.
Angewandte
Communications
As illustrated in entries 1–6 of Table 3, various alcohol
substitution patterns were tolerated, with the a,a-disubsti-
tuted alcohols 17 and 20 providing the highest level of
enantioselectivity (> 95% ee). The meso-dieneol 22 provides
a 6:1 ratio of diastereomers favoring the trans-substituted
tetrahydrofuran 23, even though the minor cis diastereomer
24 is formed with higher enantioselectivity (Table 3, entry 6).
Both electron-rich (p-MeO) and electron poor (p-F) 1,1-
diaryl ethylenes can be used in the coupling (Table 3, entries 7
and 8). It should be noted that conversion of the alkene of the
product into an aldehyde should be facile[13b] and would
extend their utility beyond diarylalkenes. Net benzofuran and
indole coupling adducts 26 and 28 were obtained by reaction
of the alkenols with heterocyclic vinylarenes 25 and 27,[24]
respectively (Table 3, entries 9 and 10). Additionally, both 4-
methoxy- and 4-tert-butyl styrene served as the vinylarene
component in this coupling reaction, thus giving homoallylic
ethers 30 and 31, respectively, in moderate yield and high
enantioselectivity (Table 3, entries 11 and 12).
The high enantioselectivity was used to further probe the
mechanism of this novel reaction. Involvement of the chiral
copper catalyst in the alkene addition step is evident from the
observed reaction enantioselectivity. This step is thought to
occur by enantioselective cis-oxycupration.[19] Cis-oxycupra-
tion presupposes that the alcohol moiety of the substrate first
coordinates to the copper(II) center in preference to the
alkene. This interaction is supported by reported coordination
preferences of copper(II) complexes.[25] An alternative trans-
oxycupration mechanism was thus considered less likely. To
further probe the enantiodetermining alkene addition step,
the pro-S (major) and pro-R (minor) cis-oxycupration tran-
sition states were modeled using density functional theory
calculations.
Unrestricted density functional theory calculations were
performed at the B3LYP/6-31 + G(d)[26–30] level of theory
using the Gaussian 09 software suite.[31] Single-point calcu-
lations using the polarizable continuum model[32] were carried
out to determine the solvation free energy, but CH2Cl2 (e =
8.93) was used instead of PhCF3 (e = 9.18) as the program
does not contain parameters for the latter. Calculations of the
pro-S (major) and pro-R (minor) cis-oxycupration transition
states at 1008C for 15 are illustrated in Figure 2. The major
transition state is 1.59 kcalmolÀ1 lower in Gibbs free energy,
thus translating to a calculated ee value of 79.1% (82% is
experimentally observed, Table 3, entry 2). While no steric
interactions of 2.2 ꢀ or less were observed in the major
transition state, two were observed in the minor transition
state, one between a substrate terminal alkene H and a ligand
backbone H, and another between a substrate a-carbon H
and a ligand backbone H (Figure 2). The Supporting Infor-
mation contains full details of the computational method-
ology employed, as well as in-depth analysis of the most
important computational results.
Figure 2. a) Calculated major transition state. b) Calculated minor
transition state. DDG° =1.59 kcalmolÀ1 (79.1% ee).
of the major transition state indicates that the unpaired
electron resides mainly on copper(II) (46%) but the emer-
À
gent terminal carbon atom (C1 Cu bond) also picks up spin
(26%) as does the oxygen adding to the alkene (21%).
Mulliken charge analysis indicates the internal alkene carbon
atom (C2) increases in positive charge from 0.16 in the
substrate to 0.95 at the major transiton state, and analysis of
the Wiberg bond indices[33–35] indicates the C1 Cu bond is
À
À
68% formed while the C2 O bond is 45% formed in the
major transition state. Taken together, these data support an
alkene addition with substantial polar character, though
radical contributions cannot be discounted. Tetrahedral
twist angle measurements indicate the major transition state
is a distorted tetrahedron (16.58 less than a perfect tetrahe-
dron) about the copper center, while the minor transition
state is almost perfectly tetrahedral. Natural Bond Order
(NBO) analysis of the two transition states indicate there are
more favorable bonding interactions in the major transition
state than in the minor.
In conclusion, we have rendered the copper-catalyzed
carboetherification of 4-alkenols highly enantioselective. We
have developed a new intra/intermolecular coupling reaction
of 4-alkenols with vinyl arenes and it results in net alkyl Heck-
type products where the alkyl component consists of an
enantiomerically enriched tetrahydrofuran. This reaction
extends the scope of what is possible by polar/radical reaction
cascades.[36] The enantioselectivity of the reaction can be
greater than 95% ee, and the absolute stereochemistry of the
major products was definitively assigned. DFT transition-
state calculations are consistent with a cis-oxycupration
stereodetermining transition state and there is good agree-
ment between experimental and calculated levels of enantio-
The electronic structure of the transition states was
further analyzed. Data were obtained in both vacuum and
dichloromethane; the latter is shown here. Inclusion of
solvent effects via single point calculations on gas phase
geometries did not have a notable effect on the results (see
the Supporting Information for a comparison). Spin analysis
4
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2014, 53, 1 – 6
These are not the final page numbers!