ACS Medicinal Chemistry Letters
Letter
supercoiling by gyrase and relaxation by Topo IV, nb4.6 only
inhibited topo-IV-mediated relaxation. For Topo IV-mediated
decatenation of kDNA, E. coli Topo IV was incubated with
kDNA and 200 μM of one of the test compounds (Figure 1C).
Only nz7 completely blocked the decatenation reaction (lane
4), while nb4.6 partially inhibited decatenation (lane 5). Thus,
Both nz7 and nb4.6 inhibited Topo IV activity in both
relaxation and decatenation assays, though the inhibitory effect
of nb4.6 was more pronounced in the relaxation assay.
The observed differential inhibition of bacterial type-II
topoisomerases by select N-arylacyl O-sulfonated aminoglyco-
sides may be due to the degree of sulfation, the N-arylacyl
moiety, the core aminoglycoside, or a combination these
structural differences. As shown in Figure 1A, nz7 inhibited the
gyrase-mediated supercoiling reaction. Since more highly
sulfated heparin derivatives are more potent inhibitors of
topo I,8 N-cbz O-sulfonated neomycin with an average degree
of sulfation of 5.6 (nz5.6) was screened along with persulfated
nz7 to determine concentration-dependent inhibition of gyrase-
mediated supercoiling of relaxed DNA (Figure 1D). Although
100 μM of nz5.6 only partially inhibited gyrase activity (lane
6), 200 μM of nz5.6 completely inhibited the supercoiling
activity of gyrase (lane 7). Comparatively, 50 μM of nz7
partially inhibited gyrase (lane 11), while 100 μM of nz7
completely inhibited gyrase supercoiling activity (lane 12).
Thus, nz7 is about twice as potent as nz5.6. While this result
demonstrates the importance of sulfate groups for these
particular neomycin derivatives to inhibit gyrase, the overall
data in Figure 1 clearly shows the influence of N-arylacyl
moieties and the core aminoglycoside for selective inhibition of
the bacterial type-II topoisomerases.
heparin-binding proteins have poor affinity for sulfated
polysaccharides less than octasaccharide in length.
Only select N-arylacyl O-sulfonated aminoglycoside that have
both N-arylacyl groups and sulfate groups on a certain
aminoglycoside scaffold inhibited different topoisomerases to
different degrees (Table 1 and Figure 1). This result is
consistent with previous studies for N-desulfonated, N-acyl
derivatives of heparin, where only select N-arylacyl groups
could be substituted in place of N-sulfo groups to maintain or
increase affinity for select heparin-binding proteins.14−16 In
addition to the aryl groups on these tri- and tetra-saccharide-
sized compounds being necessary for topoisomerase inhibition,
these results show that both the structure of the core
aminoglycoside and the structure of the N-arylacyl moiety
imparts selectivity for which the topoisomerase(s) are inhibited.
For example, among the N-cbz O-sulfonated aminoglycosides,
only az4.9 showed greater than 90% inhibition of all four
topoisomerases tested (Table 1). The N-cbz kanamycin
derivative kz6, which is more highly sulfated than az4.9,
showed 75% inhibition of gyrase and greater than 95%
inhibition of hTopo I but did not inhibit either Topo IV or
hTopo II. The cognate N-cbz neomycin derivative, nz5.6,
showed greater than 95% inhibition of gyrase, hTopo II, and
hTopo I, but it did not inhibit Topo IV.
To better understand the mechanism of topoisomerase
inhibition, the N-arylacyl O-sulfonated aminoglycosides were
coadministered with ciprofloxacin to evaluate their ability to
interfere with ciprofloxacin-induced DNA cleavage. Ciproflox-
acin is a known topoisomerase poison that, when incubated
with a bacterial type II topoisomerase and DNA, induces DNA
cleavage by arresting the enzyme and its DNA substrate in a
ternary complex that prevents religation of the double stranded
break in the DNA.23−25
To more fully evaluate the role of sulfate groups, core
structure, and N-arylacyl group on selective topoisomerase
interactions, the complete panel of N-arylacyl and N-acetyl
aminoglycosides, both O-sulfonated and bearing no sulfate,
were screened for inhibitory activity with four topoisomerases:
E. coli gyrase, E. coli Topo IV, hTopo II, and hTopo I (Table 1).
Incubation of E. coli Topo IV with a plasmid DNA affords
mainly supercoiled DNA, and small amounts of nicked and
linear DNA (Figure 2, lane 2). The addition of ciprofloxacin
Table 1. Percent Inhibition of Catalytic Activity for Different
Type I and Type II Topoisomerases
a
drug
gyrase
Topo IV
hTopo II
hTopo I
az4.9
kb6.4
kz6
90%
85%
75%
b
95%
80%
95%
>95%
60%
>95%
>95%
70%
kp5.8
na1−6
nz5.6
np5.9
Figure 2. Select N-arylacyl O-sulfonated aminoglycosides block
ciprofloxacin-induced cleavage of DNA by TopoIV.
>95%
95%
>95%
>95%
>95%
>95%
>95%
a
b
Compounds screened at 200 μM. Blank spaces: <5% inhibition.
stimulates the production of linear, cleaved DNA (Figure 2,
lane 3). Ciprofloxacin-induced DNA cleavage is completely
blocked by nz7 (Figure 2, lane 5), while ab0 and nb4.6
produce a slight decrease (Figure 2, lanes 4 and 6). No effect
on ciprofloxacin-induced DNA cleavage was seen with aa3−5
or ab4.1 (Figure 2, lanes 7 and 8).
The effect of N-arylacyl O-sulfonated aminoglycosides on
ciprofloxacin-induced DNA cleavage by gyrase was similarly
investigated (Table 2). With gyrase, kz6 and nz5.6 completely
blocked the production of ciprofloxacin-induced linear DNA,
while np5.9, kb6.4, and az4.9 partially blocked ciprofloxacin-
induced DNA cleavage. These results indicate that, despite the
structural homologies between gyrase and Topo IV,17
compounds az4.9, kb6.4, and np5.9 block ciprofloxacin-
None of the unsulfated N-arylacyl aminoglycosides (azo, kb0,
kz0, kp0, na0, nz0, and np0) inhibited any topoisomerase
(data not shown). The presence of sulfate groups on the N-acyl
aminoglycosides was not alone sufficient to afford topoisomer-
ase inhibition; neither of the N-acetyl O-sulfonated amino-
glycosides (aa3−5 and na1−6) inhibited any of the top-
oisomerases. Indeed, sulfated dextran oligosaccharides with a
degree of polymerization of 14 are capable of inhibiting hTopo-
I.22 Some DNA-binding and heparin-binding proteins, such as
fibroblast growth factor-I, will bind persulfated disaccharides
like sucrose octasulfate and sulfonated polyaromatics like
suramin with weak affinity. However, most DNA-binding and
472
dx.doi.org/10.1021/ml3004507 | ACS Med. Chem. Lett. 2013, 4, 470−474