
mechanism precludes an alternate pathway, in
which vinyl radical 9 is further reduced to vinyl
anion 11 [Ep,c = –0.1 V (36), which is at least 2 V
more favorable than carbonyl to ketyl reduction]
to afford allyl ester 4. Instead, by coupling cat-
alyst turnover with product formation, the classic
reductive mechanism can be overridden by this
redox-neutral pathway.
ORGANIC CHEMISTRY
Ketyl radical reactivity
via atom transfer catalysis
Lu Wang, Jeremy M. Lear, Sean M. Rafferty, Stacy C. Fosu, David A. Nagib*
Single-electron reduction of a carbonyl to a ketyl enables access to a polarity-reversed
platform of reactivity for this cornerstone functional group. However, the synthetic utility of
the ketyl radical is hindered by the strong reductants necessary for its generation, which also
limit its reactivity to net reductive mechanisms. We report a strategy for net redox-neutral
generation and reaction of ketyl radicals. The in situ conversion of aldehydes to a-acetoxy
iodides lowers their reduction potential by more than 1 volt, allowing for milder access to the
corresponding ketyl radicals and an oxidative termination event. Upon subjecting these
iodides to a dimanganese decacarbonyl precatalyst and visible light irradiation, an atom
transfer radical addition (ATRA) mechanism affords a broad scope of vinyl iodide products
with high Z-selectivity.
he ketyl coupling of carbonyls offers a
mechanistically inverted approach to con-
structing C-C bonds versus classic, polar
mechanisms (1). However, a major limita-
tion of this valuable method is its reliance
promotes mild ketyl radical formation from an
in situ–generated intermediate containing a
weak C-I bond. The resulting radical is capable
of coupling with a range of alkynes. Catalyst
turnover occurs (via formal oxidation of the
ensuing vinyl radical intermediate) by atom
transfer (19, 20) with Mn-I, in a net redox-neutral
mechanism that enables access to synthetically
versatile (21) Z-vinyl halides.
T
on strong, stoichiometric reductants (e.g., Na, K,
Ti) (2–4) to overcome the large reduction poten-
tial of carbonyls (peak cathodic potential Ep,c
>
–2 V versus SCE) (5, 6). As shown in Fig. 1A,
a powerful tool used to overcome the thermo-
dynamic barrier for ketyl generation is Kagan’s
reagent (SmI2) (7, 8). This single-electron re-
ductant can even be used catalytically when
coupled with strong, stoichiometric reductants
(e.g., Zn/Hg) (9). Recently, photochemical ap-
proaches have been applied to address this
fundamental thermodynamic challenge in a
complementary manner. For example, Knowles
and co-workers developed a proton-coupled
electron transfer strategy to reduce ketones
to ketyl radicals using Ir or Ru photocatalysts
(< –1.5 V), Brønsted acids, and a milder stoi-
chiometric reductant (e.g., Hantzsch ester)
(10, 11). The groups of Yoon, Ngai, and Huang
(12–15) have also shown that concerted use of
Lewis acids enables photocatalytic reduction
of carbonyls to access ketyl radicals and their
vinylogous analogs. Additional metal-catalyzed
strategies for carbonyl-alkyne coupling promote
complementary reactivity (by Ni, Ru, or Ir) with
alternate reductants (e.g., Et3B, Mg, H2) (16–18).
However, in each of the ketyl-based strategies,
a redox-neutral approach remains mechanis-
tically unfeasible because catalysts capable of
overcoming the high reduction potential of a
carbonyl are necessarily also prone to reducing
the resulting ketyl-coupling adduct.
In our synthetic design, we focused on ad-
dressing the challenge of ketyl radical gener-
ation from aliphatic aldehydes. We envisioned
that their conversion to a-oxy iodides would
benefit from hyperconjugative donation of the
nonbonding oxygen electrons into the C-I anti-
bonding orbital (n → s*) to further weaken
this bond. Among several a-iodo radical precur-
sors we investigated, the a-acetoxy derivative
proved simplest to generate under mild condi-
tions. This in situ activation is performed by
combining AcI (AcCl, NaI) with carbonyls [5%
Zn(OTf)2, 0°C, 15 min] in a modified version
of Adams’ nearly century-old procedure (22).
The resulting aldehyde derivatives are conve-
niently handled in an aerobic atmosphere at
room temperature and are stable to basic, aque-
ous washes without elimination. This practical
synthetic accessibility allowed us to electro-
chemically validate our hypothesis that a-acetoxy
iodides (Ep,c = –1.1 V; fig. S2) are more easily
reduced than their aldehyde precursors (> –2.2 V)
(5) as well as other alkyl iodides (23–26). Next,
we explored the generation of ketyl radicals—
and their redox-neutral coupling with alkynes—
by using a variety of atom transfer catalysts.
In accordance with our design plan, we ob-
served that several photocatalysts promote this
redox-neutral alkyne coupling with ketyl radi-
cals derived from aliphatic aldehydes (1), as
illustrated in Fig. 1C. Expecting the nucleo-
philicity of a-OAc ketyl radicals to be atten-
uated, we explored their combination with
several alkynes of varying electronic character.
In particular, coupling of silyl acetylene 2 af-
fords silyl vinyl iodide 3 (containing orthog-
onal handles for further synthetic manipulation)
Our complementary strategy, outlined in Fig. 1,
addresses this challenge by replacing the car-
bonyl reduction step with a halogen abstraction
event via an atom transfer radical addition
(ATRA) mechanism. In this case, a Mn catalyst
In probing the synthetic utility of this strat-
egy, we were pleased to find that aliphatic
aldehydes, which are challenging to reduce to
ketyls (Ep,c > –2 V) (5), efficiently combine with
a range of alkynes, as shown in Fig. 2. Alkynes
with broad electronic character are coupled to
the stabilized ketyl radicals, providing Z-vinyl
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, The Ohio State
University, Columbus, OH, USA.
*Corresponding author. Email: nagib.1@osu.edu
Wang et al., Science 362, 225–229 (2018)
12 October 2018
1 of 5