1
954
P. Ábrányi-Balogh et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 57 (2016) 1953–1957
in the formation of the tryptamine benzoate salt (3a). However,
when the T3P reagent (solution in ethyl acetate) was also added
under MW conditions, acylation took place giving rise to the
Table 1
a
Ò
Optimization of the Bischler–Napieralski reaction
Entry
T3PÒ equivb
T (°C)
t (h)
Heating
Yield (%)
formation of N
quent Bischler–Napieralski cyclization in
b
-benzoyltryptamine (4a), which underwent subse-
consecutive and
1
2
3
4
5
6
1.25
1.5
1.5
1.5
1.5
2
100
100
120
120
120
120
2
2
1.5
2
1.5
1.5
MW
MW
MW
MW
D
74
80
81
76
61
58
a
one-pot manner, leading to the expected 1-phenyl-3,4-dihydro-b-
carboline (5a, Scheme 1). The reaction conditions were optimized
and the results are shown in Table 1. When utilizing 1.25 equiv
D
Ò
of the T3P reagent at 100 °C for 2 h, the yield of 5a was 74%
a
Table 1, entry 1). Upon increasing the amount of the T3PÒ reagent
Reaction conditions: tryptamine (2.5 mmol), benzoic acid (1 equiv), 30–50 W.
5
(
b
0 w/w% in EtOAc solution.
to 1.5 equiv, the yield increased to 80% (entry 2). At 120 °C, 1.5 h
was sufficient for reaction completion to afford product 5a in
8
1% yield (entry 3). A longer reaction time (2 h) at 120 °C resulted
O
P
O
P
Pr
in the formation of product 5a in a lower yield (76%) due to the
appearance of by-products, which were detected by TLC and
HPLC–MS (entry 4).
Pr
Pr
O
O
OH
O
HO
O
HO
P
H2O
2
H O
O
O
O P
+
P
P
HO
P
O
O
P
Comparative thermal experiments were also carried out at
Pr Pr
Pr
O
O
HO
20 °C using 1.5 or 2 equiv of the T3PÒ reagent in a sealed tube
HO
1
Pr
P
Pr
O
O
Pr
leading to yields of 61% and 58%, respectively, after 1.5 h (entries
, 6). From the above results it can be concluded that MW irradia-
T3P®
®
T3P . H O
2
5
tion was beneficial in the one-pot synthesis of 1-phenyl-3,4-
Scheme 2. Two-step reaction of T3PÒ with two equivalents of water.
dihydro-b-carboline (5a) by the reaction of tryptamine (1) and
Ò
benzoic acid (2a) in the presence of T3P .
It is noteworthy that both the amidation and the ring closure
reactions, altogether involving the elimination of two molecules
on HPLC–MS, in reaction A the conversion of tryptamine was 56%
with N -benzoyltryptamine (4a) and 1-phenyl-3,4-dihydro-b-car-
b
Ò
of water, take place in the presence of only 1.5 equiv of T3P . This
boline (5a) detected in 27% and 29%, respectively. In reaction B,
the cyclization to 5a took place with 85% conversion. Therefore,
it can be concluded, that the water adduct of T3PÒ is able to cat-
alyze both the acylation of tryptamine and the subsequent
Bischler–Napieralski cyclization of the amide.
can be explained by assuming that the T3PÒ molecule can react not
only in its cyclic form, but also in the open-chain compound
Ò
(
(
T3P ꢀH
2 2
O) formed from the formal uptake of a H O molecule
Scheme 2).
Ò
To examine this hypothesis, two experiments were performed
After optimization of the reaction conditions (1.5 equiv T3P ,
using 0.5 equiv of T3PÒ (MW, 120 °C, 1.5 h). When benzoyl-
tryptamine (4a) was used as the starting compound, the cycliza-
tion to 5a took place with 70% conversion. In the reaction of
MW, 120 °C, 1.5 h) for 1-phenyl-3,4-dihydro-b-carboline (5a), the
reaction scope was extended to substituted benzoic acids (2b–k),
as well as aliphatic (2l–o) and heterocyclic carboxylic acids
(2p–s) in order to synthesize the corresponding 1-substituted-3,
4-dihydro-b-carbolines. The results summarized in Scheme 3 and
Table 2 demonstrate that aryl substituents in the meta or para posi-
tion did not have a significant effect on conversion or yields. Only
the highly electron donating methoxy group facilitated (Table 2,
entry 5) and the highly electron withdrawing nitro group (entry
11) hindered the reaction significantly, which could be explained
by the activation or the deactivation of the nitrilium cation respec-
tively. In the cases of ortho substituents (entries 6, 7, 10) the lower
yields and longer reaction times can be explained by steric effects.
With aliphatic carboxylic acids (entries 12–15) a reaction time of
2 h was necessary for full conversion, and a slight correlation could
be found between the increasing size of the aliphatic group and the
decreasing yields. The best yield (95%) was achieved in the synthe-
Ò
tryptamine (1), benzoic acid (2a) and 0.5 equiv of T3P , the reac-
b
tion mixture contained, based on HPLC–MS, N -benzoyltryptamine
(4a, 79%) and 1-phenyl-3,4-dihydro-b-carboline (5a, 15%). The
findings of these two experiments show that one molecule of
Ò
T3P can promote the elimination of more than two molecules of
2
H O. Therefore it is plausible to assume that the open-chain deriva-
Ò
tive of T3P , which is formed in the ring opening step and contains
two anhydride moieties, is still reactive and may serve as a reagent
for the further reaction steps. Additionally, further evidence comes
Ò
from an earlier study which found that the T3P -promoted esteri-
fication of phosphinic acids could also be performed using less
Ò 23
than an equimolar amount of T3P . To further support this the-
Ò
ory, the T3P reagent was mixed with one equivalent of H
2
O in
order to hydrolyze the cyclic anhydride. After the exothermic reac-
tion, tryptamine and one equivalent of benzoic acid (reaction A) or
1
c,25
sis of harmalan (5l), an important harmala-alkaloid.
Ivanov and
N
b
-benzoyltryptamine (reaction B) were added and the mixture
co-workers previously applied polyphosphoric acid (PPA) and
heated under the standard conditions (MW, 120 °C, 1.5 h). Based
isolated 5l from the reaction of tryptamine and acetic acid in 77%
O
3
4
2
NH3+
O
NH2
O
MW
T3P
N
H
5
4a
4
b
N
®
P
Ph
6
7
P
1
+
Ph
OH
9a
N
H
N
H
-H
2
O
Ph
EtOAc
N
H
4a
-H
2
O
8a
N
H
5a
9
-O
8
Ph
1
2a
3a
P = T3P® or T3P® H O
.
2
O
N
N
H
N
Ph
N
Ph
N
H
N
H
Ph
N
H
H
N
H
Ph
Scheme 1. Reaction of tryptamine and benzoic acid in the presence of T3PÒ with a schematic mechanism proceeding through the nitrilium ion.