Full Paper
ency on the electron density of the substituent group (R2).
Thus, when aryl groups bearing electron-donating groups
(EDG) were used as substituents in R2, the corresponding lac-
tones were obtained in moderate-to-high yields in short reac-
tion times (entries 4, and 7–10). Although 5 mol% of gold was
used for the transformation of propargylic ester 16d (entry 4),
its conversion achieved the lowest yield among these exam-
ples. Lactone 17d bears only a methyl group at the aryl ring,
thus lacking of the mesomeric effect present in the other ex-
amples owing to the methoxy groups. By the same manner,
lactone 17g, bearing three methoxy groups at the aryl group,
was obtained in 65% yield after only 30 min of reaction
(entry 9). On the other hand, when aryl groups bearing elec-
tron-withdrawing groups (EWG), or without substituents, were
used, the formation of lactones 17 was not accomplished (en-
tries 5 and 6). In those cases, only decomposition and/or un-
substituted lactones (i.e. 18) were observed. These results indi-
cate that for these systems the carbocation formed is not
stable enough to enable the CÀC coupling with the vinyl gold
species, which instead undergoes simple protodeauration. The
formation of 17o and 17p (entries 19 and 20) was slower
(24 h). Different to the allylic ester in entry 19, the homoallylic
ester is not activated by the olefin, in the case of the cycloprop-
yl group there is also no kinetic benefit for the conversion.
Entry 23 shows a tertiary alcohol, in this case no reaction of
the substrate was detected and the starting material could be
reisolated. Because the preparation of such tertiary esters is
quite difficult, this lack of reactivity is no serious synthetic re-
striction.
Heteroaryl groups at the R2 position were also examined.
For this purpose, only p-excessive heterocycles, such as thio-
phene, were used. Thus, derivate 17i, bearing a methylthio-
phene substituent, could be obtained after 3 h in 62% yield
(entry 11). On the other hand furan did not convert (entry 12).
A vinyl group was also investigated as a substituent R2—no
conversion was observed even after 24 h at 408C (entry 13).
The fact that formation of the unsubstituted lactone (product
of the protodeauration of vinyl gold intermediate)
was not observed could be explained by considering
an extremely high activation energy related to a re-
markably lower stability of the migrating carbocation.
Therefore, it is possible to conclude that the forma-
tion of any product, in this case, is inhibited by a sig-
nificant increase in the activation energy needed to
form both intermediates; the vinyl gold species and
the migrating carbocation. This indicates that the for-
mation of these two species is strictly linked to the
stability of the carbocation. With these results in
mind, in the next experiments the R2 fragment was
kept constant, as an aryl group bearing a methoxy
substituent, and R3 was varied by using different al-
kynyl, alkenyl, and alkyl groups (entries 14–20). Deri-
vates 17j and 17k, possessing a terminal and an in-
ternal alkyne at the R3 position, respectively, were ob-
extra stabilization to the carbocation. Lactone 17n, possessing
an alkyl chain, could also be obtained in high yield after 3 h of
reaction (88%, entry 18). When a vinyl group was employed as
substituent, the initially formed carbocation has the possibility
to migrate into the allylic system. In this case, the product cor-
responding to the CÀC coupling between the vinyl gold spe-
cies and the less hindered carbocation was observed in 46%
yield (entry 19). No formation of the branched product was de-
tected. An allylic moiety at the R3 position avoids this problem
and still offers the stabilization needed to perform the reaction.
Thus, derivate 17p was obtained in 65% after 24 h of reaction
(entry 20). Finally, taking into account the high stability of cy-
clopropyl carbonium ions,[15] stabilization coming from cyclo-
propyl rings was investigated. Derivate 17q, bearing a phenyl
group and a cyclopropyl ring, was satisfactorily obtained in
47% yield after 24 h (entry 21). This result corroborates the
higher stabilization coming from the cyclopropyl ring, as prop-
argylic ester 16e, bearing also a phenyl ring, but instead of
the cyclopropyl ring an alkyne moiety, could not be trans-
formed into the desired lactone (entry 5). When two cycloprop-
yl rings were used as substituents only decomposition was ob-
served (entry 22).
These results indicate that the high stabilizing effect from an
aromatic substituent is needed to diminish the activation
energy, allowing the formation of the migrating carbocation
and the vinyl-gold-species intermediate. It is possible to con-
clude, that when an aromatic ring bearing EDGs is present at
the R2 position, the synthesis of highly substituted lactones
bearing terminal and internal alkynyl, alkenyl, alkyl, cycloalkyl
groups, and aromatic moieties takes place in moderate-to-high
yields.
As mentioned before, an isomerization of lactones 17 bear-
ing an alkyne moiety was observed when the gold-catalyzed
reaction was purified by chromatography using Al2O3 instead
of silica gel. This type of isomerization has been reported by
Larock and co-workers and Hashmi and co-workers in the syn-
thesis of allenyl ketones.[13] Figure 2 depicts the allenyl-substi-
Figure 2. Isomerization of lactones 17 to allenyl-substituted lactones 20. [a] Yield in pa-
rentheses refers to the one-pot gold-catalyzed reaction and isomerization starting from
propargylic esters 16 (conditions: column chromatography on aluminum oxide using
tained in moderate-to-high yield (entries 14 and 15).
The best yield was achieved with derivate 17m bear-
ing a phenyl group (89%, entry 17), which offers hexane/ethyl acetate).
Chem. Eur. J. 2014, 20, 1 – 8
5
ꢁ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
&
&
These are not the final page numbers! ÞÞ