Communications
NAD-independent d-lactate dehydrogenases (d-iLDHs) in-
volved in d-lactate metabolism in vivo, have been character-
ized previously.[18] However, most of these enzymes are mem-
brane-bound, require artificial electron acceptors for the oxida-
tion of d-lactate in vitro, and have narrow substrate spectra,[18]
which makes them unsuitable for use in biocatalysis. The wide
distribution and availability of abundant sequence information
from various sequenced organisms provide an opportunity to
screen a d-iLDH with the desired characteristics for (S)-2-HA
production.
The candidate genes that encoded the putative d-LOXs,
which included SC-LOX (DLD3, protein id=“AJV36019.1”) from
S. cerevisiae, GO-LOX (GOX2071, protein id=“AAW61807.1”)
from G. oxydans 621H, BCa-LOX (protein id=“AEP01915.1”),
BCb-LOX (protein id=“AEP02239.1”) from Bacillus coagulans
36D1, LD-LOX (protein id=“CAI96943.1”) from Lactobacillus
delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus ATCC 11842, and BC-LOX (protein
id=“AEH53827.1”) from Bacillus coagulans 2–6 (Table S2), were
cloned into the pETDuet-1 vector with an N-terminal His6-tag
and transformed to Escherichia coli BL21 (DE3) for overexpres-
sion. For membrane-bound proteins, a suitable surfactant must
be added for the stability of proteins from the cell membrane
during purification and storage.[18–19] However, sodium dodecyl
sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) showed
that all seven overexpressed enzymes above could be purified
by using a HisTrap HP column without the addition of any sur-
factant (Figure S2), which indicated that none of the enzymes
are membrane-bound (i.e., they are soluble) in accordance
with the present hypothesis (Figure 1A).
Membrane-bound d-iLDHs are rather difficult to overexpress
and purify on a large scale[18–19] and thus are unsuitable for use
in biocatalysis. The initial screening strategy used here in-
volved solubility as the first criterion. The sequence features of
reported d-iLDHs and their homologous proteins (from >100
genomes) were analyzed in the Pfam database (Table S1 and
Figure S1). The results showed that most proteins contained
a membrane-associated sequence (Figure S1). Actually, only
two soluble d-iLDHs, DLD3 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae[20] and
GOX2071 in Gluconobacter oxydans,[21] have been characterized
previously. Other reported soluble d-iLDHs have been shown
to exist in the crude extracts of lactic acid bacteria (LAB).[22]
Analysis of these two soluble d-iLDHs in the Pfam database in-
dicated that they shared a similar sequence feature, which con-
tained only an FAD-binding domain at the N terminus and an
FAD-oxidase domain at the C terminus. For this reason, several
candidate proteins from LAB with the sequence feature of
soluble d-iLDHs, together with DLD3 and GOX2071, were se-
lected for further screening as possible putative d-lactate
oxidases (d-LOXs; Figure 1A).
Subsequently, the substrate spectra of the purified enzymes
were assayed using 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenylte-
trazolium bromide (MTT) as an artificial electron acceptor. Ac-
tivity assays were performed at 308C and 578 nm in 0.8 mL of
50 mm Tris-HCl buffer (pH 7.4) that contained 10 mm various
2-HAs, 0.2 mm MTT, 0.2 mm phenazine methosulfate (PMS),
and the purified enzymes. No detectable activities were ob-
served in the enzyme solution of BCa-LOX, LD-LOX, and
BC-LOX, although the purified soluble enzymes were produced
in large quantities. In contrast, purified SC-LOX, GO-LOX, and
BCb-LOX showed activities and preferences toward various
2-HAs (Table S3). These three enzymes with broad substrate
spectra were subjected to subsequent screening
experiments (Figure 1A).
To further assess the catalytic capacity of SC-LOX,
GO-LOX, and BCb-LOX using O2 as an electron ac-
ceptor, their specific activities for various 2-HAs (1a–
16a) were assayed by using a Clark-type oxygen
electrode with 10 mm 2-HAs and an appropriate
amount of enzyme solution in 50 mm air-saturated
Tris-HCl buffer (pH 7.4) at 900 rpm and 308C. These
three enzymes all showed catalytic capacity directly
using O2 (Table 1). Although their specific activities
toward different electron acceptors (MTT and O2)
were not equivalent, all enzymes showed similar
trends in their catalytic properties. For various 2-HAs
with different side-chain lengths, SC-LOX showed
the greatest activity toward short aliphatic chains,
BCb-LOX preferred longer aliphatic or aromatic
chains, and GO-LOX preferred nearly all (R)-2-HAs
with aliphatic and aromatic chains. GO-LOX also
showed high oxidase activities toward most 2-HAs
that contained substituent groups (10a–16a). With
regard to stereoselectivity, GO-LOX also performed
better than SC-LOX and BCb-LOX. In this way, after
sequential screening (Figure 1A), GO-LOX was select-
ed as the most appropriate enzyme for use in the re-
action shown in Scheme 1. Then the enzymatic
Figure 1. A) Screening process for suitable d-LOX and B,C) its application for the produc-
tion of (S)-2a, and (S)-7a. &, 2-HA; *, 2-ketocarboxylic acid; ~, ee.
&
ChemCatChem 2016, 8, 1 – 5
2
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ÝÝ These are not the final page numbers!