June 2003
821
pathway. The neutrophil oxidase consists of 5 major sub- terol synthesis, and it is possible that pravastatin cannot sup-
units: a plasma membrane spanning cytochrome b558 com- press the isoprenylation of the rac2 protein of the neu-
posed of a large subunit gp91phox and a smaller subunit trophils. In addition, different characteristics between pravas-
p22phox, and 3 cytosolic components p40phox, p47phox and tatin and fluvastatin are also found, with respect to a lack of
p67phox.13—15) The low molecular weight G protein rac2 par- the inhibitory effect on the thickening of the intima after bal-
ticipates in the assembly of the active complex and NADPH loon catheterization.23) Thus, although the dose factor cannot
oxidase is activated by isoprenylation of the rac2 protein, be excluded, pravastatin might be less permeable to neu-
which results in a production of superoxide anions.16) HMG- trophils than fluvastatin, as shown by the liver specificity of
CoA reductase generates mevalonate from HMG-CoA, and the former drug action based on its hepatocytes specific car-
mevalonate is further metabolized into a series of iso- rier mediated system and greater hydrophilicity.10) In this in
prenoids. Accordingly, fluvastatin may suppress the isopreny- vivo model, it is considered that fluvastatin did not alter
lation of the rac2 protein, and may finally suppress the pro- serum lipid concentration. Tsujita et al. reported that pravas-
duction of superoxide. The fact that the inhibitory effect of tatin did not reduce serum lipids in rats and mice.24) Further-
fluvastatin on superoxide generation was reversed by the ad- more, Kimura et al. reported that fluvastatin also did not re-
dition of mevalonate is also further evidence to the possibil- duce serum lipids at a dose of 6 mg/kg in rats.25)
ity. Inoue et al. reported that the mRNA levels of p22phox,
Recently, it was demonstrated that the oxidative stress by
and the protein levels of p47phox of NADPH oxidase, were NADPH oxidase in endothelial cells (EC) also plays a role in
decreased by treatment with fluvastatin, and that this effect the early steps of atherosclerosis.26) Meyer et al. confirmed
was reversed by the addition of mevalonate.17) To understand protein expression of NADPH oxidase subunits, such as gp
the detailed mechanism by which fluvastatin inhibits neu- 91phox, p22phox, p47phox, and p67phox in EC, and that
trophil superoxide anion production, additional studies such apocynin, a specific leukocyte NADPH oxidase inhibitor, in-
as an analysis of the translocation of cytosolic subunits hibits the translocation of p47phox to the membrane of stim-
(p40phox, p47phox and p67phox) to the membrane, and their ulated EC. These findings also support the presence of a
assembly with the gp91phox and p22phox subunits, is re- functionally active leukocyte type NADPH oxidase in EC.27)
quired.
From these facts, it is likely that fluvastatin inhibits the pro-
Fluvastatin reduced active oxygen species such as hy- gression of atherosclerosis via the inhibition of NADPH oxi-
droxyl radicals and superoxide anions, generated by the Fen- dase in not only neutrophils but also in EC. Rueckschloss et
ton reaction and by the xanthine–xanthine oxidase system, al. reported that oxidized LDL induces proatherosclerotic
respectively. There are several reports that fluvastatin sup- NADPH oxidase expression and superoxide anion formation
presses lipid peroxidation by scavenging active oxygen in human endothelial cells, and an antioxidative potential of
species such as hydroxyl radicals and the superoxide anions HMG-CoA reductase inhibition via the reduction of vascular
of rat liver microsomes in vivo and in vitro.18,19) Pravastatin NADPH oxidase expression.28) Furthermore, Inoue et al. re-
did not show a chemical scavenging action, such as hydroxyl ported that after the 16-week lipid-lowering therapy, the anti-
radicals and superoxide anions. It is assumed that these phe- ox-LDL titer significantly decreased in the fluvastatin group
nomena originate in its chemical structure.
but did not change in the pravastatin group.29)
Thus, it was confirmed that fluvastatin decreased PMA-de-
Several kinds of molecules such as hydrogen peroxide, hy-
pendent ROS generation in vitro, and we further examined droxyl radical, and singlet oxygen, are known as reactive
the in vivo effects of fluvastatin on PMA-dependent ROS oxygen species which neutrophils produce, beside superox-
generation to confirm whether the observed in vitro effects ide anions. At first, superoxide anions are produced, and then
actually occur in vivo. Treatment with fluvastatin (5 mg/kg other reactive oxygen species are produced from superoxide
per day, p.o.) for 1 week also decreased PMA-dependent anions by the chemical reaction. Accordingly, NADPH oxi-
ROS generation in vivo, and this suppressive effect of fluvas- dase takes part directly only in the production of superoxide
tatin on ROS generation was also reversed by the combined anions.30) Therefore, it was thought that the direct NADPH
administration with mevalonate. Pravastatin with the same oxidase inhibition of fluvastatin is important.
concentration and dose as fluvastatin did not show any signif-
NADPH oxidase is present in neutrophils and EC, and it
icant effect on ROS generation in vitro or in vivo. The most seems to be a source of superoxide anion production in ani-
likely reason for the difference between these HMG-CoA re- mal models of vascular disease, and in human atherosclero-
ductase inhibitors is that greater doses of pravastatin are re- sis.31) Therefore, these effects of fluvastatin may be beneficial
quired to produce these effects in this species of animal and in preventing vascular complications in hyperlipidemia, in
cells. However, pravastatin showed a similar range of lipid addition to its strong hypocholesterolemic action.
lowering effects in humans at 0.3—0.7 mg/kg20): 20—
40 mg/d for pravastatin versus 20—60 mg/d for fluvastatin.21)
REFERENCES
Pravastatin is known as a highly hepatocyte-selective agent in
inhibiting cholesterol synthesis.10) Pravastatin is actively
1) Steinberg D., Parthasarathy S., Carew T. E., Khoo J. C., Witztum J. L.,
transported into hepatocytes via a carrier mediated system.
Conversely, in non hepatic cells, the uptake of pravastatin is
minimal over a wide concentration range because of its
greater hydrophilicity.10) It was reported that the IC50 values
of the cholesterol synthesis with fluvastatin and pravastatin
on aortic smooth muscle cells were 0.15 mM and 195.0 mM,
respectively.22) It may not actually inhibit neutrophil choles-
N. Engl. J. Med., 320, 915—924 (1989).
2) Geng Y. J., Hansson G. K., J. Clin. Invest., 89, 1322—1330 (1992).
3) Kojda G., Harrison D., Cardiovasc Res., 43, 562—571 (1999).
4) Kita T., Nagano Y., Yokoda M., Ishii K., Kume N., Ooshima A.,
Yoshida H., Kawai C., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 84, 5928—5931
(1987).
5) Maeba R., Maruyama A., Tarutani O., Ueta N., Shimasaki H., FEBS
Lett., 377, 309—312 (1995).