10.1002/anie.202000684
Angewandte Chemie International Edition
RESEARCH ARTICLE
increased steric hinderance (8-14a). In biaryl systems,
functionalization is favored on the more electron-rich ring
system (4a, 8a). The mass balance for these reactions
typically consists exclusively of returned starting material
and C–H functionalized product.
resulting enolate by the solvent closes the second catalytic
cycle.
To investigate the energetic feasibility of the proposed
mechanism, the reaction between mesitylene and ethyl
diazoacetate was modeled using DFT (B3LYP, 6-31+g(d))
calculations (see SI for complete computational details).
Following oxidation of mesitylene, ethyl diazoacetate
undergoes nucleophilic addition to the arene cation radical
with a transition state energy of +11.7 kcal/mol and an
overall free energy change of +5.9 kcal/mol. The calculated
endergonicity of this process is in agreement with the
Next, the scope of this transformation with respect to the
diazo compound coupling partner was explored. This
reaction proceeded efficiently with simple diazoesters
possessing tert-butyl, benzyl and cyclopentyl diazoacetates,
affording the desired adducts 1e, 1c, and 1d in good to
moderate yields. Cyclic diazodihydrofuranone furnished
product 1b in 61% yield. Less nucleophilic methyl
diazomalonate formed product 1f, albeit with reduced yield.
Following C-H alkylation, the resulting ester products can be
converted into formal C-H methylation adducts via a simple
hydrolysis/decarboxylation sequence, utilizing a photoredox
hydrodecarboxylation method previously developed by our
group.18 The installation of tert-butyl, benzyl-, and malonate
esters are also valuable due to the number of possible
further transformations, which can be used to elaborate
these products. For example, benzyl esters can be cleaved
to the corresponding acid19, tert-butyl esters can be
converted to an acid chloride20 and malonate derivatives
can be used in the malonic ester synthesis to give
substituted acids.21
To probe the mechanism of this transformation, we
conducted a series of experimental and computational
investigations. Based on previous studies on the reaction of
diazoacetate derivatives with alkene cation radicals, we
initially hypothesized that following nucleophilic addition to
the aromatic cation radical, electron transfer from the
reduced form of the catalyst to the generated
cyclohexadienyl radical could trigger a 1,2-hydride shift and
expulsion of N2, leading to the formation of the observed C–
known equilibrium between arene cation radical/nucleophile
23,24
pairs and the corresponding σ-adducts.
Following
single electron transfer from the reduced form of the
catalyst to the σ-adduct, a barrierless loss of N2 and
cyclization forms norcaradiene 9 with an overall free energy
change of -6.5 kcal/mol relative to the starting materials. A
second single electron transfer event generates cation
radical intermediate 8 which then undergoes ring opening to
form a distonic cation radical. This process has a calculated
transition state energy of +5.0 kcal/mol and an overall free
energy change of -0.6 kcal/mol. Following electron transfer
from the reduced catalyst and proton transfer, the desired
C–H alkylation product is formed. The free energy change
for this overall process was calculated to be -50.9 kcal/mol.
Norcaradienes are known to exist as equilibrium
mixtures with the corresponding cycloheptatrienes.25,26 To
further explore the impact of this equilibrium in our system,
the free energy change for the interconversion of these
species was modeled for intermediates 6 and 7 (V, Chart 2).
In the neutral species, the cycloheptatriene form (6) is
favored by 1.8 kcal/mol. However, upon oxidation of this
species, the equilibrium was calculated to favor
norcaradiene cation radical 8 by 4.1 kcal/mol. This suggests
that, under the reaction conditions, the equilibrium between
norcaradiene and cycloheptriene may be driven towards
products via electron transfer.
To support this proposal, we subjected cycloheptatriene
6 to our optimized conditions (VI, Chart 2). Following
irradiation for 18 h, full conversion of 6 to the desired
product 1a was observed. Control experiments indicated
that the presence of Mes-Acr-BF4 is required for conversion.
A mass corresponding to the desired [4+2] adduct (5) was
observed by GC-MS upon the inclusion of maleic anhydride
(1 equiv.) as a Diels-Alder trap under otherwise optimized
conditions, supporting the formation of norcaradiene 9
during the reaction (VI, Chart 2). Diazoacetates bearing aryl
substituents, which are known to form free carbenes upon
irradiation with blue light, gave solely the product resulting
from O-H insertion of trifluoroethanol into the corresponding
carbene. Ethyl diazoacetate, which absorbs at 371 nm with
no overlap at 465 nm (SI 35), shows no formation of these
O-H insertion byproducts. This suggests that under these
reaction conditions a carbene is not formed and instead
ethyl diazoacetate behaves as a polar nucleophile. Control
experiments also indicated that the blue LEDs used for this
reaction are unable to trigger photolysis of ethyl
diazoacetate in a similar manner to aryl diazoacetates. This
is in accordance with other experimental and computational
data in support of the proposed mechanism given above.
In conclusion, we have developed an operationally
simple, metal-free site-selective aromatic C–H alkylation
which utilizes equimolar quantities of coupling partners,
unlike known metallocarbene chemistry which requires
H
functionalization product (IV, Chart 2). Such
a
mechanism would be reminiscent of that proposed for the
cyclopropanation of alkene cation radicals by Ferreira and
coworkers.22 When utilizing d3-Mesitylene as a substrate, no
deuterium incorporation was observed in the C–H alkylation
product, suggesting that a 1,2-hydride shift is an unlikely
step in the mechanism (II, Chart 2). When d1-TFE is used
as the reaction solvent, a mixture of non-deuterated, mono-
deuterated and di-deuterated products is observed with the
mono-deuterated formed as the major product in 72% yield.
The presence of non-deuterated and di-deuterated products
in the presence of the singly labeled product was
rationalized as the result of enolate equilibration. Treatment
of the proteo-product with d1-TFE did not lead to any
observable deuterium incorporation. This is consistent with
a mechanism invoking the protonation of an enolate by the
solvent as part of the mechanism.
Based on this evidence, we propose an alternative
mechanism as follows: following excitation by blue light,
Mes-Acr-BF4* engages in photoinduced electron transfer
(PET) with an arene, producing cation radical 1 and the
reduced form of the catalyst (Mes-Acr·). Polar nucleophilic
addition of ethyl diazoacetate forms distonic cation radical 2,
which is reduced by acridine radical (Mes-Acr·) to form the
intermediate norcaradiene 3 and regenerate ground state
Mes-Acr-BF4. Following a second PET event, intermediate
3 undergoes ring-opening to form distonic benzylic radical
cation 4. Reduction of this intermediate by Mes-Acr·,
deprotonation (presumably by conjugate base of the
solvent) to rearomitize the product, and protonation of the
4
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.