FULL PAPERS
procedure[7] to construct both structural motifs, as it only
produces water as waste. In addition, compound 2 can be
prepared in a single step from isatins, whereas precursor iii
or iv for coupling reactions are usually obtained by two
steps from isatins or anilines.[8] The synthesis of symmetrical
3,3-diaryloxindoles from isatins and arenes in the presence
of a large excess amount of strong acids or superacids was
known.[4a,b] The reaction of 3-hydroxy-3-aryloxindoles and l-
tyrosine derivatives promoted by 5.0 equivalents of trifluor-
omethanesulfonic acid (TfOH) was developed by Nicolaou
et al. during the synthesis of diazonamide A.[2a] They also
found that the use of 20 mol% of TfOH or some metal tri-
flates led to the decomposition of starting materials.[2b] De-
spite their achievements, the catalytic versions of this reac-
tion were very limited, possibly because the formation of
the carbocationic intermediate was difficult due to the elec-
tron-withdrawing effect of the amide group of 3-hydroxyox-
indole 2. By now, only Lewis acid catalyzed arylation of isa-
tins with indoles or N,N-dimethylaniline to symmetric 3,3-
diaryl oxindoles, and the arylation of 3-indolyl-3-hydroxyox-
indoles by using indoles or pyrroles have been reported,[3-
ration. For example, Barron et al. reported that the forma-
tion of stabilized arene–mercury complexes significantly in-
creased the acidity of the aromatic protons of the coordinat-
ed arenes. The thus-obtained stable arene–mercury com-
plexes could serve as highly efficient catalysts for the H/D
exchange reaction of C6D6 with arenes in which the coordi-
nated arene protonated C6D6.[13] Nishizawa and co-workers
identified HgACHTNUTRGNEUNG(OTf)2 as a highly efficient catalyst for a
number of transformations, including hydration of alkynes,
À
C C bond-forming cyclizations initiated from alkynes or al-
lylic alcohols, and heterocycle synthesis.[14b–l] Deslongchamps
et al. also contributed greatly to mercury catalysis.[14m] The
high catalytic efficiency and mild reaction conditions made
these transformations very useful, particularly when applied
to natural product synthesis.[15]
Although aromatic mercuration has been extensively
studied and Olah et al. have suggested that mercury–arene
complexes might be the intermediates by NMR spectroscop-
ic studies,[16] most of these studies focused on the use of a
stoichiometric amount of mercury salts to convert aromatic
compounds to arylmercurials, which were used as versatile
synthons in transition-metal-catalyzed coupling reactions.[17]
Whereas Barron et al. reported a highly efficient H/D ex-
change reaction of C6D6 with arenes catalyzed by a stabi-
lized arene–mercury complex that resulted from aromatic
d,9a–e]
which involved the formation of reactive vinylogous
iminium intermediates.[9f,g] To increase the structural diversi-
ty for structure–activity relationship studies, the catalytic
synthesis of unsymmetrical 3,3-diaryl oxindoles by means of
Friedel–Crafts arylation of 3-aryl-3-hydroxyloxindoles that
cannot form vinylogous iminium intermediates is highly de-
sirable but is unprecedented.
mercuration,[13] the highly efficient catalytic C C bond-
À
forming reactions initiated by aromatic mercuration have
not been reported as far as we know.[17] Here we wish to
report the unprecedented dual activation effects of aromatic
mercuration, which could generate a strong protic acid to fa-
cilitate the generation of a carbocationic intermediate and
simultaneously activate the aromatics to form more nucleo-
philic aryl mercurials. This would contribute to a highly effi-
cient Friedel–Crafts reaction of 3-hydroxyoxindoles and a
variety of aromatic compounds to furnish the congested
quaternary carbon center at the C3-position of oxindole.
Recently, much effort has been devoted to the exploration
of new catalytic properties of inexpensive and easily avail-
able metal salts such as iron, bismuth, and copper salts in or-
ganic synthesis.[10] Mercury, as an “element of mystery,”[11]
however, has received very limited attention, mainly due to
the concern about its toxicity.[12a,b] This is to some extent per-
plexing because mercury still has numerous applications in
many areas nowadays.[12] In industrial applications, mercury
could be used for barometers, manometers, gauges, high-in-
tensity discharge (HID) lamps, and as an electrode in the
electrolytic production of chlorine and caustic soda from
saline, and in electrical switches widely used in automobiles.
The application of mercury to extract gold and silver from
their respective ores continues to this day. Furthermore,
mercury and its chemical compounds still have medical ap-
plications nowadays. For example, mercury amalgam princi-
pally with silver is widely used as a tooth filling, and there is
no convincing evidence that dental amalgam leads to ad-
verse health effects.[12a] Thimerosal is still used in vaccines in
many countries, and the current scientific consensus is that
no convincing scientific evidence to support the thimerosal
controversy that mercury-containing vaccines lead to the de-
velopment of autism and brain development disorders.[12a,b]
In view of the aforementioned facts, academic research
that aims toward the discovery of new catalytic properties of
mercury compounds is still needed, although unnecessary
usage of mercury compounds in organic synthesis should be
avoided. In particular, recent studies have shown that mer-
cury compounds had interesting properties worthy of explo-
Results and Discussion
In our efforts to synthesize 3,3-disubstituted oxindoles for
biological evaluation,[18] we speculated that the formation of
a reactive carbocation at the C3-position from oxindole 2
might be difficult owing to the electron-withdrawing amide
group, therefore we tried to develop a catalytic arylation of
3-hydroxyindoles 2 by using Lewis acids with weak-coordi-
nating counteranions that might enhance the catalytic prop-
erty of Lewis acids.[19] Given that inexpensive and easy-to-
handle metal perchlorate hydrates with a weak-coordinating
anion had been identified as powerful Lewis acids for a
number of reactions,[20] we first examined a series of metal
perchlorate hydrates in the reaction of 3-hydroxyoxindole
2b and N-methylindole 3a by using tetrahydrofuran (THF)
as the solvent in the presence of 10 mol% catalyst. Some
typical results are shown in Table 1.
It was found that InIII-, AlIII-, CrIII-, CuII-, ZnII-, CoII-, NiII-
, and AgI-derived metal perchlorate hydrates all failed to
234
ꢀ 2012 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Chem. Asian J. 2012, 7, 233 – 241