Communication
case.[16,17] The catalytic cycle would conclude with the diazoni-
um species in C reacting with the urea-stabilized anion (XÀ) to
generate the observed insertion products (4 or 6). The weak
interaction of 4 or 6 with difluoroboronate urea 1a would
then free the urea to re-enter the catalytic cycle.
Table 1. Aryldiazoacetate substrate scope.
Entry
1
4
Yield [%][a] Aryldiazoester
3
Entry
6
6
Yield [%][a]
More concrete insight into the proposed reaction pathway
was collected through the execution of strategically selected
experiments (Scheme 4b–d). We first attempted to trap a po-
tential donor/acceptor carbene intermediate through an intra-
molecular cyclopropanation of the olefin in the cinnamyl alco-
hol-derived a-aryldiazoacetate 3g (Scheme 4b).[18] When 3g
was subjected to the standard OÀH insertion reaction condi-
tions, we observed only formation of the a-acetoxyester 4q.
Importantly, when acetic acid was omitted from the reaction,
under otherwise identical reaction conditions, we observed no
reaction after 48 h at 238C. Moreover, when 3g was subjected
to high temperatures in PhCF3, reaction conditions known to
generate free carbenes from aryldiazoacetates,[19] 87% of exo-
(Æ)-7 was isolated as a single diastereomer. Collectively, this
data contends the formation of a free donor/acceptor carbene
intermediate under the optimal reaction conditions.
4l 66
4m 89
3b
6j 65[b,c]
2
3
3c
3d
3e
7
8
9
6k 81
4n 57[d]
6l 72[c]
4
5
4o 76
4p 50
6m 75[b]
3 f 10
6n 91
Further support of the proposed mechanism, depicted in
Scheme 4c, can be seen when the XÀH bond is not present
for HBD activation. For example, when triethylammonium ace-
tate or sodium benzoate were utilized under the optimal reac-
tion conditions, no reaction was observed. Similarly, when
sodium thiophenolate was added to the standard SÀH inser-
tion conditions, the expected product 6a was not formed in
any appreciable amount, demonstrating that the XÀH bond is
crucial for the insertion to occur. Confident that the reaction
was proceeding through an initial protonation event, we were
also curious if the catalyst could be involved in a direct proto-
nation of the a-aryldiazoester. To probe this question, the most
active diazo compound surveyed during our studies (3a) was
subjected to one equivalent of catalyst 1a in [D3]acetonitrile
for 24 h at 238C (Scheme 4d). Under these conditions, we
were unable to detect formation of 8, the product known to
form from deprotonation and isomerization of the urea cata-
[a] Yields are of isolated product [b] Reaction time 72 h. [c] Reaction temper-
ature 508C. [d] Reaction time 48 h. Reactions were performed at 0.5m with
respect to 3 (see the Supporting Information for elaborative experimental
details). The XÀH insertion conditions are identical to those shown in
Scheme 4 unless otherwise noted.
89% yield (entry 2). Similarly, 3c underwent insertion efficiently
into thiophenol to afford 6k (81%, entry 7). Halogens as the
sole substituent were also accepted; 3d underwent both OÀH
and SÀH insertion at room temperature, albeit longer reaction
times were required to provide 4n and 6l in 57 and 72%, re-
spectively (entries 3 and 8). As was expected, inductively do-
nating groups facilitated the insertion process; both acetic
acid and thiophenol underwent insertion by 3e more efficient-
ly than 3b, providing 10% higher yields in each of the studied
insertion reactions (entries 4 and 9). Unfortunately, the electron
poor a-aryldiazoester, methyl 4-(trifluoromethyl)phenyldiazoa-
cetate was inoperable in both insertion reactions, plausibly
due to its relatively poor basicity. The heteroaryl a-diazoester
3 f also operated well in the insertion reactions; insertion of 3 f
into acetic acid provided the a-acetoxyester 4p in 50% yield
(entry 5), whereas insertion into thiophenol occurred efficiently
providing 6n in 91% (entry 10).
Our working hypothesis of the catalytic cycle is depicted in
Scheme 4a. The process is thought to begin with coordination
of the difluoroboronate urea to the acidic heteroatom (XÀH),
forming complex B.[14,15] This complexation enables the amplifi-
cation of the acidity of the organic acid, which in the presence
of a Brønsted basic diazo compound, undergoes a proton
transfer through species D. The proton transfer, converting D
1
lyst, to any measureable extent by H NMR spectroscopy.[20,21]
In summary, we have discovered that difluoroboronate ureas
are unique metal-free catalysts for OÀH and SÀH insertion re-
actions of aryldiazoacetates. This innovative approach for diazo
insertion chemistry is believed to occur through hydrogen
bonding to suitable functionalities giving a urea-induced or-
ganic-acid enhancement. The reaction tolerates an assortment
of carboxylic acids and thiols, enabling the efficient prepara-
tion of a wide array of a-acyloxyesters and a-mercaptoesters
under mild reaction conditions. The utility of urea-induced or-
ganic acid amplification as a tool for metal-free, enantioselec-
tive insertion chemical technologies is of current interest in
our laboratory.
to C, may be rate determining in this process because it has Acknowledgements
been shown that a-aryldiazoacetate hydrolysis occurs through
The Ohio State University (OSU), Department of Chemistry and
a general acid-catalyzed A-SE2 mechanism, although additional
studies are required to provide tangible evidence in this
Biochemistry, and Donors of the American Chemical Society
Chem. Eur. J. 2014, 20, 1 – 6
3
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
&
&
These are not the final page numbers! ÞÞ