R. Hitge, et al.
Bioorganic&MedicinalChemistryLettersxxx(xxxx)xxxx
Fig. 2. The synthetic route for the synthesis of nitrocatechol derivatives of
chalcone and the pyrazoline derivatives. Reagents and conditions: (a) HNO3,
acetic acid, rt; (b) AlCl3, pyridine, ethyl acetate, 77 °C; (c) ethanol, KOH, RCHO,
rt; (d) acetic acid, hydrazine hydrate, 120 °C.
Fig. 3. Sigmoidal plots for the inhibition of COMT by 7f (open circles) and 9c
presence of acetic acid to yield the nitro derivative 11 (5–ni-
troapocynin). In the second step, demethylation of 11 was carried out
with AlCl3/pyridine to yield the 5-acetyl-3-nitrocatechol 12.23,28 The
target chalcones (6a–c; 7a–f) were obtained via the Claisen-Schmidt
condensation reaction between 12 and an appropriately substituted
aldehyde in ethanol. Potassium hydroxide served as the base.29 The
nitrocatechol derivatives of chalcone were purified by crystallisation
from an appropriate solvent (yields: 12–35%). The pyrazoline deriva-
tives (8a–c; 9a–d) were synthesised by reacting the corresponding
chalcones with hydrazine hydrate in the presence of acetic acid.26,30
The yields for these reactions ranged from 38 to 96%. The chalcone and
pyrazoline derivatives were characterised by NMR and MS, while the
purity was assessed by HPLC (see supplementary material).
(filled circles).
the nitrocatechol derivatives of chalcone (6a–c; 7a–f) and the pyrazo-
line derivatives (8a–c; 9a–d) are good potency inhibitors of COMT with
IC50 values < 0.29 μM. The pyrazoline derivatives are more potent
inhibitors than the chalcones, with 8b being the most potent inhibitor
with an IC50 value of 0.048 μM. COMT inhibitors containing the 3-ni-
trocatechol moiety that have been developed and introduced into the
market include entacapone (IC50 = 0.23 µM) that display similar po-
tency under these experimental conditions. Among the heterocyclic
derivatives, pyrazoline 9a was found to be the most potent inhibitor
with an IC50 value of 0.16 µM.
It is noteworthy that all nitrocatechol derivatives of chalcone and
the pyrazoline derivatives are good potency COMT inhibitors. This
shows that the B-ring does not have a significant effect on COMT in-
hibition. The B-ring can thus be explored to improve MAO-B inhibition
The MAO inhibitory properties of the nitrocatechol derivatives of
chalcone and the pyrazoline derivatives were investigated with the
recombinant human MAO enzymes. The MAO activity measurements
were carried out with kynuramine as substrate, which is converted by
MAO to yield the fluorescent compound, 4-hydroxyquinoline.31,32 After
measuring the catalytic activities of MAO-A and MAO-B in the absence
and presence (0.003–100 µM) of the test inhibitors, IC50 values were
as it is unlikely to affect COMT inhibition to
a large extent.
Nitrocatechol derivatives of chalcone and the corresponding pyrazoline
derivatives may serve as leads for the future design of potent COMT
inhibitors. This study is the first report of COMT inhibition by pyr-
azoline compounds and thus proposes the further development of these
nitrocatechol derivatives as potentially clinically useful COMT in-
hibitors. It should be kept in mind that the pyrazoline derivatives are
chiral and represent the racemates of two enantiomers. It is not clear if
both enantiomers contribute equally to COMT inhibition, but future
studies should separate the enantiomers of a representative inhibitor
(e.g. 8b) to determine the stereochemistry of the eutomer and distomer.
As mentioned, nitrocatechol derivatives of chalcone have previously
been investigated as COMT inhibitors.23 In accordance with the find-
ings of this study, the pyrazoline compounds are significantly more
potent COMT inhibitors than the chalcones investigated previously. The
most potent pyrazoline compound (8b, IC50 = 0.048 µM) is approxi-
mately 1.46-fold more potent that the most potent chalcone (5,
IC50 = 0.07 µM) reported in literature.23
estimated in triplicate and are reported here as the means
standard
deviation (SD). These IC50 values are given in Table 1 and show that the
nitrocatechol derivatives of chalcone (6a–c; 7a–f) and the pyrazoline
derivatives (8a–c; 9a–d) are relatively weak inhibitors of MAO-A and
MAO-B, with IC50 values > 41.4 μM. These values are significantly
higher than those of the reference inhibitor, curcumin, which inhibit
MAO-A and MAO-B with IC50 values of 5.02 µM and 2.56 µM, respec-
tively. It is well-known that benzo- and phthalonitriles inhibits MAO-B
potently, and hydroxy substitution is also known to enhance MAO-B
inhibition of chalcones.24,25 Since chalcones are in general good po-
tency inhibitors of MAO-B, particularly compounds containing polar
groups on the A-ring (e.g. OH), it may be concluded that nitro sub-
stitution on the A-ring greatly diminishes MAO-B inhibition.20 It is in-
teresting to note that the pyrazoline derivatives are in general weaker
MAO inhibitors than the corresponding chalcones. The only exception
is MAO-B inhibition by 8a versus 6a.
To obtain insight into potential binding orientations and interac-
tions of pyrazoline compound 8b with the COMT active site, molecular
docking was carried out. For comparison, the corresponding chalcone,
6b, was also investigated. For this study, rat COMT complexed with 3,5-
dinitrocatechol was used as protein model (PDB code: 1VID).36 Pre-
paration of the protein models and ligands were carried out according
docking was done with AutoDock Vina.31,37 The accuracy of the
docking procedure was assessed by redocking the co-crystallized ligand
into the COMT active site, which yielded a root mean square deviation
(RMSD) of 0.684 Å between the docked orientation and the position of
the co-crystallised ligand (Fig. 4). In the crystal structure, the Mg2+ co-
factor is octahedrally coordinated to the side chains of Asp141 and
Asp169, Asn170, the two hydroxy groups of the catechol substrate, and
To determine whether the synthesised compounds are inhibitors of
COMT, soluble fractions obtained from homogenates of rat liver tissue
were used as enzyme source.23,33,34 Ethical approval for the collection
and use of animal tissue was obtained from the Research Ethics Com-
mittee of the North-West University (ethics approval numbers: NWU-
00561-19-S5 and NWU-00562-19-S5). Esculetin (6,7–dihydrox-
ycoumarin) served as substrate and is methylated by COMT to yield
scopoletin, a reaction that may be monitored by fluorescence spectro-
photometry.35 COMT catalytic activity was thus measured in the ab-
sence and presence (0.003–80 µM) of the test inhibitors, and IC50 values
were estimated in triplicate and are given as the means
3