COMMUNICATION
pose of our initial investigation was to develop this concept
and to delineate the reactivity of 1 towards the metal-cata-
lyzed hydroboration reaction. As a test reaction, we subject-
ed methylene- and alkylidenecyclopropanes to pinacol
borane (HBPin, 1.1 equiv) in the presence of the Wilkinson
catalyst (0.5 mol%) in CH2Cl2 at room temperature as
shown in Table 1.[8] We chose to use pinacolborane (HBPin)
which would have resulted from the most substituted
carbon–carbon bond ring-cleavage (through reductive elimi-
nation of 4). Only the non-substituted proximal bond under-
goes the ring cleavage to give the corresponding acyclic
alkyl–rhodium intermediate 3, which leads to 5 after reduc-
tive elimination (Scheme 2).[12] Therefore, the Rh-catalyzed
hydroboration of methylenecyclopropane derivatives is a re-
markable combination of several consecutive chemical steps
that proceeds to cleanly lead to the unique formation of 5.
Whatever the methylenecyclopropane derivatives used
(Table 1, entries 1 and 2) a single isomer 5 was always ob-
tained, even when a potentially tertiary benzylic organome-
tallic species could be formed (Table 1, entry 2). When al-
Table 1. Rh-catalyzed hydroboration of MCPs and ACPs.
ACHUTNGRENkNUG ylACHUTNGTRENiNGUN denecyclopropane derivatives were engaged in the same
Entry
R1
R2
R3
Yield 5 [%][a]
Yield 8 [%][b]
reaction (R3 =alkyl or aryl), the chemical outcome is similar
and excellent isolated yields of the single ring-opened prod-
ucts 5 were obtained (no traces of 6, Table 1, entries 3–8).
Following oxidation with hydrogen peroxide and reduction
of the double bond,[13] the resulting saturated alcohols 8c–h
were isolated by column chromatography in excellent yields.
Following our initial success with pinacol borane, we further
decided to investigate the rhodium- and palladium-catalyzed
addition of silanes[14] and stannanes,[15] respectively, of alkyli-
denecyclopropane derivatives and confirm that a selective
ring-opening should also be observed as described in
Table 2.[16] We were pleased to see that the RhI-catalyzed
hydrosilylation of alkylidenecyclopropanes (method A)[14]
also proceeds with selective cleavage of the less substituted
carbon–carbon bond of the cyclopropane ring according to
our mechanistic hypothesis described in Scheme 2. Only ho-
moallylsilanes 9 were produced in good to excellent isolated
yields (see Table 2, method A, entries 1–7). Moreover, the
reaction is stereoselective as the E/Z ratios of homoallylsil-
1 (1a)
2 (1b)
3 (1c)
4 (1d)
5 (1e)
6 (1 f)
7 (1g)
8 (1h)
Bu
Me
Bu
Me
Me
Me
Me
Me
Hex
Ph
Et
Et
Ph
Et
Bu
Hex
H
90 (5a)
89 (5b)
81 (5c)
83 (5d)
83 (5e)
80 (5 f)
84 (5g)
90 (5h)
81 (8a)[c]
81 (8b)[c]
87 (8c)
83 (8d)
81 (8e)
87 (8 f)
81 (8g)
85 (8h)
H
Me[d]
(CH2)2Ph[d]
ACHTUNGTRENNUNG
A
Ph[d]
Ph[d]
Ph[d]
[a] Boronate esters 5 are unstable by column chromatography and yields
were determined by 1H NMR spectroscopy. [b] Isolated yields after pu-
rification by column chromatography. [c] Yields determined based on the
non-reduced double bond. [d] Mixture of geometrical isomers was ob-
tained E/Z 2:1. [e] Mixture of geometrical isomers was obtained E/Z 4:1.
because the reductive elimination to form the carbon–boron
bond is slower than other boronate esters (i.e., catechol
borane), a feature attributed to pinacolboraneꢁs lower Lewis
acidity.[9] Our choice of a less reactive substrate would ideal-
ly stack the deck in favor of ring-opening as opposed to
direct addition. Remarkably, the reaction proceeds smoothly
and when methylenecyclopro-
pane (MCP) 1a was subjected
to our experimental conditions,
a single boronate ester 5a was
observed (Table 1, entry 1).
The formation of the isomer
5a could be rationalized
through the following mecha-
nism (Scheme 2).[10] Oxidative
addition of the catalyst into
À
the H B bond of HBPin gives
the corresponding metal hy-
dride species that add to the
double bond of MCP 1 through
a hydrometalation reaction to
form the alkyl metal 2.[11]
The ring-opening process is
indeed faster than reductive
elimination, since no cyclopro-
pylborane 7 was detected in
the crude reaction mixture.
Moreover, the ring opening is
selective, since we could not
detect the formation of 6,
Scheme 2. Mechanistic hypothesis.
Chem. Eur. J. 2010, 16, 774 – 778
ꢀ 2010 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
775