Communications
ability order: IÀ >BrÀ >ClÀ >FÀ. The remained glucoside 1 in
one hour were 28, 41, 43, and 91% and in four hours were 22,
26, 32, and 84%, respectively, for TBAI, TBABr, TBACl, and TBAF.
The same activation order was obtained when BnCl was used
instead of BnBr (Table S1).
Table 1. Recorded unreacted starting material at various conditions for
Ag2O-mediated benzylation of glucoside 1.[a]
For halide anions, the softness follows the order: IÀ >BrÀ >
ClÀ >FÀ, the order seen above for activation ability. Thus, the
hard–soft acid–base (HSAB) principle may provide an explana-
tion as to how KI activated the Ag2O-mediated protections. For
Ag2O, oxide anion is a hard base, and Ag+ is a soft acid. Thus,
when Ag2O encounters a soft base such as BrÀ or IÀ, the soft
Ag+ preferentially coordinates to the soft base BrÀ or IÀ, lead-
ing to the formation of AgOÀ (Figure 1). AgOÀ, a much stron-
ger base than Ag2O, deprotonates the hydroxyl group, then
followed by benzylation with BnBr to regenerate AgOÀ and
AgBr and restart the cycle. Consequently, a softer anion would
be an initiator and show higher activation ability in these reac-
tions. As can be seen (entry 11 in Table 1), the soft sulfur anion
also appeared activation ability for the reaction. Without con-
sideration of the essential reason (HSAB principle), the positive
effect of catalytic amount of halides (X) could be simply ex-
plained by the precipitation of AgX, with the formation of
basic species AgOÀ. The relative solubility of AgX in acetoni-
trile follows the order: AgI>AgBr>AgCl>AgF, the order seen
above for activation ability. The basicity in the reaction simply
depends on the amount of halides and remains unchanged
until Ag2O is depleted. Without the addition of halides, there is
no AgOÀ formed, thus the benzylation showing low reactivity.
According to this mechanism, we hypothesized that the addi-
tion of a catalytic amount of hydroxyl anion should also trigger
the activation process. As can be seen (entry 12 in Table 1), the
addition of 0.1 equiv. of NaOH proved efficient. The conversion
of Ag2O to AgI and hydroxide in aqueous iodide solution on
open-circuit potential has been reported.[8] The enhanced ba-
sicity can also be confirmed by the measurement of pH values
(Figure S2, S3). The results indicate that Ag2O (6 mg) or TBABr
(8 mg) alone in water (1 mL) appears roughly 6–7 of pH value,
whereas the mixture of Ag2O (6 mg) with TBABr (8 mg) in
water appears roughly 13–14 of pH value. Powder X-ray dif-
fraction (XRD) data indicated the formation of AgBr after Ag2O
and KBr were mixed thoroughly (Figure S4). It was reported
that AgOK were obtained as colorless, tetragonal single crystals
under very harsh condition.[9] Density functional theory (DFT)
calculations for four reactions of Ag2O with KX (X=F, Cl, Br, or
I) further support the proposed principle on the enhanced ba-
sicity of Ag2O by coordination to soft halides.
Entry Various conditions Reaction time [h] Unreacted substrate [%][b]
1
2
Only Ag2O
With KI
1
4
4
8
1
4
1
4
1
4
1
4
1
4
1
4
1
4
1
4
1
4
1
4
100
95
30
8
3
DCM as solvent
With KBr
48
27
88
59
75
44
28
22
94
92
41
26
43
32
91
84
87
76
49
28
4
5
With NaI
6
With TBAI
With KF
7
8
With TBAB
With TBACl
With TBAF
With Na2S
With NaOH
9
10
11
12
[a] Reagents and conditions: substrates (50 mg), Ag2O (1.1 equiv.), BnBr
(1.5 equiv.), M+XÀ (0.1 equiv.), RT. [b] NMR yield.
due to the formation of more reactive BnI from BnBr, the addi-
tion of 0.1 equiv. of KBr would be ineffective. However, when
KBr was tested (entry 4 in Table 1), the reaction remained
highly reactive, with 88% and 59% of unreacted 1 in 1 h and
4 h respectively, thus excluding the proposal that the im-
proved reactivity is due to the formation of more reactive BnI
(also see Figure S1). When sodium or tetrabutylammonium
(TBA) cations were used instead of the potassium cation, the
reaction remained highly reactive (entry 5, 6 in Table 1), indi-
cating that the cation does not play dominating role on the re-
activity. It was recently found that the acetylation of hydroxyl
groups with acetic anhydride can be activated by the forma-
tion of H-bonds between the hydroxyl groups and anions.[5a,b]
Thus, we firstly hypothesized that the activated benzylation by
KI was due to the formation of H-bonds between the hydroxyl
groups and iodide. If this was the case, the anions that can
form stronger H-bond with hydroxyl group should have higher
activation ability for benzylation, and the activation order
would be FÀ >ClÀ >BrÀ >IÀ. However the addition of KF
proved inefficient (entry 7 in Table 1). Considering about the
better solubility of tetrabutylammonium salts in acetonitrile, in
further experiments, 0.1 equiv. of tetrabutylammonium salts of
Br, Cl and F were used in the benzylations (entries 8–10 in
Table 1) to compare their activation ability with that of TBAI.
These experiments indicated an exactly opposite activation
The relative electronic energies in gas phase (DEgas) and sol-
vation-corrected relative electronic energies (DEsol) of the four
reactions [Eqs. (1–4)] were given. It is seen that both DEsol and
DEgas decrease in the order F>Cl>Br>I, indicating that the
stability of AgX follows the order AgF<AgCl<AgBr<AgI, con-
sistent with the HSAB principle that Ag+ as a soft acid forms
a stronger bond with softer bases such as IÀ. Moreover, ac-
cording to the stability of AgX, the ability to generate AgOK
from the reaction of Ag2O with KX is in the order KF<KCl<
KBr<KI. In other words, a great quantity of AgOK is generated
when Ag2O meets with KI, while little AgOK even without
&
ChemCatChem 0000, 00, 0 – 0
2
ꢀ 0000 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ÝÝ These are not the final page numbers!