Photooxidative Coupling of Thiophenol Derivatives to Disulfides
J. Phys. Chem. A, Vol. 114, No. 45, 2010 12013
It is not clear yet how electronic excitation of thiolate leads
to the formation of disulfide. We performed time-dependent
density functional theory calculations (TD DFT) to find the
nature of the electronic excited state of the thiolate form of pNTP
and to gain insights into the reaction mechanism. The calcula-
tions revealed that the only transition with a nonzero oscillator
strength (f) is to the excited singlet state at 435 nm (f ) 0.54),
in good agreement with the measured absorption at 441 nm
(
Supporting Information, Figure S6). The molecular orbitals
involved in the transition show that the electron density moves
from the anionic sulfur atom to the nitro group upon transition
from the ground state to the excited singlet state. We also note
Figure 5. Dependence of the photooxidation reaction yield of pNTP
on excitation wavelength. The pNTP solution at pH 4.3 was irradiated
at 325, 365, 455, 530, and 660 nm at 25 mW for 2 h. The yield was
measured by the Raman intensity of the photoproduct DNDPDS at 1078
·
that thiyl radicals (RS ) have been proposed as intermediates
in the formation of disulfide in previous catalytic oxidation
8,13
studies.
Therefore, it is possible that photoexcitation of
-
1
cm . The absorption spectrum of the solution used in the experiment
solid line) is included to indicate which species, the thiol or the thiolate
thiolate may facilitate the production of the thiyl radicals by
removing the electron density from the anionic sulfur atom,
leading to the formation of disulfide. Further experimental and
theoretical investigations are required to unravel the reaction
mechanism.
(
form of pNTP, is excited to yield the product. Absorption spectra of
the thiol (dotted line) and thiolate (dashed line) forms of pNTP are
adopted from Figure 3 to show the absorption region of each species.
3
.4. Effect of the Substituents. Because the electron-
of the thiol form of pNTP is calculated from the Raman peak
intensity at 1340 cm- at each pH divided by the Raman
intensity at pH 1.7, where pNTP exists exclusively in the thiol
form. The 1310 cm- Raman peak intensity was used for
calculation of the fraction of the thiolate form of pNTP.
Calculation of the fraction using the UV-vis absorption bands
at 326 and 441 nm produced the same results. Plotted together
is the relative amount of the photoproduct by irradiation of pNTP
at each pH, measured by the Raman intensity of DNDPDS at
withdrawing/donating properties of substituents often influences
the reactivity of aryl compounds, it is possible that the
photooxidative coupling reaction we observed is limited to the
1
1
2
strong electron-withdrawing group, namely, -NO . Thus, we
explored the photooxidation of other functional-group-substi-
tuted thiophenols. We selected pMBA for its moderate electron-
withdrawing functional group (-COOH), pCTP for its weak
electron-withdrawing functional group (-Cl), and pMTP for
3
its strong electron-donating functional group (-OCH ). The
-
1
1
110 cm . Figure 4 shows that the formation of DNDPDS
samples were prepared in ethanol/water and irradiated at selected
wavelengths. Because the excitation of the thiolate form is key
to driving the photooxidation reaction as discussed above, we
measured the UV-vis absorption spectra of the thiolate form
of each molecule and selected the excitation wavelengths
accordingly. Figure 6 shows the UV-vis absorption spectra of
pMBA, pCTP, and pMTP in ethanol/water (red lines) and of
the corresponding thiolate forms in the basic condition (gray
lines) to identify the absorption band of the thiolate. The
wavelengths used for photoexcitation are marked by the arrows
in the figure. Upon irradiation, photoproducts were formed and
measured by Raman spectroscopy.
reaches a maximum at pH ≈ 5. In other words, photooxidation
occurs most efficiently in the pH range between 4 and 5 and
does not occur at pH lower than 2 or higher than 6. This suggests
that the reaction requires both thiol and thiolate forms of pNTP.
The requirement for the presence of both forms of pNTP is
further corroborated by the observation that DNDPDS was not
produced in pure organic solvents such as THF and dichlo-
romethane (DCM), where only the thiol form of pNTP exists
(
Supporting Information, Figure S5). Quantitative analysis of
the fraction of molecules in Figure 4 indicates that photooxi-
dation occurs best when the neutral form is about three times
more abundant than the anion form. As discussed in the
following section, photooxidation of pNTP occurs via electronic
excitation of the anionic thiolate form of pNTP. Therefore, a
higher population of the thiol form of pNTP surrounding the
electronically excited thiolate form may increase the chance of
reactive collisions between the two species, leading to the best
yield.
Figure 6d-f presents Raman spectra of pMBA, pCTP, pMTP,
and their photoproducts. The Raman spectra of the photoprod-
ucts are characterized by the absence of the S-H stretching
-1
peak near 2560 cm and the appearance of a new peak at ∼500
-
1
22
cm , assigned to the S-S stretching mode. This observation
strongly suggests that disulfide bonds are formed by irradiation.
In addition, the red shift of the C-S stretching mode from
∼
3
.3. Effect of Excitation Wavelength. To find which form
-
1
1100 to ∼1080 cm is observed, as is the case for pNTP.
of pNTP is excited by irradiation, leading to the photoreaction,
we varied the excitation wavelengths and measured the product
yield using Raman spectroscopy. Figure 5 presents the Raman
Furthermore, comparison between the Raman spectrum of the
product from irradiation of pCTP and that of the reference, 4,4′-
dichlorodiphenyldisulfide (DCDPDS), confirms that the photo-
oxidative coupling reaction has indeed occurred (Supporting
Information, Figure S7). Therefore, the photooxidative coupling
of thiophenol derivatives occurs regardless of the electron-
donating/withdrawing properties of the substituents.
-1
intensity of the DNDPDS photoproduct at 1078 cm , acquired
after irradiation of pNTP at 325, 365, 455, 530, and 660 nm
(
25 mW, 2 h). Overlaid are the absorption spectra of pNTP at
pH 4.3 (solid line), where the experiments were performed,
together with the absorption spectra of the thiol (dotted line)
and the thiolate (dashed line) forms of pNTP, with λmax at 326
and 441 nm, respectively. DNDPDS is best produced by
irradiation at 455 nm, which is where the thiolate form of pNTP
absorbs strongly. Excitation of neutral pNTP at 325 nm does
not yield significant amounts of the photoproduct. Therefore,
the photooxidation of pNTP occurs via electronic excitation of
the thiolate form rather than the thiol form of pNTP.
Our observations imply that photooxidative coupling may be
generally applicable to a variety of thiophenol molecules if the
excitation wavelength and pH conditions are properly selected.
The synthesis of disulfides via photooxidation is easy, safe,
clean, and thus well suited to green chemistry. The separation
of the products is also straightforward. Furthermore, the photo-
oxidative coupling reaction enables the synthesis of asymmetric