.
Angewandte
Communications
residues lining the substrate binding pocket.[8b,10b,d] However,
redesigning A domains for recognition of non-cognate amino
acids that exhibit larger differences in size or charge is
generally more difficult, and adenylation efficiency often
drops substantially.[10e,f] These challenges notwithstanding, we
show here that only minimal changes are needed to reengi-
neer phenylalanine-specific A domains for the efficient
incorporation of aromatic amino acids containing alkyne
and azide functional groups into NRPs.
To expand the recognition properties of GrsAA, a phenyl-
alanine-specific A domain (PheA) from gramicidin S synthe-
tase (Figure 1),[7b,11] eight active-site residues known to
correlate with substrate specificity[10a,b] were chosen for
cassette mutagenesis (Figure 2A,B). The resulting single-
mutant libraries were individually screened against the twenty
Table 1: Catalytic parameters of the adenylation reaction catalyzed by
GrsAA and GrsAA-W239S.[a]
Variant
Substrate
kcat
kcat/Km
Speci- Specificity
[minÀ1
]
[mmÀ1 minÀ1 ficity[b] switch[c]
]
wt
wt
wt
W239S
W239S
l-Phe
p-azido-l-Phe
O-propargyl-l-Tyr
l-Tyr
300
200
30
230
200
190
25000
25
2
600
9000
7000
1
1
–
–
10À3
10À5
3.2
47
800
5ꢂ104
5ꢂ105
p-azido-l-Phe
W239S O-propargyl-l-Tyr
37
[a] Catalytic parameters were determined by a pyrophosphate exchange
assay.[10e,12] For additional kinetic data and experimental errors see
Table S1. [b] Specificity: kcat/Km (target substrate)/kcat/Km (l-Phe). [c] Spe-
cificity switch: (specificity)mut/(specificity)wt for the indicated amino acid.
Simple modeling suggested that the W239S mutation
opens up a cavity large enough to accommodate amino acids
even bulkier than tyrosine (Figure 2C and D). Although l-
Trp was inefficiently adenylated (kcat/Km = 36 mmÀ1 minÀ1),
phenylalanine derivatives bearing bulky para substituents
were excellent substrates. Adenylation rates increased with
the size of the para-substituent in the order H < OH < Cl <
OMe < OEt (Figure 2E; Table S1). The p-ethoxy substituent
afforded remarkably high activity (kcat/Km = 50000
mmÀ1 minÀ1), greater than that of wt GrsAA with l-Phe
(kcat/Km=25000 mmÀ1 minÀ1). The variations in adenylation
activity manifest in these kcat/Km values largely reflect differ-
ences in Km for the different amino acids. Under saturating
conditions at high substrate concentration, all turnover
numbers, including those with l-Trp, were in the range of
GrsAA with l-Phe, i.e. 102 to 103 minÀ1 (Table S1).
The capacious GrsAA-W239S binding site also supported
efficient activation of click amino acids containing azide and
alkyne functionality. Thus, p-azido-l-Phe and O-propargyl-l-
Tyr, which are poorly processed by wt GrsAA, serve as
excellent substrates for the mutant PheA domain (Fig-
ure 2E). For example, GrsAA-W239S adenylated O-prop-
argyl-l-Tyr 10 times more rapidly than l-Tyr, the best
naturally occurring amino acid substrate, and 40 times faster
than l-Phe. These changes, corresponding to a 5 ꢀ 105-fold
switch in enzyme specificity (Table 1), were achieved with
little loss in catalytic efficiency, judging from the steady-state
parameters for the mutant enzyme with the non-natural
substrate (kcat = 190 minÀ1 and kcat/Km = 7000 mmÀ1 minÀ1)
relative to wt GrsAA with l-Phe (kcat = 300 minÀ1 and
kcat/Km = 25000 mmÀ1 minÀ1).
Figure 2. Engineering the GrsAA binding pocket. A) Crystal structure of
GrsAA (PDB code 1AMU)[11] with bound l-Phe (green carbon atoms)
and adenosine monophosphate (yellow carbon atoms). B) Residues
lining the l-Phe binding pocket are shown as stick models. The amino
acids in cyan and magenta (Ala236, Trp239, Thr278, Ile299, Ala301,
Ala322, Ile330, and Cys331) were individually subjected to cassette
mutagenesis; Cys331 is hidden behind the substrate. Asp235 and
Lys517 (gray), important for catalysis, were not mutated. Adenosine
monophosphate was omitted for clarity. C) Cut-away view of the
binding pocket in the plane of the phenyl ring. D) PyMOL model of the
W239S variant. E) Adenylation kinetics of GrsAA (gray) and GrsAA-
W239S (green) with a range of aromatic amino acid substrates,
including the click amino acids p-azido-l-Phe and O-propargyl-l-Tyr.
See Table 1 and Table S1 in the Supporting Information for details.
proteinogenic amino acids using a microtiter-plate-based
pyrophosphate exchange assay for adenylation activity.[10e,12]
Replacing Trp239, located at the bottom of the PheA
recognition pocket, with smaller amino acids afforded prom-
ising changes in substrate specificity. Substituting tryptophan
with serine (W239S), for example, resulted in an approxi-
mately three times higher preference for l-Tyr over l-Phe,
which corresponds to an 800-fold switch in specificity relative
to wild-type (wt) GrsAA. The kcat/Km value for l-Tyr
activation by this variant is 600 mmÀ1 minÀ1, only 40 times
below the kcat/Km determined for l-Phe with the wild-type
enzyme (Table 1).
Adenylation activity alone is insufficient for nonriboso-
mal peptide synthesis with unnatural building blocks; per-
missivity of downstream domains is also essential. To test
whether the modified GrsAA domain can communicate with
other domains and modules, we employed a truncated GrsA/
GrsB1 dipeptide synthetase excised from the gramicidin S
NRPS (Figure 3).[13,14] In addition to the PheA domain, the
complete GrsA initiation module contains a thiolation (T)
and an epimerase (E) domain, whereas GrsB1 is a truncated
elongation module containing a proline-specific A domain,
a T domain, and a condensation (C) domain. The wild-type
dipeptide synthetase loads l-Phe and l-Pro onto their
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2014, 53, 10105 –10108