Angewandte
Chemie
Table 1: Hydrogenation of 4b with MIC- and NHC-based borenium ions.
higher catalyst loading (entry 8). Finally, under standard
conditions, B(C6F5)3 gave no reaction.
In terms of substrate scope, the reaction is sensitive to
catalyst inhibition by imines and product amines lacking steric
bulk. Thus, although N-Ph ketimines are effective substrates,
the corresponding N-Bn compounds provide only trace
product. However, the benzhydryl protecting group was
a useful alternative, giving 26% yield at 1 atm, and 90% at
5 atm pressure.[17] To assess functional group compatibility,
the hydrogenation of 4b was run concurrently with 1 equiv of
fenchone and showed 82% product by NMR spectroscopy
and no reduction of fenchone, indicating that the ketone is not
a competitive substrate. However, less hindered methoxycar-
bonyl substituents do inhibit the reduction of imine function-
alities.[17]
Entry[a] Catalyst R1/R2
Loading [%] t [h] Conversion [%][b]
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
3b
3b
3b
3g
3c
3c
3e
3d
Ph/Ph
Ph/Ph
Ph/Ph
iPr/iPr
anisyl/anisyl
anisyl/anisyl 2.5
DiPP/Ph
Me/Ph
–
10
5
2.5
5
19
23
24
23
100 (87)
100
40
37
5
17.5 100
24
17.5 33
0
5
5
5
6.5
40
0
Next we investigated the ability of MIC-borenium-based
catalysts to reduce N-heterocycles 6a–k (Figure 4). Remark-
B(C6F5)3
17.5
[a] 0.25 mmol imine in 0.25 mL CH2Cl2 in a Schlenk tube, 1 atm H2,
1200 rpm stir rate. [b] Conversion estimated by 1H NMR spectroscopy,
yield of isolated products in brackets.
borenium 3a reduced imine 4a quantitatively in less than 4 h
at 100 atm hydrogen pressure. Decreasing the pressure to
38 atm and then 22 atm under otherwise identical conditions,
gave conversions of 50% and 30%. Isosteric NHC-derivative
3h gave only 16% conversion under 38 atm of hydrogen
illustrating the importance of the electronic effect of the MIC
group and the higher inherent reactivity of MIC-stabilized
borenium ions in this reaction.
To further assess the effect of sterics on the reaction,
compound 3b with only one flanking phenyl group was
examined and found to be the most active of all compounds
tested (Figure 3). Complete reduction of the aldimine was
observed in all cases, although longer reaction times were
required at low pressures. Previously reported NHC-bore-
nium 3g had a reactivity similar to that of MIC-borenium 3b,
but at low conversion the MIC-borane was superior (pale blue
bar, Figure 3). Having developed conditions under which
metal-free hydrogenations can be affected in regular glass-
ware under mild conditions, we turned to the more challeng-
ing ketimine 4b.
Figure 4. Mild hydrogenation of N-heterocycles catalyzed by 3b. Reac-
tions at 1 atm: 6 (0.25 mmol) in CH2Cl2 in a Schlenk tube (0.5–1 m),
1200 rpm stir rate. Reactions at 5 or 102 atm: as above, but performed
in an autoclave, 700 rpm stir rate. Yields of isolated products after
purification by column chromatography; yields in parentheses were
1
determined by H NMR spectroscopy against an internal standard.
To our delight, using 10 mol% 3b under atmospheric
pressure at 258C, the reduction of 4b proceeded to full
conversion in 19 h giving 5b in 87% yield (Table 1, entry 1).
Lowering the catalyst loading to 5 mol% gave full conversion
in less than 24 h, but at 2.5 mol% the conversion was
diminished (entry 3). Comparison with NHC-based borenium
ion 3g (entry 4) illustrated the advantage of the MIC-
stabilized borenium ion 3b, because only 37% conversion
was obtained compared with 100%.
Whereas the p-anisyl-derived borenium 3c gave full
conversion at 5% loading in 17.5 h, it was clearly inferior to
3b at 2.5% loading (entries 3 versus 6). Remote steric effects
also impacted reactivity such that 3e, in which the distal N-
substituent is a diisopropyl phenyl group, showed decreased
reactivity (entry 7). Consistent with this, unsymmetrical MIC-
borenium ion 3d, with a methyl group at the distal position,
has the highest activity observed yet, giving the same yield as
diphenyl derivative 3b in one fourth of the time, albeit at
ably, 2- and 8-arylated quinoline derivatives were hydro-
genated at near ambient pressure and room temperature with
catalyst 3b, giving the corresponding isolated 1,2,3,4-tetrahy-
droquinolines 7a–g in good to excellent yields. Although
unfunctionalized quinoline or 3-arylated quinoline deriva-
tives failed to undergo reduction even at 100 atm of H2, 8-
methyl quinoline (6d) reacted quantitatively at only 5 atm of
H2. The lack of reactivity with less hindered systems is likely
due to strong coordination to the borenium-catalyst impeding
H2 activation.
At elevated H2 pressure (102 atm), even 2,6-disubstituted
pyridine derivatives were reactive giving products 7h–j as
single diastereomers. Despite the higher pressure, this system
is still mild compared to the most effective FLP-type systems
reported to date (1008C, 50 atm H2, 20 h, 10 mol% B-
((CH2)2C6F5)(C6F5)2).[18] 9,10-Phenanthroline was also reac-
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2015, 54, 1 – 6
ꢀ 2015 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
3
These are not the final page numbers!