X. Z. Zhao et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 21 (2011) 2986–2990
2989
Table 3
Table 5
Metal-dependency of integrase inhibitory potencies in vitroa
Antiviral potencies in cells infected with HIV-1 containing wild-type or mutant
integrase enzymesa
No.
Metal cofactor
IC50 (lM)
No.
CC50
N/A
(
l
M)
EC50
(
l
M, WT)
Mutantsb
G140S/Q148H Y143R
30-P
ST
N155H
1
Mg2+
Mn2+
Mg2+
Mn2+
>4.5
>4.5
>111
0.067
0.074
9.1 1.1
1.2 0.3
1
0.004 0.002
61
425ꢁ
2ꢁ
53ꢁ
4ꢁ
35ꢁ
3ꢁ
4b–1
4b–1
291 51
9
28
2
a
Data was obtained as indicated in the Supplementary data.
Fold-loss of potency relative to virus containing wild-type (WT) enzyme.
a
b
Data was obtained from in vitro IN assays using the indicated metal cofactors as
described in the Supplementary data.
(in terms of a fold increase in IC50 value) as Raltegravir to the ef-
fects of mutations at Y143.
To complement the in vitro data, we developed HIV-1 vectors
that replicated the resistant IN mutants G140S/Q148H, Y143R
and N155H. These mutant vectors were challenged with Raltegra-
vir (1) and 4b–1 in cultured cells. One of the design rationales for
introducing a nitrogen into the parent 4,5-dihydroxy-1H-isoin-
dole-1,3(2H)-diones (3) was to remove catechol functionality and
thereby reduce cytotoxicity. As shown in Table 5, the cytotoxicity
Compound 4b–1 is also less susceptible (in terms of the
increase in IC50 value) to the effects of the G140S/Q148H double
mutant. In this case, the new PFV IN structural data does not provide
as clear an answer to the question of why the two compounds dif-
fer in their relative susceptibility to the two mutants. However, the
tricyclic hydroxy-pyrrolopyridine triones (4) showed differential
activity in the presence of Mn2+, which Raltegravir (1) does not.
This suggests the possibility that there are subtle differences in
the way(s) in which the two compounds interact with metals at
the active site. It is possible that the G140S/Q148H double mutant
changes the active site in a way that alters the interactions of Ral-
tegravir with metals, and because 4b–1 interacts differently with
metals, it is less susceptible.
The range of inhibitory potencies shown by our title inhibitors
is less than we expected based on the structures of other highly po-
tent ST inhibitors7 and recent co-crystal data of inhibitors bound to
the homologous PFV integrase.13,14,16,17 In spite of their modest
(low micromolar) potencies, these new compounds, which should
be viewed as a new structural class, are promising. We are partic-
ularly interested in understanding why the new compounds retain
activity against the G140S/Q148H double mutant. If this property
could be incorporated into more potent derivatives, they would
have real potential for the treatment of drug-resistant viruses.
of 4b–1 (CC50 = 291
ported value of the related catechol-containing analogue 3–1
(CC50 = 9.5
M),5 In addition, consistent with the in vitro data ob-
lM) was 30-fold lower than the previously re-
l
tained for the Raltegravir-resistant IN mutants (Table 4), Raltegra-
vir showed a greater than 400-fold loss of antiviral efficacy with
the G140S/Q148H vector as compared to the wild-type IN vector
(Table 5). In contrast to Raltegravir, inhibitor 4b–1 displayed only
a 2-fold loss of potency when challenged with the G140S/Q148H
mutant vector, thereby making it 200-times less sensitive to the ef-
fects of this mutation. Similarly, consistent with the in vitro data in
Table 4, analogue 4b–1 showed a 10-fold lower loss of potency
compared to Raltegravir, with vectors that individually carry the
Y143R (53-fold loss for Raltegravir and 4-fold loss for 4b–1) and
N155H mutations (35-fold loss for Raltegravir and 3-fold loss for
4b–1).
The tricyclic hydroxy-pyrrolopyridine triones (4) combine fea-
tures of bicyclic pyrimidinones (2) with those of our previously re-
ported isoindolediones (3). Introduction of the 2(1H)-pyridone
moiety into the previously 1H-isoindole-1,3(2H)-dione-based ana-
logues significantly increases the requirement for halogen substi-
tuent(s) within the key benzylamide pharmacophore. The
tricyclic hydroxy-pyrrolopyridine trione inhibitors (4) maintain
good selectivity for ST reactions relative to the 30-P reactions and
exhibit reduced cytotoxicity relative to the catechol-containing
compounds (3). In both in vitro and in vivo assays the new
analogue 4b–1 was less sensitive than Raltegravir to resistance
incurred by G140S/Q148H, Y143R and N155H mutations in
integrase. The enhanced activity toward the Y143R mutation rela-
tive to Raltegravir is consistent with recent findings based on co-
crystal structures of the homologous PFV integrase, which show
Acknowledgments
This work was supported in part by the Intramural Research
Program of the NIH, Center for Cancer Research, NCI-Frederick
and the National Cancer Institute, National Institutes of Health
and the Joint Science and Technology Office of the Department of
Defense. The content of this publication does not necessarily reflect
the views or policies of the Department of Health and Human
Services, nor does mention of trade names, commercial products,
or organizations imply endorsement by the U.S. Government.
Supplementary data
that p–p stacking interactions occur between Y212 (corresponding
to Y143 in the HIV-1 IN) and the oxadiazole ring of bound Raltegra-
vir.13,14,16,17 The new compound 4b–1, does not contain equivalent
functionality and 4b–1 would not be expected to be as susceptible
Supplementary data (biological and synthetic experimental
procedures and analytical data for synthetic products) associated
with this article can be found, in the online version, at
References and notes
Table 4
Integrase inhibitory potencies in vitro using wild-type (WT) and mutant enzymesa
1. Summa, V.; Petrocchi, A.; Bonelli, F.; Crescenzi, B.; Donghi, M.; Ferrara, M.;
Fiore, F.; Gardelli, C.; Gonzalez Paz, O.; Hazuda, D. J.; Jones, P.; Kinzel, O.; Laufer,
R.; Monteagudo, E.; Muraglia, E.; Nizi, E.; Orvieto, F.; Pace, P.; Pescatore, G.;
Scarpelli, R.; Stillmock, K.; Witmer, M. V.; Rowley, M. J. Med. Chem. 2008, 51,
5843.
No.
ST IC50
(
lM, WT)
Mutantsb
Y143R
G140S/Q148H
N155H
1
0.067
91 1.1
105ꢁ
6ꢁ
26ꢁ
2ꢁ
7ꢁ
3ꢁ
2. Marchand, C.; Maddali, K.; Metifiot, M.; Pommier, Y. Curr. Top. Med. Chem. 2009,
9, 1016.
4b–1
3. Muraglia, E.; Kinzel, O.; Gardelli, C.; Crescenzi, B.; Donghi, M.; Ferrara, M.; Nizi,
E.; Orvieto, F.; Pescatore, G.; Laufer, R.; Gonzalez-Paz, O.; Di Marco, A.; Fiore, F.;
Monteagudo, E.; Fonsi, M.; Felock, P. J.; Rowley, M.; Summa, V. J. Med. Chem.
2008, 51, 861.
a
Data was obtained from in vitro IN assays using Mg2+ cofactor as described in
the Supplementary data.
b
Fold-loss of potency relative to WT enzyme for ST.