tꢈꢊꢇꢁꢊ %ꢃ ꢆꢃꢍ ꢇ%ꢂꢄꢁꢍ ꢏꢇꢅ&ꢀꢆꢁ
Green Chemistry
Page 6 of 6
DOI: 10.1039/C8GC00348C
!wÇL/[9
Wꢀꢁꢂꢃꢄꢅ bꢄꢆꢇ
íꢀꢈꢈꢀꢇꢏꢁꢔ Çꢃꢉꢒꢁꢓꢃꢍꢒꢅꢏ [ꢃꢉꢉꢀꢔ ꢐꢑꢑ ꢔ ) ꢔ DꢑD ꢓ <ꢊ@ !ꢓ bꢓ !ꢂꢂꢃꢄ
ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ"[ꢓ tꢀꢆꢊꢍꢔ Wꢀ aꢅꢊꢀ /ꢁꢉꢁꢊꢀ !, /ꢓꢃꢂꢓꢔ ꢐꢑꢑDꢔ ꢉ)ꢔ ꢐꢑ!ꢓ <ꢎ@ óꢓ
íꢄꢔ óꢓ [ꢀꢔ !ꢓ ùꢇꢆꢃꢍꢍꢀ"Dꢊꢅꢃꢁꢇꢔ !ꢓ tꢊꢍꢍꢏꢇꢆꢔ Wꢓ [ꢀꢄꢔ !ꢓ Wꢓ aꢀꢈꢈꢁ ꢇꢆ%
Wꢓ óꢀꢇꢃꢔ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ 9ꢑꢒꢀ Wꢀꢔ ꢐꢑꢑGꢔ ꢉ)ꢔ ꢐꢐꢑ-ꢓ <&@ óꢓ íꢄꢔ Wꢓ [ꢀꢄꢔ 5ꢓ 5ꢓ
Çꢃꢏꢏꢇꢁꢃꢔ Wꢓ !ꢓ L&&ꢃꢔ /ꢓ wꢓ !ꢓ /ꢇꢍꢈꢃ7ꢔ Wꢓ .ꢇꢌꢁꢇ ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ óꢀꢇꢃꢔ
/ꢓꢃꢂꢀ 9ꢑꢒꢀ Wꢀ ꢐꢑꢑGꢔ ꢉ)ꢔ EA--ꢓ < @ hꢓ {ꢃꢈꢍꢇꢆꢀꢔ aꢓ !ꢓ !ꢅꢀ&ꢊꢅꢔ Iꢓ
ëꢇ:Fꢄꢊ:"ëꢀꢈꢈꢇ ꢇꢆ% 9ꢓ aꢓ /ꢇꢅꢅꢊꢀꢅꢇꢔ hꢒ&ꢀ [ꢃꢉꢉꢀꢔ ꢐꢑ ꢑꢔ ꢉ ꢔ ꢐG-!ꢓ <ꢀ@
Iꢓ ëꢇ:Fꢄꢊ:"ëꢀꢈꢈꢇꢔ {ꢓ wꢊ0ꢊꢅꢔ aꢓ !ꢓ !ꢅꢀ&ꢊꢅ ꢇꢆ% 9ꢓ aꢓ /ꢇꢅꢅꢊꢀꢅꢇꢔ
!ꢏ&ꢃ0ꢀ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ Lꢏꢉꢀ 9ꢍꢓꢔ ꢐꢑ ꢔ *ꢈꢔ G-E-ꢓ <ꢂ@ aꢓ !ꢓ !ꢅꢀ&ꢊꢅ ꢇꢆ% 9ꢓ
aꢓ /ꢇꢅꢅꢊꢀꢅꢇꢔ hꢒ&ꢀ [ꢃꢉꢉꢀꢔ ꢐꢑ ꢐꢔ ꢉ)ꢔ D?ꢐꢐꢓ <6@ hꢓ tꢅꢇ6ꢇꢁ ꢔ Iꢓ
Wꢃꢁ ꢀꢔ Yꢓ bꢓ { ꢇꢅꢏꢇꢔ tꢓ [ꢓ Dꢄ)ꢍꢇ ꢇꢆ% !ꢓ Yꢓ {ꢀꢆ& ꢔ
hꢒ&ꢁꢏꢅꢂꢃꢉꢁꢊꢊꢄꢈꢇꢔ ꢐꢑ Dꢔ ((ꢔ !GꢑDꢓ <ꢈ@ wꢓ {ꢃꢆꢀꢔ Çꢓ Iꢓ Iꢇꢈꢈꢔ .ꢓ tꢓ
Ç ꢀꢁ 7ꢃꢅ6 7ꢇꢁ ꢁꢄ))ꢃꢅꢍꢊ% 0ꢋ ꢍ ꢊ bꢇꢍꢀꢃꢆꢇꢈ bꢇꢍꢄꢅꢇꢈ {ꢌꢀꢊꢆꢌꢊ
Cꢃꢄꢆ%ꢇꢍꢀꢃꢆ ꢃꢎ / ꢀꢆꢇ <bꢃꢓ ꢐ Aꢑꢐꢑ ꢑ ꢍꢃ ùꢓ òꢇꢆ&ꢔ ꢇꢆ% bꢃꢓ
ꢐ ?Eꢐꢑ E ꢍꢃ Wꢓ óꢓ óꢄ@ꢔ ꢍ ꢊ .Ü/Ç Cꢄꢆ% ꢎꢃꢅ 5ꢀꢁꢌꢀ)ꢈꢀꢆꢊ
/ꢃꢆꢁꢍꢅꢄꢌꢍꢀꢃꢆ ꢇꢆ% 5ꢊ'ꢊꢈꢃ)ꢏꢊꢆꢍ <tꢅꢃꢂꢊꢌꢍ bꢃꢓ óY ?!!ꢔ ꢍꢃ ùꢓ
òꢇꢆ&@ꢔ ꢇꢆ% ꢍ ꢊ / ꢀꢆꢇ tꢃꢁꢍ%ꢃꢌꢍꢃꢅꢇꢈ {ꢌꢀꢊꢆꢌꢊ Cꢃꢄꢆ%ꢇꢍꢀꢃꢆ <bꢃꢓ
ꢐꢑ AaAꢑꢑ-ꢑꢑꢔ ꢍꢃ ùꢓ òꢇꢆ&@ꢓ 5ꢅꢓ Wꢓ [ꢀꢄ ꢍ ꢇꢆ6ꢁ tꢅꢃꢎꢓ ùꢓ òꢇꢆ& ꢇꢆ%
tꢅꢃꢎꢓ Wꢓ óꢓ óꢄ ꢎꢃꢅ )ꢅꢃ'ꢀ%ꢀꢆ& ꢇ ꢁ ꢃꢅꢍ"ꢍꢊꢅꢏ 'ꢀꢁꢀꢍꢀꢆ& )ꢃꢁꢀꢍꢀꢃꢆ ꢀꢆ tꢅꢃꢎꢓ
óꢄCꢁ ꢈꢇ0ꢃꢅꢇꢍꢃꢅꢋꢓ
bꢀꢓꢇꢌ ꢄꢃꢑ ꢂꢇꢖꢇꢂꢇꢃꢍꢇꢌ
aꢀꢍꢌ ꢊꢈꢈꢔ aꢓ wꢓ h7ꢊꢆ ꢇꢆ% aꢓ íꢀꢈꢈꢁꢔ Wꢀ hꢒ&ꢀ /ꢓꢃꢂꢓꢔ ꢐꢑ ?ꢔ -ꢈ
AEGDꢔ ꢇꢆ% ꢅꢊꢎꢊꢅꢊꢆꢌꢊꢁ ꢌꢀꢍꢊ% ꢍ ꢊꢅꢊꢀꢆꢓ
ꢔ
G
-
<ꢇ@ òꢓ íꢊꢀꢔ 5ꢓ óꢄꢊꢔ vꢓ [ꢊꢀꢔ /ꢓ íꢇꢆ& ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ óꢀꢇꢃꢔ Dꢒꢃꢃꢏ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀꢔ
ꢐꢑ !ꢔ ꢉ*ꢔ Aꢐ-ꢓ <0@ 5ꢓ Çꢇꢈ7ꢇꢅꢔ óꢓ íꢄꢔ hꢓ {ꢇꢀ%ꢀꢔ bꢓ tꢓ {ꢇꢈ&ꢄꢊꢅꢃ
ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ óꢀꢇꢃꢔ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ 9ꢑꢒꢀ Wꢀꢔ ꢐꢑ Dꢔ ꢈꢔ ꢐG!?ꢓ
<ꢇ@ ùꢓ òꢇꢆ&ꢔ ùꢓ ù ꢄꢔ wꢓ [ꢄꢃꢔ óꢓ vꢀꢄꢔ Wꢓ [ꢀꢄꢔ Wꢓ"Yꢓ òꢇꢆ& ꢇꢆ% íꢓ
Çꢇꢆ&ꢔ Dꢒꢃꢃꢏ /ꢓꢃꢂꢓꢔ ꢐꢑ Eꢔ ꢉ<ꢔ !ꢐ-Aꢓ <0@ ùꢓ òꢇꢆ&ꢔ wꢓ [ꢄꢃꢔ ùꢓ ù ꢄꢔ
óꢓ òꢇꢆ& ꢇꢆ% íꢓ Çꢇꢆ&ꢔ hꢒ&ꢁꢏꢅꢂꢃꢉꢁꢊꢊꢄꢈꢇꢔ ꢐꢑ Eꢔ (+ꢔ Dꢑ-?ꢓ
Cꢃꢅ ꢁꢊꢈꢊꢌꢍꢊ% ꢅꢊ'ꢀꢊ7ꢁꢔ ꢁꢊꢊ, <ꢇ@ .ꢓ {ꢍꢊꢎꢇꢆꢊ ꢇꢆ% Cꢓ tꢃ:&ꢇꢆꢔ Çꢅꢐꢀ
/ꢑꢒꢀ /ꢓꢃꢂꢓꢔ ꢐꢑ Aꢔ (,)ꢔ Gꢓ <0@ tꢓ"Dꢓ 9ꢌ ꢊ'ꢊꢅꢅꢀꢇꢔ Çꢓ !ꢋꢇ%ꢔ tꢓ
t ꢇꢆꢁꢇ'ꢇꢍ ꢇꢆ% ëꢓ wꢇꢍꢃ'ꢊꢈꢃꢏꢇꢆꢇꢆꢇ"ëꢀ%ꢇꢈꢔ {ꢋꢏꢉꢓꢃꢇꢄꢇꢔ ꢐꢑ Aꢔ
)-ꢔ ꢐ?ꢐ!"ꢐ?!-ꢓ <ꢌ@ 5ꢓ íꢇꢆ& ꢇꢆ% 5ꢓ !ꢁꢍꢅꢄꢌꢓ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ wꢃꢔꢀ ꢐꢑ ?ꢔ
ꢉꢉ*ꢔ AAꢐ ꢓ <%@ Cꢓ Cꢃꢄ0ꢊꢈꢃꢔ /ꢓ bꢇꢂꢊꢅꢇ ꢇꢆ% aꢓ òꢄꢁꢔ Çꢃꢉꢒꢁꢓꢃꢍꢒꢅꢏ
!ꢇꢋꢂꢂꢃꢉꢒꢋꢔ ꢐꢑ ?ꢔ +ꢔ EA-ꢓ <ꢊ@ !ꢓ .ꢇꢅꢍꢃꢁ:ꢊ7ꢀꢌ:ꢔ bꢓ ! ꢈꢁꢍꢊꢆꢔ .ꢓ
aꢇꢅꢍꢀꢆ"aꢇꢍꢄꢍꢊꢔ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ 9ꢑꢒꢀ Wꢀ# ꢐꢑ !ꢔ ꢉ<ꢔ EꢐEDꢓ <ꢎ@ Wꢓ ëꢇꢌꢈꢇ'ꢀ6ꢔ
ꢑ D"Iꢊ)ꢍꢇꢆꢃꢆꢊ ꢌꢃꢄꢈ% 0ꢊ ꢅꢊ%ꢄꢌꢊ% ꢄꢆ%ꢊꢅ ꢍ ꢊ ꢁꢍꢇꢆ%ꢇꢅ%
ꢌꢃꢆ%ꢀꢍꢀꢃꢆꢁꢔ 0ꢊꢌꢇꢄꢁꢊ ꢃꢎ ꢈꢇꢅ&ꢊ ꢁꢍꢊꢅꢀꢌ ꢀꢆ%ꢅꢇꢆꢌꢊ ꢍ ꢊ ꢍ7ꢃ ꢏ"
)ꢅꢃ)ꢋꢈ &ꢅꢃꢄ)ꢁ ꢇ%ꢂꢇꢌꢊꢆꢍ ꢍꢃ ꢍ ꢊ ꢌꢇꢅ0ꢃꢆꢋꢈꢓ
<ꢇ@ {ꢓ aꢓ aꢊ%ꢇꢅ%ꢊꢔ {ꢓ {ꢇꢆꢌ ꢊ:"tꢇꢈꢃꢏꢀꢆꢃꢔ .ꢓ aꢓ aꢇ%ꢅꢀ&ꢇꢈꢔ Wꢓ
!ꢈꢌꢇꢏꢀꢔ 9ꢓ aꢄꢆꢃ: ꢇꢆ% !ꢓ {ꢓ Cꢊꢈꢀꢌꢀꢇꢆꢃꢔ .ꢄꢅꢅꢒ&ꢀ aꢃꢍꢀ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ
[ꢃꢉꢉꢓꢔ ꢐꢑꢑDꢔ ꢉ)ꢔ DDG!ꢓ <0@ 5ꢓ Wꢓ bꢃꢅꢅꢀꢁꢔ Dꢓ ëꢓ 5ꢊꢈꢄꢌꢌꢇꢔ !ꢓ ëꢓ
Dꢇ'ꢇꢀꢔ /ꢓ !ꢓ vꢄꢊꢁꢆꢊꢈꢈꢊꢔ tꢓ Dꢀꢈꢈꢔ 5ꢓ hUaꢇꢈꢈꢊꢋꢔ íꢓ ëꢇꢌꢌꢇꢅꢃꢔ Cꢓ òꢓ
[ꢊꢊꢔ aꢓ ëꢓ 5ꢊ0ꢊꢆꢊ%ꢊꢍꢍꢃꢔ !ꢓ tꢓ 5ꢊ&ꢆꢇꢆꢔ Iꢓ Cꢇꢆ&ꢔ aꢓ 5ꢓ Iꢀꢈꢈꢔ Iꢓ
Iꢄꢇꢆ&ꢔ íꢓ 5ꢓ {ꢌ ꢏꢀꢍ:ꢔ Wꢓ 9ꢓ Wꢅꢓ {ꢍꢇꢅꢅꢊꢍꢍꢔ íꢓ"/ꢓ Iꢇꢆꢔ Wꢓ {ꢓ
tꢓ Yꢇꢌꢊꢅꢔ aꢓ Yꢄ:ꢏꢇ ꢇꢆ% [ꢓ /ꢊꢅ'ꢊꢆꢋꢔ aꢅꢊꢃꢈꢑꢊꢃꢇ# ꢐꢑ ꢔ ꢉ+
ꢔ
?DAꢑꢓ <&@ wꢓ Iꢓ aꢃꢅꢅꢀꢁꢔ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ {ꢅꢈꢀ wꢃꢔꢓꢔ ꢐꢑꢑ-ꢔ (-ꢔ ꢐꢐGꢐꢓ < @ íꢓ
.ꢇꢅꢇꢍꢍꢇꢔ tꢓ wꢀ&ꢃꢔ 9ꢑꢒꢀ Wꢀ Lꢏꢅꢒ&ꢀ/ꢓꢃꢂꢓꢔ ꢐꢑꢑGꢔ +ꢔ DꢑD ꢓ <ꢀ@ Çꢓ
L6ꢇꢅꢀꢋꢇꢔ !ꢓ Wꢓ .ꢈꢇꢌ6ꢊꢅꢔ !ꢈꢈꢀ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ wꢃꢇꢀꢔ ꢐꢑꢑEꢔ )ꢈꢔ !ꢑꢑꢓ <ꢂ@ Çꢓ
L6ꢇꢅꢀꢋꢇꢔ Yꢓ aꢄꢅꢇꢍꢇꢇ ꢇꢆ% wꢓ bꢃꢋꢃꢅꢀ0ꢓ hꢒ&ꢀ .ꢄꢅꢂꢅꢊꢀ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀꢔ ꢐꢑꢑAꢔ
)ꢔ !-!ꢓ <6@ Wꢓ"9ꢓ .ꢇꢌ6'ꢇꢈꢈꢔ Wꢀ hꢒ&ꢁꢏꢅꢂꢃꢉꢁꢊꢀ /ꢓꢃꢂꢓꢔ ꢐꢑꢑꢐꢔ +*
ꢑ?ꢓ
ꢔ
ꢐ
!
D
Cꢃꢅ ꢁꢊꢈꢊꢌꢍꢊ% ꢅꢊ'ꢀꢊ7ꢁꢔ ꢁꢊꢊ, <ꢇ@ óꢓ íꢄꢔ /ꢓ íꢇꢆ&ꢔ ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ óꢀꢇꢃꢓ
/ꢓꢃꢂꢀ wꢃꢈꢀꢔ ꢐꢑ Aꢔ ꢉ+ꢔ ꢐEEꢐꢓ <0@ òꢓ"aꢓ Iꢊ ꢇꢆ% vꢓ"Iꢓ Cꢇꢆꢔ
/ꢓꢃꢂ/ꢁꢉ/ꢓꢃꢂ# ꢐꢑ ?ꢔ ,ꢔ !-Gꢓ <ꢌ@ òꢓ íꢊꢀꢔ óꢓ íꢄꢔ /ꢓ íꢇꢆ& ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ
Çꢃ6ꢇꢅꢁ6ꢀꢔ {ꢓ ꢈꢓ Yꢓ aꢇꢆ%ꢇꢈꢔ t/Ç Lꢏꢉꢀ !ꢐꢐꢊꢀ# ꢈꢉ*
ꢔ íh
ꢐꢑ ? ꢑꢑꢐGꢐ ! ꢐꢑ ?ꢑEꢑꢐꢓ <ꢌ@ {ꢓ"Wꢓ bꢇꢏꢔ {ꢓ tꢓ Dꢇꢄ%ꢊꢆꢌꢀꢃꢔ /ꢓ
!ꢓ Yꢇꢄꢎꢎꢏꢇꢆꢔ tꢓ wꢓ Wꢊꢆꢁꢊꢆꢔ Çꢓ tꢓ Yꢃꢆ%ꢅꢇꢍꢋꢄ6ꢔ [ꢓ 9ꢓ aꢇꢅꢈꢊꢅꢔ Wꢓ aꢓ
tꢊ::ꢄꢍꢃ ꢇꢆ% íꢓ Cꢊꢆꢀꢌꢇꢈꢔ Wꢀ bꢁꢉꢀ tꢒꢅꢍꢀ# ꢐꢑ ꢑꢔ ,(ꢔ ꢑGꢑꢓ <%@ aꢓ
Dꢃꢄꢈꢊꢍꢔ aꢓ Wꢓ íꢋ'ꢅꢇꢍꢍꢔ tꢓ Wꢓ {ꢀꢆꢌꢈꢇꢀꢅ ꢇꢆ% Cꢓ íꢃꢆ&ꢔ 9ꢑꢒꢀ tꢁꢉꢀ
!ꢐꢐꢊꢀ# ꢉ<< ꢔ 9t ? ?ꢑE !ꢐ --ꢐ ꢐ?ꢓ <ꢊ@ !ꢓ . ꢇꢍꢍꢇꢌ ꢇꢅꢂꢊꢊꢔ òꢓ
5ꢄꢔ 9ꢓ aꢓ 5ꢄꢎꢎꢋꢔ Dꢓ 9ꢓ Wꢃ0ꢔ wꢓ [ꢃꢄꢔ ùꢓ [ꢄꢃꢔ Iꢓ hU5ꢃ7%ꢔ òꢓ Çꢇꢆ&
ꢇꢆ% òꢓ íꢄꢔ t/Ç Lꢏꢉꢀ !ꢐꢐꢊꢓꢔ ꢈꢈ-ꢔ íh ꢐꢑꢑG ꢑAꢐꢐD !
ꢐꢑꢑGꢑ-ꢑDꢓ
óꢀꢇꢃꢔ /ꢁꢉꢁꢊꢀ Çꢅꢍꢁꢋ ꢐꢑ ?ꢔ ),ꢔ ꢑDꢓ <%@ óꢓ íꢄꢔ ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ óꢀꢇꢃꢔ
Iꢋꢍꢒꢅ&ꢃꢏꢁꢉꢄꢅꢏ ꢁꢏꢍ Çꢒꢁꢏꢇ)ꢃꢒ Iꢋꢍꢒꢅ&ꢃꢏꢁꢉꢄꢅꢏ ꢄꢏ íꢁꢉꢃꢒꢔ ꢀꢆ
aꢃꢉꢁꢊ+/ꢁꢉꢁꢊꢋ,ꢃꢍ wꢃꢁꢈꢉꢄꢅꢏꢇ ꢄꢏ íꢁꢉꢃꢒ <ꢊ%ꢁ tꢓ Iꢓ 5ꢀꢒꢆꢊꢄꢎ ꢇꢆ% ëꢓ
/ꢇ%ꢀꢊꢅꢆꢃ@ꢔ íꢀꢈꢊꢋ"ë/Iꢔ íꢊꢀꢆ ꢊꢀꢏꢔ Dꢊꢅꢏꢇꢆꢋꢓ ꢈꢉ(= t)ꢓ E!"
ꢐDꢐꢓ <ꢊ@ òꢓ Çꢇꢆ& ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ 5ꢊꢆ&ꢔ tꢒꢅ&ꢀ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀꢔ ꢐꢑ ꢑꢔ ꢔ ꢐDꢐꢓ <ꢎ@
óꢓ íꢄ ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ óꢀꢇꢃꢔ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ /ꢅꢂꢂꢑꢏꢓꢔ ꢐꢑꢑEꢔ )ꢔ ꢐDD-ꢓ <&@ Wꢓ
óꢀꢇꢃꢔ óꢓ íꢄꢔ !ꢓ ùꢇꢆꢃꢍꢍꢀ"Dꢊꢅꢃꢁꢇ ꢇꢆ% Cꢓ Iꢇꢆꢌꢃꢌ6ꢔ /ꢓꢄꢂꢀ h&&ꢄꢔ
ꢐꢑꢑ?ꢔ (ꢔ ?ꢑꢓ < @ /ꢓ íꢇꢆ&ꢔ óꢓ íꢄꢔ ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ óꢀꢇꢃꢓ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ !ꢇꢄꢁꢏ Wꢓꢔ
ꢐ Lꢆ ꢍ ꢊ ꢅꢊ%ꢄꢌꢍꢀꢃꢆ ꢃꢎ 8"<b#b"%ꢀꢏꢊꢍ ꢋꢈꢇꢏꢀꢆꢃ@ ꢇꢌꢊꢍꢃ) ꢊꢆꢃꢆꢊꢔ "
) ꢊꢆꢋꢈꢊꢍ ꢇꢆꢃꢈ ꢇꢆ% 0ꢊꢆ:ꢃꢀꢌ ꢇꢌꢀ% 7ꢊꢅꢊ ꢀ%ꢊꢆꢍꢀꢎꢀꢊ%ꢓ
ꢐꢑꢑGꢔ
Cꢃꢅ ꢁꢊꢈꢊꢌꢍꢊ% ꢅꢊ'ꢀꢊ7ꢁ ꢃꢆ &ꢅꢊꢊꢆ ꢌ ꢊꢏꢀꢁꢍꢅꢋꢔ ꢁꢊꢊ, <ꢇ@ [ꢓ {ꢃ ꢇꢆ%
aꢓ Wꢓ 9ꢌ6ꢊꢈꢏꢇꢆꢓ !/{ {ꢑꢇꢉꢀ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ 9ꢏ&ꢀ# ꢐꢑ Aꢔ ꢔ ?Gꢐ ꢓ <0@ Cꢓ
(ꢔ E?ꢑꢓ
! Cꢃꢅ ꢇ ꢅꢊ'ꢀꢊ7 ꢃꢆ %ꢊꢌꢃꢏ)ꢃꢁꢀꢍꢀꢃꢆ ꢃꢎ ꢎꢃꢅꢏꢀꢌ ꢇꢌꢀ%ꢔ ꢁꢊꢊ, <ꢇ@ 5ꢓ
aꢊꢈꢈꢏꢇꢆꢆꢔ tꢓ {)ꢃꢆ ꢃꢈ:ꢔ Iꢓ Wꢄꢆ&ꢊ ꢇꢆ% aꢓ .ꢊꢈꢈꢊꢅꢓ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ {ꢅꢈꢀ
wꢃꢔꢀ# ꢐꢑ Aꢔ )*ꢔ !-?Dꢓ Cꢃꢅ ꢅꢊ)ꢃꢅꢍꢁ ꢃꢆ %ꢊꢍꢇꢀꢈꢊ% ꢏꢊꢌ ꢇꢆꢀꢁꢏ ꢎꢃꢅ
&ꢊꢆꢊꢅꢇꢍꢀꢃꢆ ꢃꢎ ꢀꢅꢀ%ꢀꢄꢏ ꢋ%ꢅꢀ%ꢊꢁ ꢀꢆ ꢎꢃꢅꢏꢀꢌ ꢇꢌꢀ% %ꢊꢌꢃꢏ)ꢃꢁꢀꢍꢀꢃꢆꢔ
ꢁꢊꢊ, <0@ íꢓ"Iꢓ íꢇꢆ&ꢔ {ꢓ óꢄꢔ òꢓ aꢇꢆꢇ6ꢇꢔ òꢓ {ꢄꢆꢇꢔ Iꢓ
Yꢇꢏ0ꢇꢋꢇꢁ ꢀꢔ Wꢓ Çꢓ aꢄꢌ6ꢊꢅꢏꢇꢆꢔ 9ꢓ Cꢄꢂꢀꢍꢇ ꢇꢆ% òꢓ Iꢀꢏꢊ%ꢇꢔ
)
tꢊꢆꢇ"tꢊꢅꢊꢀꢅꢇꢔ !ꢓ Yꢈꢃꢁ6ꢃ7ꢁ6ꢀꢌ ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ bꢇꢏꢀꢊTꢆꢀ6ꢓ Dꢒꢃꢃꢏ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ#
ꢐꢑ ?ꢔ ꢉ,ꢔ !AGEꢓ <ꢌ@ tꢓ Dꢓ Wꢊꢁꢁꢃ)ꢔ 5ꢓ !ꢓ Wꢊꢁꢁꢃ)ꢔ 5ꢓ Cꢄ ꢇꢆ% [ꢓ
t ꢇꢆꢓ Dꢒꢃꢃꢏ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ ꢐꢑ ꢐꢔ ꢉ)ꢔ ꢐD?ꢓ <%@ tꢓ Wꢓ 5ꢄꢆꢆꢓ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ {ꢅꢈꢀ
wꢃꢔꢀ# ꢐꢑ ꢐꢔ )ꢉꢔ D?ꢐꢓ <ꢊ@ wꢓ !ꢓ { ꢊꢈ%ꢃꢆꢓ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ {ꢅꢈꢀ wꢃꢔꢀ#
ꢐꢑ ꢐꢔ )ꢉꢔ D!Eꢓ <ꢎ@ aꢓ"hꢓ {ꢀꢏꢃꢆ ꢇꢆ% /ꢓ"Wꢓ [ꢀꢓ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ {ꢅꢈꢀ wꢃꢔꢀ#
ꢐꢑ ꢐꢔ )ꢉꢔ D ?ꢓ <&@ wꢓ !ꢓ { ꢊꢈ%ꢃꢆꢓ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ /ꢅꢂꢂꢑꢏꢀ# ꢐꢑꢑGꢔ
!!?ꢐꢓ < @ Yꢓ !ꢈꢎꢃꢆꢁꢀꢔ Wꢓ /ꢃꢈ0ꢊꢅ&ꢔ tꢓ Wꢓ 5ꢄꢆꢆꢔ Çꢓ Cꢊ'ꢀ&ꢔ {ꢓ
Wꢊꢆꢆꢀꢆ&ꢁꢔ Çꢓ !ꢓ Wꢃ ꢆꢁꢃꢆꢔ Iꢓ tꢓ Yꢈꢊꢀꢆꢊꢔ /ꢓ Yꢆꢀ& ꢍꢔ aꢓ !ꢓ bꢇ&ꢋꢔ 5ꢓ
!ꢓ tꢊꢅꢅꢋ ꢇꢆ% aꢓ {ꢍꢊꢎꢇꢆꢀꢇ6ꢓ Dꢒꢃꢃꢏ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ# ꢐꢑꢑGꢔ ꢉꢈꢔ ! ꢓ <ꢀ@ /ꢓ"Wꢓ
[ꢀ ꢇꢆ% [ꢓ / ꢊꢆꢓ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ {ꢅꢈꢀ wꢃꢔꢀ# ꢐꢑꢑAꢔ (*ꢔ AGꢓ
/ꢓꢃꢂ{ꢑꢇ/ꢓꢃꢂꢔ ꢐꢑ Dꢔ
{ꢓ óꢄꢔ bꢓ hꢆꢀꢁ ꢀꢔ òꢓ aꢇꢆꢇ6ꢇꢔ òꢓ {ꢄꢆꢇꢔ Iꢓ Yꢇꢏ0ꢇꢋꢇꢁ ꢀꢔ Wꢓ Çꢓ
aꢄꢌ6ꢊꢅꢏꢇꢆꢔ 9ꢓ Cꢄꢂꢀꢍꢇ ꢇꢆ% òꢓ Iꢀꢏꢊ%ꢇꢔ !/{ /ꢁꢉꢁꢊꢀ# ꢐꢑ ?ꢔ
,ꢔ -EAꢓ <ꢌ@ íꢓ"Iꢓ íꢇꢆ&ꢔ aꢓ ùꢓ 9ꢅꢍꢊꢏꢔ
*ꢔ
?D-Aꢓ <%@ bꢓ hꢆꢀꢁ ꢀꢔ aꢓ ùꢓ 9ꢅꢍꢊꢏꢔ {ꢓ óꢄꢔ !ꢓ Çꢁꢄꢅꢄꢁꢇ6ꢀꢔ òꢓ
aꢇꢆꢇ6ꢇꢔ Wꢓ Çꢓ aꢄꢌ6ꢊꢅꢏꢇꢆꢔ 9ꢓ Cꢄꢂꢀꢍ ꢇꢆ% òꢓ Iꢀꢏꢊ%ꢇꢔ /ꢁꢉꢁꢊꢀ {ꢈꢄꢀ
Çꢃꢈꢓꢏꢅꢊꢀꢔ ꢐꢑ Aꢔ
ꢇꢆ% /ꢓ [ꢀꢔ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ 9ꢑꢒꢀ Wꢀ# ꢐꢑ ?ꢔ ꢉꢔ ꢐ?-ꢐꢓ <ꢎ@ Wꢓ Iꢓ .ꢇꢅꢆꢇꢅ%ꢔ /ꢓ
íꢇꢆ&ꢔ bꢓ Dꢓ .ꢊꢅꢅꢋꢇ ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ óꢀꢇꢃꢔ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ {ꢈꢄꢀ# ꢐꢑ !ꢔ ꢔ ꢐ!Dꢓ <&@
<ꢎ@ Wꢓ [ꢀꢔ Wꢓ [ꢀꢔ 5ꢓ ù ꢇꢆ& ꢇꢆ% /ꢓ [ꢀꢄꢔ !/{ /ꢁꢉꢁꢊꢀ# ꢐꢑ Aꢔ ꢔ DEDAꢓ
+ꢔ -GGꢓ <ꢊ@ ùꢓ íꢇꢆ&ꢔ {ꢓ"aꢓ [ꢄꢔ Wꢓ [ꢀꢔ Wꢓ íꢇꢆ&
<ꢇ@ wꢓ .ꢇꢅꢔ [ꢓ Yꢓ .ꢇꢅꢔ òꢓ {ꢇꢁꢁꢃꢆꢔ Wꢓ .ꢈꢄꢏꢔ Wꢀ aꢅꢊꢀ /ꢁꢉꢀꢔ -G?ꢔ ((
A ꢓ <0@ wꢓ .ꢇꢅꢔ òꢓ {ꢇꢁꢁꢃꢆꢔ Wꢓ .ꢈꢄꢏꢔ Wꢀ aꢅꢊꢀ /ꢁꢉꢀꢔ -GDꢔ +ꢔ !ꢐEꢓ
!ꢓ .ꢊꢆꢋꢊꢀꢔ Cꢓ Wꢃꢃꢔ Wꢀ aꢅꢊꢀ /ꢁꢉꢓꢔ --ꢑꢔ *-ꢔ ? ꢓ
ꢔ
)
+
?
A
< @ ùꢓ íꢇꢆ&ꢔ {ꢓ"aꢓ [ꢄꢔ Wꢓ íꢄꢔ /ꢓ [ꢀ ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ óꢀꢇꢃꢔ 9ꢑꢒꢀ Wꢀ Lꢏꢅꢒ&ꢀ
/ꢓꢃꢂꢀ# ꢐꢑ Aꢔ D-ꢑꢓ
<ꢇ@ {ꢓ h&ꢃꢔ bꢓ aꢇ6ꢀ ꢇꢅꢇ ꢇꢆ% òꢓ íꢇꢍꢇꢆꢇ0ꢊꢓ hꢒ&ꢁꢏꢅꢂꢃꢉꢁꢊꢊꢄꢈꢇ#
---ꢔ ꢉ-ꢔ ?DEꢑꢓ <0@ {ꢓ h&ꢃꢔ bꢓ aꢇ6ꢀ ꢇꢅꢇꢔ òꢓ Yꢇꢆꢊ6ꢃ ꢇꢆ% òꢓ
íꢇꢍꢇꢆꢇ0ꢊꢔ hꢒ&ꢁꢏꢅꢂꢃꢉꢁꢊꢊꢄꢈꢇꢔ ꢐꢑꢑ ꢔ ꢈꢔ D-ꢑ!ꢓ <ꢌ@ Çꢓ !0ꢄꢅꢇꢔ {ꢓ
h&ꢃꢔ òꢓ íꢇꢍꢇꢆꢇ0ꢊ ꢇꢆ% {ꢓ Cꢄ6ꢄ:ꢄꢏꢀꢔ Wꢀ !ꢂꢀ /ꢓꢃꢂꢀ {ꢅꢈꢓꢔ ꢐꢑꢑ!ꢔ
ꢉ *ꢔ D D-ꢓ
Cꢃꢅ ꢁꢊꢈꢊꢌꢍꢊ% ꢊꢒꢇꢏ)ꢈꢊꢁꢔ ꢁꢊꢊ, <ꢇ@ Iꢓ òꢓ w ꢋꢃꢃꢔ Iꢓ "Wꢓ tꢇꢅ6ꢔ íꢓ Iꢓ
{ꢄ ꢇꢆ% íꢓ Yꢓ / ꢄꢆ&ꢔ Çꢃꢉꢒꢁꢓꢃꢍꢒꢅꢏ [ꢃꢉꢉꢓꢔ ꢐꢑꢑꢐꢔ )(ꢔ ꢐA-ꢓ <0@ òꢓ
Iꢀꢏꢊ%ꢇꢔ bꢓ hꢆꢃ:ꢇ7ꢇ"Yꢃꢏꢇꢍꢁꢄ:ꢇ6ꢀꢔ Iꢓ {ꢄ&ꢀ ꢇꢅꢇꢔ Iꢓ !ꢅꢇ6ꢇ7ꢇ
ꢇꢆ% Yꢓ Yꢇꢁꢄ&ꢇꢔ Wꢀ aꢅꢊꢀ /ꢁꢉꢁꢊꢀ ! /ꢓꢃꢂꢓꢔ ꢐꢑꢑ!ꢔ ꢉ<*ꢔ -?ꢓ <ꢌ@ /ꢓ
.ꢄ0ꢊꢅꢍꢔ Wꢓ .ꢈꢇꢌ6ꢊꢅꢔ {ꢓ aꢓ .ꢅꢃ7ꢆꢔ Wꢓ /ꢅꢃꢁ0ꢋꢔ {ꢓ Cꢀꢍ:ꢂꢃ ꢆꢔ Wꢓ tꢓ
aꢄꢒ7ꢃꢅꢍ ꢋꢔ Çꢓ Ç ꢃꢅ)ꢊ ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ aꢓ Wꢓ íꢀꢈꢈꢀꢇꢏꢁꢔ Çꢃꢉꢒꢁꢓꢃꢍꢒꢅꢏ
[ꢃꢉꢉꢓꢔ ꢐꢑꢑ ꢔ ) ꢔ Dꢑ!Eꢓ <%@ Çꢓ Ç ꢃꢅ)ꢊꢔ Wꢓ .ꢈꢇꢌ6ꢊꢅꢔ {ꢓaꢓ .ꢅꢃ7ꢆꢔ /ꢓ
.ꢄ0ꢊꢅꢍꢔ Wꢓ /ꢅꢃꢁ0ꢋꢔ {ꢓ Cꢀꢍ:ꢂꢃ ꢆꢔ Wꢓ tꢓ aꢄꢒ7ꢃꢅꢍ ꢋ ꢇꢆ% Wꢓ aꢓ Wꢓ
D !/ baw ꢁꢍꢄ%ꢀꢊꢁ %ꢊꢏꢃꢆꢁꢍꢅꢇꢍꢊ ꢍ ꢇꢍ )ꢅꢃꢍꢃꢆ ꢌꢇꢆ ꢇꢌꢍꢀ'ꢇꢍꢊ
6ꢊꢍꢃꢆꢊꢁꢓ Cꢃꢅ %ꢊꢍꢇꢀꢈꢔ ꢁꢊꢊ Cꢀ&ꢄꢅꢊ {ꢐ ꢀꢆ 9{Lꢓ
? Ç ꢊ YL9 ꢁꢍꢄ%ꢀꢊꢁ 7ꢊꢅꢊ ꢇꢈꢁꢃ )ꢊꢅꢎꢃꢅꢏꢊ% ꢀꢆ ꢍ ꢊ %ꢊ ꢋ%ꢅꢃ&ꢊꢆꢇꢍꢀꢃꢆ
ꢃꢎ ꢎꢃꢅꢏꢀꢌ ꢇꢌꢀ% ꢌꢇꢍꢇꢈꢋ:ꢊ% 0ꢋ <ꢐꢔꢐC"0ꢀ"ꢐ"ꢀꢏꢀ%ꢇ:ꢃꢈꢀꢆꢊ@"Lꢅ ꢌꢃꢏ)ꢈꢊꢒ
ꢎꢅꢃꢏ [ꢀCꢁ &ꢅꢃꢄ)ꢓ
E
+ # Wꢀ bꢁꢂꢃꢓꢔ ꢐꢑ ꢐꢔ ꢈꢈꢔ "!
Ç ꢀꢁ ꢂꢃꢄꢅꢆꢇꢈ ꢀꢁ ꢉ Ç ꢊ wꢃꢋꢇꢈ {ꢃꢌꢀꢊꢍꢋ ꢃꢎ / ꢊꢏꢀꢁꢍꢅꢋ ꢐꢑꢒꢒ
tꢈꢊꢇꢁꢊ %ꢃ ꢆꢃꢍ ꢇ%ꢂꢄꢁꢍ ꢏꢇꢅ&ꢀꢆꢁ