R.A. Lowe, et al.
Bioorganic&MedicinalChemistry28(2020)115442
2% of the ZINC database of commercially-available compounds.29 Only
two of the 16 final scaffolds were found as substructures of these
compounds: the pyrimidine-containing scaffold and the parent tropane
core.
2.3. Design, synthesis and evaluation of a small molecule library based on
diverse tropane-related scaffolds
A range of building blocks was prepared in which the protecting
groups were chosen to enable decoration of the scaffolds at com-
plementary positions (Scheme 7). Hydrogenation of the enone 11b
tion, alkene and ketone reduction and isopropylation (by reaction with
acetone) to give the hydroxyl-substituted tropane 24. Reductive ami-
nation of the ketone 12c, by treatment with methylamine, Ti(OiPr)4 and
then sodium borohydride gave the secondary amine 25 in 41% and
with high diastereoselectivity; the relative configuration of similar re-
ductive amination products was determined by NOESY analysis
(Supplementary Information). In a similar vein, reaction of the ketones
22c, 22d and 7d with iBu2AlH was moderately diastereoselective
(crude dr observed with these substrates: 22c, 75:25; 22d, 90:10; 7d,
75:25) and, after purification, yielded the corresponding alcohols 27a,
27b and 28 as single diastereomers. Finally, hydrogenolysis of 22a, 27b
and 28 yielded the corresponding debenzylated building blocks 26, 27c
and 29. The relative configurations of 27a, 27b and the 2-methyl-
propionamide of 29 were determined by X-ray crystallography
(Supporting Information).30
A set of 53 screening compounds based on many of the tropane-
related scaffolds was designed and prepared. In addition to compounds
that had already been prepared (6a, 6b, 8b, 8c, 8d, 12c, 13, 14, 16, 17,
18a, 18b, 19a, 19b, 20a, 20b, 20c, 20d, 22e, 24, 25, 27a, 27c and
29), additional compounds were also synthesised by derivatisation of
building blocks (see Scheme 7) with a single capping group. Final
mated reverse-phase flash column chromatography; purification was
often challenging, and low yield of purified products were often ob-
tained using these methods. The synthesis of ten exemplar screening
compounds (see Fig. 3, Panel A) is summarised in Table 2 (see also
shape diversity (Panel C) of the screening compounds is summarised in
properties, and are more three-dimensional than many screening sets.31
The 53 final compounds were screened in two phenotypic assays
that were selected as representative applications of the library. It was
intended that these assays would enable a preliminary assessment of the
biological relevance of the scaffolds accessible using the unified syn-
thetic approach. An osteoblast differentiation assay32 was used to
screen the compounds, initially at 10 μM, for inhibition of Hedgehog
signalling. The dose-dependent activity of hits, identified on the basis of
at least 50% inhibition of signallig and < 20% impact on cell viability,
was determined. In addition, a screen against a NF54 (chloroquine-
susceptible) P. falciparum strain was performed in dose-response mode
in which lactate dehydrogenase activity served as a marker for parasite
viability.33 The dose-dependent activity of the active compounds from
both assays is shown in Figure 4. Two inhibitors of Hedgehog signalling
were discovered (38 and 39; Panel A), both of which were based on a
tetracyclic indotropane scaffold that is a substructure of some known8b
inhibitors of this pathway (such as 3, Fig. 1). Four compounds with
weak antiplasmodium activity were also identified (16, 20, 40 and 41;
Panel B); these compounds were based on four distinct tropane-related
scaffolds that had been prepared. We note that three of the active
compounds may be considered to be pseudo natural products in which a
tropane is fused with a fragment from another natural product class: 38
and 39 are indotropanes and 41 is a pyrrolotropane.9
Scheme 7. Synthesis of building blocks for library synthesis.
and the enone of 11 g and 11 h gave the tetrahydroquinotropanes 6a
and 6b.
Substitution of the enones 11 was possible at alternative positions
(Scheme 6). Rh-catalysed conjugate addition25 of aryl-boronic acids to
the enones 11b and 11c yielded the corresponding aryl-substituted
tropanes 22a-e with high diastereoselectivity. The relative configura-
tion of derivatives of 22c and 22d was determined by X-ray crystal-
lography (vide infra). In addition, a Bayliss-Hillman reaction of the
enone 11a yielded the hydroxymethyl-substituted enone 23.
The unified approach had enabled the synthesis of sixteen distinct
deprotected graph-node-bond level26 scaffolds in which alpha atoms
had been removed. The diversity of these scaffolds may be captured in
terms of an hierarchical tree27 that formalises the relationship between
LLAMA28 to assess the novelty of the scaffolds with respect to a random
5