Full Paper
liminary concentration-dependent 1H NMR spectroscopy ex-
periments in CDCl3. In good correlation with some other exam-
ples,[13] increasing the concentration results in a downfield shift
of both resonances at dꢀ7.6 and 7.4 ppm, corresponding to
the inner and outer amides, respectively, and in a shielding
effect on the protons corresponding to the aromatic core, es-
pecially those at dꢀ8.6 ppm, which are ascribable to protons
of the bay position of the perylene unit (Figure S1 in the Sup-
porting Information). This trend of 1 to self-assemble in more
apolar solvents, such as MCH and Tol, has been also studied by
dynamic light scattering (DLS). The correlation functions ob-
tained for 1 in MCH exhibit a sum of exponential decays to-
gether with an oscillatory term. This behavior has been previ-
ously described for highly absorbing macromolecules or aggre-
gated species and it has been rationalized by the presence of
different species in convective motion.[14] The average hydrody-
namic radii obtained by analyzing the correlation functions ob-
tained for 1 in MCH is 296 nm (Figure S2a in the Supporting In-
formation). However, CONTIN analysis of the correlation func-
tions of 1 in Tol shows a very broad distribution of particle
sizes indicative of the presence of species with very different
morphologies (Figure S2b in the Supporting Information).
Compound 1 readily form gels in apolar solvents, such as
MCH or Tol, which implies the formation of organized supra-
molecular structures (Figure 1b). The solvent strongly condi-
tions the morphology of the aggregates visualized by AFM of
dilute solutions of 1 (1ꢂ10À5 m). In more apolar MCH, bundles
of fibers constitutive of the organogel are clearly visible. The
diameter of the thinner fibers is around 7 nm (Figure 1c and
Figure S3 in the Supporting Information). However, the AFM
images of 1 in Tol reveal the formation of nanoparticles to-
gether with isolated fibrillar structures (Figure 1d). The dissimi-
lar morphologies observed in MCH or Tol have also been re-
ported for PDI organogelators capable of undergoing SSP.[11b]
Variable-temperature UV/Vis (VT-UV/Vis) experiments, in dif-
ferent solvent at different concentrations, have been utilized
to achieve a detailed investigation of the supramolecular poly-
merization mechanism. In analogy with that reported for the
aggregated state of a comparable N-annulated perylenedicar-
boxamide,[12a] compound 1 in an aggregated state features
a broad band centered at l=423 nm that splits upon heating
into three bands at l=398, 427, and 452 nm (Figure 1e). The
strong trend of 1 to self-assemble in an apolar solvent such as
MCH and at a total concentration (cT) as low as 5ꢂ10À6 m im-
pedes the observation of the abovementioned spectroscopic
features of 1 in a molecularly dissolved state. Consequently,
the addition of a more polar cosolvent, such as Tol, is necessa-
ry to obtain the molecularly dissolved state for 1. The corre-
sponding cooling curves of 1 in mixtures of MCH/Tol show
nonsigmoidal curves with very high elongation temperatures
(Te), that is, the temperature at which the nucleation regimen
changes to the elongation one,[3] which is indicative of cooper-
ative supramolecular polymerization. Closer inspection of the
cooling curves shows a subtle transition at intermediate tem-
peratures (Figure S4 in the Supporting Information). The transi-
tion between the nucleation and elongation regimens cannot
be observed because of the strong trend of 1 to aggregate.
However, a clear intermediate transition is observed at around
508C in the heating curves. Interestingly, increasing the per-
centage of Tol allows two defined transitions at around 80 and
508C to be unambiguously observed; these are diagnostic of
a three-step supramolecular polymerization (Figure 1 f and Fig-
ure S5 in the Supporting Information). The heating curves of
1 involve the contribution of three different species, namely,
the monomeric unit M; annealed, aggregated intermediate
species I; and completely aggregated state A. The UV/Vis spec-
tra at 20, 52, and 908C show different crossing points that are
indicative of the formation of three different chemical species
(Figure 1 f). Notably, the elongation temperatures observed in
the heating (Te) and cooling (Te’) processes, even if very high,
are not identical; thus indicating thermal hysteresis. This be-
havior has been identified in comparable PDIs as a fingerprint
of a kinetically controlled supramolecular polymerization in
which an inactive monomeric species is present.[11]
The Te and Te’ values decrease notably with Tol as the solvent
in the corresponding heating and cooling curves (Figure 2a).
The increasing difference between these two transition tem-
peratures indicates that the supramolecular polymerization of
1 can be kinetically controlled in this solvent. The VT-UV/Vis ex-
periments performed in Tol show that the spectrum at 208C
exhibits the same shape as that observed for 1 at intermediate
temperatures (ꢀ508C) in mixtures of MCH/Tol (Figure 2b).
These studies suggest that in the aggregation process of 1 in
Tol only the denaturation and annealing steps occur involving
the monomeric unit M and the annealed, aggregated inter-
mediate species I.
The nonsigmoidal transitions observed for the denaturation–
annealing processes in both Tol and mixtures of MCH/Tol can
be fitted to the EQ model to extract the corresponding ther-
modynamic parameters of the self-assembly process, namely,
the enthalpy of elongation, DHe; the entropy of elongation,
DS; and the nucleation penalty, DHn (Table 1 and Figure S6 in
the Supporting Information).[15] Considering the differences in
polarity of the solvent and concentration of the sample, the
values of the thermodynamic parameters are similar.
Data extracted from the VT-UV/Vis experiments of 1 show
good agreement with that reported for the kinetically con-
trolled supramolecular polymerization of PDIs[11] with a striking
difference in the three-step aggregation process. The forma-
tion of up to nine-membered pseudocycles through intramo-
lecular hydrogen-bonding interactions between bis-amides or
bis-ureas has been utilized to justify the origin of the inactiva-
tion of the monomers in the case of PDIs.[16] Thus, the forma-
tion of an intramolecular hydrogen-bonding interaction be-
tween the NÀH of the amide functional group and one of the
Table 1. Thermodynamic parameters of the supramolecular polymeri-
zation of 1 derived from the EQ model.
1
Tol (1ꢂ10À4 m)
MCH/Tol (70/30; 1ꢂ10À5 m)
DHe [kJmolÀ1
]
À109.7Æ3.5
À258Æ11
À103.1Æ3.1
À198Æ9
DS [JKÀ1 molÀ1
]
DHn [kJmolÀ1
]
À15.1Æ0.8
À18.0Æ0.9
Chem. Eur. J. 2016, 22, 1 – 8
3
ꢁ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
&
&
These are not the final page numbers! ÞÞ