Tetrahedron Letters 50 (2009) 3008–3012
Tetrahedron Letters
An imidazolidin-1-ol, nitrone and oxadiazinane ring-chain-ring tautomeric
dynamic combinatorial library
*
Necdet Coßskun , Çag˘daßs Aksoy
Uludag˘ University, Department of Chemistry, 16059 Görükle-Bursa, Turkey
a r t i c l e i n f o
a b s t r a c t
Article history:
A dynamic combinatorial library (DCL) based on benzylidene exchange reactions between imidazolidin-
1-ol, nitrone and oxadiazinane (INO) ring-chain-ring tautomers at room temperature is created. The
probable mechanism of the reaction is discussed based on Hammett type correlation analyses. The equi-
libria in the DCL are defined as interconversion of INOAr-X to INOAr-Y as a result of reactions with the
Received 20 December 2008
Revised 18 March 2009
Accepted 27 March 2009
Available online 2 April 2009
corresponding aldehydes Y-ArCHO and X-ArCHO and are shown to depend on the
stituents and are described by a simple equation logKXY qrdif + logKXY(X = Y). The prediction of KXY for
any INOAr-X and INOAr-Y interconversion requires only the experimental values of and the known
constants of the substituents. The effect of Zn(II) and CF3SO3H on the DCL equilibria is also
r constants of the sub-
=
Keywords:
q
Ring-chain-ring tautomers
Dynamic combinatorial libraries
Linear free energy relationships
Benzylidene exchange reaction
Hammett
reported.
r
Ó 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Dynamic combinatorial chemistry1 (DCC) has added a new
dimension to the synthetic capability of combinatorial chemistry
exploiting reversible covalent chemistry to generate combinatorial
libraries that are under thermodynamic control. Since the library
members interconvert by equilibrium processes, any stabilization
of a given member of the library results in the thermodynamic
redistribution of the equilibrium to yield a new thermodynamic
equilibrium. Imines were first explored in a dynamic combinatorial
context in 1997 by Huc and Lehn,2 who described a virtual combi-
natorial library of imines the composition of which was influenced
by the presence of carbonic anhydrase as a ‘molecular trap’. Stabi-
lized imines, in the form of oximes and hydrazones,3 have since at-
tracted significant interest in DCC as they can provide kinetically
inert products without the need for subsequent reduction and
the attendant change in geometry and electronics. Eliseev and
co-workers have explored the use of O-aryl oximes to construct dy-
namic combinatorial libraries (DCLs).4 The relative degree of
amplification in the dynamic library will depend on the difference
in binding affinity of the library components to the template.5 The
identification of dynamic covalent bonds and the development of
catalysts which promote the fast exchange of covalent bonds are
crucial for furthering dynamic covalent chemistry.1b In this respect
creating DCLs based on scaffolds which could bind a compound to
give several products in equilibrium would be extremely impor-
tant for accessing richer DCLs than classical DCL scaffolds provide.
Recently, it was reported that nitrones are able to undergo dy-
namic exchange in non-polar solvents such as chloroform. By cou-
pling a nitrone-based replicator to a dynamic library based on
nitrone-imine exchange, it was demonstrated that a synthetic rep-
licator is able to exploit a network of reactions within a dynamic
library to amplify its own formation at the expense of other
species.6
Here we report on the benzylidene exchange reactions of imi-
dazolidin-1-ol, nitrone and oxadiazinane ring-chain-ring tauto-
meric mixtures (INOAr-X(Y))7 as
a
useful tool for the
construction of DCLs. The effect of substituents on the interconver-
sions of INOAr-X to INOAr-Y was investigated and correlations
with Hammett constants and their differences were performed to
elucidate the probable mechanism of the new benzylidene ex-
change reaction applied in the DCL formation.
Treatment of INOAr-X (X = H, R = p-MeOC6H4) in THF with an
equimolar amount of hydroxylamine hydrochloride8 dissolved in
MeOH at 25 °C for 4 h leads quantitatively to the corresponding
aldoxime and hydroxylaminoamine hydrochloride 3 (Scheme 1)
as confirmed by 1H NMR spectroscopy. A mixture of five aromatic
aldehydes was added to the in situ formed 3 and the resulting mix-
ture was left to equilibrate for 20 h.9 The 1H NMR analyses revealed
that compound 3 was fully consumed to give the corresponding
INOAr-X(Y) DCL. The concentrations of the aldehydes were moni-
tored by gas chromatography (Table 1). There are 25 inter IN-
OAr-X(Y) equilibria (Scheme 2) as depicted in Figure 1. Five of
the latter are between INOAr-X and Y-ArCHO where X = Y and
are non-productive.
The equilibrium constants KXY = [INOAr-Y][X-ArCHO]/[INOAr-
X][Y-ArCHO] for the equilibrium series A–E in the DCL were calcu-
lated and are presented in Table 2. A comparison of the equilibrium
series A–E clearly reveals the reactivity order of the aldehydes in
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +90 224 2941725.
0040-4039/$ - see front matter Ó 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.tetlet.2009.03.201