J. Ren et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
3
Table 1
possibly due to the orientation change of benzonitrile moiety.
Menin inhibitory activity of compounds 9–11
Reducing the n length from 3 to 2 resulted in compounds 10 and
11 (x = O, N respectively) with decreased inhibitory activity about
20 folds, emphasizing the necessity of proper length to maintain
the hydrogen bond interaction with residue Trp341 (Table 1).
From compound 7, we first performed the optimization of the
R1 substituent on the phenyl ring. Introducing electron-donating
methyl or methoxy group resulted in compounds (12 and 13) with
similar activity. In contrast, introducing electron-withdrawing
cyano or trifluoromethyl group resulted in compounds (14 and
15) with more than 20-fold decrease in the inhibitory activity.
Additionally, compound 16 with fluorophenyl ring showed similar
activity as compound 7 (Table 2).
CF3
S
N
n
X
N
N
CN
N
Compd
N
x
Menin
IC50 (lM)
9
10
11
3
2
2
N
O
N
1.54 0.20
>20
>20
Eventually, we focused on the optimization of compound 8.
Molecular docking indicated that the thienopyrimidine part of
compound 8 adopted a similar mode with MI-2-2, and the benzyl
part attached to piperidine ring interacts with the Pro13 subpocket
of menin. We explored the SAR of the benzyl moiety, and found
that the absence of benzyl group significantly decreased the inhibi-
Table 2
Menin inhibitory activity of compounds 12–16
4
R1
3
CF3
tory activity for about 70-fold (compound 17, IC50 = 32.81 lM).
S
N
Similarly, replacing phenyl ring with more steric–hindered group
(18–20) showed much weaker activity. We replaced the benzyl
group with phenyl ethyl group to increase the flexibility, and the
resulting compound (21) showed slightly decreased activity about
4-fold. Aliphatic moieties were also introduced, yielding com-
pounds 22–23 with slightly weaker activity than compound 8. By
using the bioisosterism rules, we replaced the phenyl ring with
alkynyl group and heterocyclic rings to produce compounds 24–
NH
N
N
Compd
R
Menin
IC50
Compd
R
Menin
IC50 (lM)
(l
M)
12
13
14
3-Me
4-OMe
4-CN
3.80 0.41
1.07 0.12
33.4%@20 lM
15
16
4-CF3
4-F
18.5%@20
1.17 0.00
lM
27, and among which, compound 26 (IC50 = 0.22 lM) contained a
thiophene ring was about 2-fold more potent than compound 8
(Table 3).
We then explored the substitutions on the phenyl ring of com-
pound 8. With methoxyl substitution, the inhibitory activity of
compound 28 was similar to compound 8. In contrast, introduction
of 4-trifluoromethyl or 4-cyano resulted in compounds 29 and 30
with decreased inhibitory activity by more than 20-fold. But the
introduction of fluorine atom (compound 31) did not show much
decrease of activity. Similarly, 3-amino substituent reduced the
activity slightly, and 3-nitro lowered the activity significantly.
Overall, compounds substituted with electron-donating groups
were more potent than that with electron-withdrawing groups
(Table 4).
The molecular docking structure of menin with compound 8
revealed several negatively charged residues around the phenyl
ring, such as Asp285 and Glu363. On the basis of structure data,
we anticipated that introducing an appropriate positively charged
group, such as an amino moiety, should result in additional favor-
able electrostatic interactions with adjacent acidic residues. Differ-
ent linear amino alkyl groups were introduced to the 3-position of
phenyl ring and most of these compounds exhibited preferable
activity except for compound 37, which may be due to its steric
hindrance from N,N-dimethyl group. We also introduced piperi-
dine to the phenyl ring. The resulting compound 40 was found
with moderate inhibitory activity and compound 39 with weaker
activity (Table 5 and Fig. 3).
Table 3
Menin inhibitory activity of compounds 17–27
CF3
R
N
S
NH
N
N
Compd
R
Menin
Compd
R
Menin
IC50 (lM)
IC50
(
l
M)
17
18
H
32.81 6.77 23
5.67 0.56
2.4%@20
lM
24
25
26
31.3%@20
4.69 0.11
0.22 0.12
lM
O
19
20
15.6%@20
lM
S
N
4.6%@20
lM
21
22
1.80 1.39
0.77 0.03
27
2.70 0.42
We selected compounds 34 and 40 to dock into menin utilizing
the software GLIDE. The amino groups of compound 34 in the side
chain formed electrostatic interactions with Asp285, with a dis-
tance of 2.63 Å between N and O. The amino group of compound
40 extended to the opposite direction of Asp285, forming electro-
static interactions with Glu363. These predicted binding mode
highlighted that the positively charged groups in ligands can con-
tribute new interactions, which may provide a new direction for
the design of new inhibitors targeting the menin-MLL1 interaction.
Based on the previous studies, human leukemia cells expressing
MLL-AF4 were sensitive to menin inhibitors, such as MV-4-11 cell
line.19 However, K562 cell, another kind of chronic myelogenous
leukemia (CML) cell, is independent of the MLL1-menin proteins
and should not be sensitive to menin inhibitors. Disruption of the
menin–MLL1 fusion protein interaction is expected to result in
growth arrest of MLL leukemia cells. Therefore, we selected several
compounds to test their activity in MV-4-11 cells and K562 cells
(see the Supporting information for the experimental details). As
expected, strong and dose-dependent inhibition of cell prolifera-
tion was observed for compounds 5, 8, 26 and 35 in MV-4-11 cells,