2278
C. Tomassi et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 18 (2008) 2277–2281
of the inhibitory effects on HIV-1 replication demon-
strated that these ATSAO derivatives showed the same
HIV-1 specific activity spectrum (EC50: 0.13–0.53 lM)
but significantly, showed no inhibitory activity against
HIV-2 at subtoxic concentrations. A computational
study revealed that the ATSAO compounds adopt a
similar conformation at the p66–p51 interface as that
of TSAO analogs.11
tion of a Boc group at the N-3 position improves the
antiviral activity over that of the lead TSAO-T com-
pound (EC50 = 0.06 0.010 lM). We hypothesized that
this might probably be due to the establishment of addi-
tional interactions with the dimer interface near the b7–
b8 loop. Moreover, N-3 carbamoylation decreased the
cytotoxic concentration compared with TSAO-T
(CC50 = 26.2 1.12 lM vs 16 1.0 lM for TSAO-T).
No antiviral activity was observed against HIV-2. This
result is in accordance with our preliminary results ob-
tained in the ATSAO series.
AzaTSAO-T derivatives bearing a substituted dihydro-
isothiazole dioxide ring with a phenyl group at 500 posi-
tion have also been reported. Their biological evaluation
revealed that the phenyl group leads to a dramatic de-
crease in the inhibitory effect. Continuing our work on
this area, and in order to gain a deeper insight into the
SAR of (A)TSAO derivatives, herein we report the syn-
thesis of TSAO-Boc3T (8) as well as its biological evalu-
ation and modeling study of the most active TSAO and
ATSAO compounds (with a Boc functionality at N-3).
In order to further elucidate the binding mode induced
by this novel pharmacophore, a modeling study was
undertaken. A recent computational study focused on
the role of the heteroatom at the spirocycle revealed that
its endocyclic moiety is mostly exposed to the solvent,
and it was argued that additional electrostatic stabiliza-
tion by the polar solvent might stabilize the complex
formed with the oxathiole or unmethylated aza deriva-
tives.11 It was postulated, on the other hand, that the
presence of a substituent on the endocyclic nitrogen
atom constrains the ring pucker to a narrow region of
the pseudorotational cycle. This leads to a fairly dis-
torted disposition of the base and substituents of fura-
nose, mainly the 50-O-TBDMS group. Because of the
well-known rigorous geometric requirements for the
functional groups at C-50,5a,12 we speculated that this
enhanced conformational rigidity may impede the com-
pound’s efficient adaptation to the enzyme binding site,
leading to a loss of affinity.
In the previous work,10a we demonstrated that ATSAO-
Boc3T, which has an unsubstituted isothiazolic ring,
proved to be only 2- to 7-fold less active than TSAO-T
against HIV-1 replication in MT-4 and CEM cells. The
inhibitory effects for ATSAO-Boc3T and the unsubstitut-
ed N-3 analog (EC50: 0.13 vs 0.53 lM) suggested that it
was the Boc group at the N-3 position that increases the
activity. In spite of the large number of compounds
tested,4 it is surprising that no TSAO analog equivalent
to our ATSAO-Boc3T has been synthesized so far.
In order to establish the role of a Boc group at N-3 on
the biological activity and to further elaborate SAR
studies, here we describe the synthesis, modeling studies,
and the anti-HIV-1 activity of compound TSAO-Boc3T
(8).
According to the proposed model, the N-3 substituent
would be mostly exposed to the solvent and run parallel
to the subunit interface. Thus additional interactions with
other interface residues may help destabilize the RT dimer
by disrupting key p51/p66 interface interactions.8 In fact,
it has been demonstrated that modifications at the N-3 po-
sition are well tolerated,13 and in some cases are even
better than the prototype TSAO-T at disrupting the in-
ter-subunit interactions. Thus, they are more potent
inhibitors of the enzyme’s DNA polymerase activity,
and also exhibit potent antiviral activity.14
Following the synthetic pathway described by Camar-
asa et al., carbamoylation of the TSAO-T was unsuc-
cessful; consequently, the Boc group was introduced
before the Carbanion mediated Sulfonate Intramolecular
Cyclization (CSIC)-reaction step.10b,c Accordingly, com-
pound 4, obtained from precursor 1, was reacted under
the usual conditions to give the Boc-derivative 5, which
was submitted to the CSIC protocol to provide product
6 in 60% yield. Subsequent deprotection (NH3/MeOH)
and silylation afforded the target compound 8 in 50%
yield.
We have now conducted a molecular modeling analysis
(see Supplementary Data) on the effect of a Boc substi-
tuent on N-3 to identify the structural features that are
important for the improved ability, relative to the lead
TSAO compound, to inhibit HIV-1 RT dimerization.
The inhibitory activity of compound 8 against HIV-1
(IIIB) and HIV-2 (ROD) was evaluated in CEM cell
cultures. In a previous work,10a we demonstrated that
the ATSAO derivatives lacking a substituent (methyl)
on the endocyclic nitrogen atom of the spiro moiety
were potent and selective inhibitors of HIV-1 in
CEM cell cultures, as none of them showed inhibitory
activity against HIV-2 replication, at subtoxic
concentrations.
Docking studies15 (see Supplementary Data) were per-
formed on the proposed binding site using the com-
pounds shown in Figure 2. The number of clusters
found for each compound, the proportion of highly
populated clusters, and the corresponding binding and
docking energies of each complex were calculated (see
Supplementary Data) (Scheme 1).
Our data indicate that the Boc-derivatives can pose in
the presumed binding site mainly in two different modes,
each differing in orientation of the Boc group at N-3:
complexes a and b. Figure 3 shows both conformations
for compound 8. As can be seen, the Boc carbonyl oxy-
However, for compound 8, which has an oxathiole spiro
ring, the concentration required to protect CEM cells
against the cytopathogenicity of HIV by 50% (EC50:
0.023 0.010 lM) clearly demonstrates that introduc-