Modulating Large Area Self-Assembly
COMMUNICATION
quence of both the increased number of non-adsorbed
alkoxy side chains as compared to the “chess board” motif
and the enhanced density of packing, determined by the reg-
istry with the substrate. Interestingly, the same packing
motif has been observed in BTP-1 upon addition of one
equivalent of tetrakis(acetonitrile)copper(I) hexafluorophos-
phate to the solution, leading to the formation of CuACTHUNTGRNEUNG(BTP-
1)+ complexes (see Figure S5[11]).
Figure 2d–f shows the packing motif of molecules BTP-2
after their protonation. Again, major structural changes
took place on the surface, that is, from the “rosette” to the
“tetragon” motif. The proposed packing model (Figure 2 f),
extrapolated from high resolution STM measurements,
shows unambiguously that the BTP-2 cores adopt an “ex-
tended” conformation, in line with protonation. Despite
their different initial arrangement under neutral pH condi-
tions, both BTP derivatives undergo significant structural
transformations of the self-assembled monolayer packing
upon protonation. Given that the structure of the unit cell
notably changes for both BTP-1 and BTP-2 upon protona-
tion, it is most likely that switching takes place in the 3D su-
pernatant solution, through a desorption–readsorption pro-
cess. Significantly, virtually identical protonation-driven
transformations were observed both for ex situ and in situ
acidifications.
Figure 3. Consecutive STM images showing the structural evolution of a
monolayer of BTP-2 over 20 min after the addition of ca. 10 mL TFA.
The evolution of the shape of the domain containing the molecules in the
rosette packing is highlighted in white. a) Image taken right after the ad-
dition of TFA b) After 5 min c) After 10 min d) After 15 min. The unit-
cell found for the new packing corresponds exactly to the one of the tet-
ragon structure. Tunneling parameters: Ut =500 mV, It =10 pA.
The real-time conformational switch, and related reorgan-
ization of the self-assembled pattern, occurring at the solid–
liquid interface have been monitored in situ on the scale of
several tens of nanometers. The transformation from the
“chess-board” to the “lamellar” motif for BTP-1 based mon-
olayers was found to be too fast for being visualized in real-
time with our experimental set-up, due to hardware limita-
tions.[11] Gratifyingly, under the same experimental condi-
tions the structural reorganization of the BTP-2 monolayer
from “rosette” to “tetragon” motif could be monitored in
real-time on the timescale of several tens of minutes, taking
advantage of the slower nature of the process. The observed
slower switching kinetics are caused by the longer alkoxy
chains of BTP-2, providing an increased desorption energy
on graphite[14] and hence a partial hindrance towards reor-
ganization of the self-assembled motif. Figure 3 shows a set
of measurements where the “rosette” domains are gradually
converted into “tetragon” ones in the vicinity of a HOPG
step over a time scale of 20 min, the latter “tetragon” pack-
ing becoming the more favorable over time. The total cover-
age of the surface by the “tetragon” assembly is completed
a few hours after the deposition of the droplet of the acidi-
fied solution. The fuzzy parts on the STM images corre-
spond to areas where the considerable mobility of the mole-
cules, triggered by the protonation process, hinders high res-
olution STM imaging. Such areas may include solvent mole-
cules as well.
In summary, for the first time we have utilized STM to
visualize large conformational changes of a responsive mo-
lecular building block resulting in its dramatically altered
self-assembly behavior at the solid–liquid interface. Protona-
tion can successfully be used to overcome the repulsive in-
teraction between the adjacent N atoms present in the neu-
tral “kinked” heteroaromatic BTP molecule and result in
the formation of an “extended” conformation on a HOPG
surface. This represents the first yet crucial step towards the
development of reversible pH triggered switches at the
solid-liquid interface. Furthermore, more sophisticated,
functionalized (macro)molecules are being synthesized in
order to control the adsorption conformation of extended
foldamers on solid substrate surfaces[16] and to switch benefi-
cial physico-chemical properties of the monolayer, in partic-
ular fluorescence[4] and conductivity.[3,9]
Experimental Section
Scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) measurements at the solid–liquid
interface have been carried out both in constant height and constant cur-
rent mode using a DI Multimode microscope. The STM tips have been
mechanically cut from a Pt/Ir (80:20) wire. Samples have been prepared
by applying a droplet of solution on freshly cleaved highly oriented pyro-
lytic graphite (HOPG). The molecules were dissolved in 1-phenyloctane
with an approximate concentration of 1 mmolLÀ1. The protonation of the
molecules was performed ex situ, by addition of trifluoroacetic acid
(TFA) to the solution containing the molecules before the deposition,
and in situ, that is, when an acidified solution of 1-phenyloctane was de-
The observed molecular switch occurring in a dynamic
scenario, that is, at the solid–liquid interface, differs from
previous STM evidences of pH-mediated conformational
switching for physisorbed organic systems that were detect-
ed on dry films.[15]
Chem. Eur. J. 2009, 15, 4788 – 4792
ꢃ 2009 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
4791