Serendipitous assemblies of two large phosphonate cages: A Co15 distorted molecular cube and a Co12 butterfly type core structure

Article abstract of DOI:10.1021/ic3025183

This report describes the synthesis, characterization, and magnetic properties of two novel phosphonate-based Co^II cages. Structural investigation reveals some interesting geometrical features in the molecular core that may provide new models in single molecular magnetic materials.

Full text of DOI:10.1021/ic3025183

Communication
pubs.acs.org/IC
Serendipitous Assemblies of Two Large Phosphonate Cages: A Co15
Distorted Molecular Cube and a Co12 Butterfly Type Core Structure
Javeed Ahmad Sheikh, Soumyabrata Goswami, Amit Adhikary, and Sanjit Konar*
Department of Chemistry, IISER Bhopal, Bhopal-462023, India
S
* Supporting Information
[Co15(chp)8(chpH)(O3PR)8(O2CtBu)6(CH3CN)3]·(CH3CN)
(1) and [Co12(chpH)2(O3PR)4(O2CtBu)12(CO3)4]·(CH3CN)
ABSTRACT: This report describes the synthesis, charac-
terization, and magnetic properties of two novel
phosphonate-based CoII cages. Structural investigation
reveals some interesting geometrical features in the
molecular core that may provide new models in single
molecular magnetic materials.
(2), R= p-nitrobenzyl, chpH = 6-chloro-2-hydroxypyridine. All
the metals centers in both molecules are at a +II oxidation state as
required for the charge balances and confirmed by magnetic
measurements and BVS calculations (Table S1, Scheme2,
Supporting Information, SI).6 The molecular structure of
complex 1 consists of an inorganic core made of 15 CoII that
are held together by bridging oxygen atoms from eight doubly
deprotonated phosphonates and six carboxylate ligands (Figure
1). Nine 6-chloro-2-hydroxypyridine units are also present per
he study of nanoscopic paramagnetic metal-ion aggregates
Thas emerged as a focal point in material chemistry owing to
their immense technological applications.1 In the field of
molecule-based magnetic materials, studies have largely been
based on discrete transition-metal aggregates, as they typically
display properties of a single molecular magnet. A large number
of molecular magnetic aggregates have been documented in the
literature, where carboxylate, tripodal alkoxide, and related
ligands have been used.1a,2 In this context, phosphonate ligands
are an ideal choice, as they possess three O donors and are
capable of binding up to nine metal centers in principle. But, a
thorough literature survey reveals that phosphonate-based
transition metal complexes have rarely been employed for
discrete molecule synthesis owing to their tendency to form
layered structures and limited solubility.3 Over the past few years,
considerable progress has been achieved by the groups of
Winpenny, Clearfield, Chandrasekhar, and others to explore
metal-phosphonate cage compounds as magnetic materials.4
However, until today, most of the reported metal-phosphonate
clusters/cages bear core structures of irregular geometrical
pattern. From a magnetic point of view, regular polygonal
(Archimedean and Platonic solid) type paramagnetic cores are
extremely important and find wide applications.2c Unfortunately,
there are rare examples in the literature that demonstrate cages
with regular geometrical cores.
As part of the investigation in exploring cages with regular
geometrical cores, herein we report the synthesis, structural
characterization, and magnetic study of two novel phosphonate-
based CoII cage compounds. The geometry of the inorganic core
of the molecules can be best described as a combination of
Platonic as well as Archimedean type polygons. The phosphonic
acid ligand, p-nitrobenzylphosphonic, was synthesized following
the Michelis−Arbusov reaction5a,b from its corresponding
bromide. In two similar one pot reactions, the carboxylate
bridged cobalt dimer,5c [Co2(μ-OH2)(O2CtBu)4]·(HO2CtBu)4,
was reacted with phosphonic acid and 6-chloro-2-hydroxopyr-
idine. A mere change in ratio of the reactants from 1:1:1 to
1:1:0.5 in the above order resulted in the formation of two high
nuclearity cages having molecular formulas of
Figure 1. Color code: orange, cobalt; bluish-green, phosphorus; red,
oxygen; nitrogen, blue; gray, carbon; and green, chlorine. Hydrogen
atoms are omitted for clarity.
molecule and are functioning as nitrogen and oxygen donation
ligands towards cobalt sites. All the organic parts of the coligands
are pointed towards the outer periphery of the molecule. The
shape of the inorganic interior can be best described as a
distorted cubic unit made of metal and phosphorus tethered by
oxygen atoms (Figure 2a, Figure S8, SI). Out of the 15 CoII
centers, nine are exhibiting octahedral geometry, five tetrahedral,
and one square pyramidal arrangement (Table S1, SI). Six of the
eight phosphonate ligands are showing a 5.221 bridging mode
and another two are exhibiting a 3.111 mode as per Harris
notation7 (Scheme S1, SI). Another interesting perspective of
the structure was observed after removal of all the atoms except
Co and P centers and connecting them through imaginary lines
Received: November 17, 2012
© XXXX American Chemical Society
A
dx.doi.org/10.1021/ic3025183 | Inorg. Chem. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX

Inorganic Chemistry
Communication
Figure 2. (a) Core structure of 1, color code same as Figure 1. (b)
“Stick” type view of the core after removing all atoms except Co and P.
(Figure 2b). Here, each phosphorus (except P5 and P8) bears
five CoII centers as nearest neighbors, and thereby, a pentagonal
unit is formed. Each pentagon shares three vertices and an edge
with its adjoining pentagons and thereby forms a new type of
geometry having total six pentagonal and eight triangular faces
with each of the vertices occupied by a metal center. A
representative polyhedral view of the core can be seen after the
removal of two phosphorus sites, P5 and P8 (Figure 3). The
Figure 4. Molecular structure of 2 in the crystal. Color code: Same as in
1.
surrounded by six cobalt ions and thereby forms four such
hexagons (Figure 5a). Consequently, a new geometry consisting
Figure 5. (a) “Stick” type view of the core after removing all atoms
except Co and P. (b) Core structure of 2, color code: same as 1.
Figure 3. Polyhedral view of the core of complex 1, central spheres
represent P.
of four hexagonal and four trigonal faces is formed where all the
vertices are occupied by metal ions. The average distance of
cobalt ions of the hexagonal faces is 3.20 Å and that of triangular
faces is 3.37 Å. The interconnection of P atoms resulted in a
tetrahedral geometry where four P (P4) occupied its vertices with
an average P−P distance of 5.16 Å. Interestingly, the P4
tetrahedral structure is surrounded by the CoII polygon, and
this feature makes the structure unique. Although the geometry
of the core is slightly distorted, it is not difficult to see the
presence of four C3 axes each at the vertex of P4 Td and running
through the center of each Co3 triangular unit at the opposite end
(Figure 5b). Nine mirror planes are also present along each edge
of the tetrahedron and intersecting two opposite edges of the Co6
hexagonal faces.
For magnetic characterization, dc susceptibility data of 1 and 2
were collected on polycrystalline samples in the range 1.8−300 K
at 0.1 T. The magnetic measurements for 1 and 2 are shown in
the form of a χMT (χMT is the molecular magnetic susceptibility)
versus temperature (T) plot in Figure 6. The room temperature
χMT value for 1 is 36.45 cm3 Kmol−1 and for 2 it is 30.07
cm3Kmol−1. Both values are significantly higher than the
calculated spin only values of 28.12 cm3Kmol−1 (g = 2) and
22.50 cm3Kmol−1 (g = 2) for isolated 15 and 12 CoII centers,
respectively. This can be explained on the basis of the orbital
contribution of CoII, which is known to be significant in an
octahedral field. The χMT value decreases gradually from room
temperature to 13.63 cm3Kmol−1 for 1 at 55 K and then sharply
to 2.05 cm3Kmol−1 at 1.9 K. For 2, the χMT value decreases
gradually from room temperature to 21.99 cm3Kmol−1 at 150 K
and then sharply to 5.07 cm3Kmol−1 at 4.5 K, followed by an
remaining two phosphonate groups cap two of the opposite
triangular faces and observe a 3.111 bridging mode.7 The average
distance of cobalt ions of the hexagonal faces is 3.20 Å and that of
triangular faces is 3.37 Å. The most recognizable feature of this
structure is the presence of paramagnetic pentagonal faces, where
each phosphorus at the center of the pentagonal unit is
connected to five cobalt, as phosphonate adopts a 5.221 bridging
mode.7
These pentagonal units bear resemblance to the idea presented
by Muller et al.8 According to him, the presence of {Mo }
̈
6
pentagons is the prime requirement for the formation of
nanoscale polyoxometalate cages.8c The generation of pentag-
onal metal arrays by phosphonate ligands opens up a new avenue
in the scientific community for exploring giant phosphonate-
based nanoscopic cages. Complex 2 (see Figure 4 for molecular
structure) also has an organic outer sheath and inorganic core
within. The core is made of 12 octahedral CoII centers held
together by four μ3 oxo groups of four phosphonate ligands, four
carboxylates, four carbonates, and two 6-chloro-2-hydroxopyr-
idine coligands. The carbonate ligands came from unreacted
cobalt carbonate used in the preparation of cobalt dimer as
starting material. All the phosphonate ligands adopt a 6.222
bridging mode as per Harris notation (Scheme S1, SI).7 After
removing the organic part except selected carbon atoms, the
inorganic metal−oxo core of the molecule resembles a butterfly
type shape.9
Further removal of all atoms except Co and P sites and
connecting them through imaginary lines reveals some very
interesting geometrical features. Each phosphorus atom is
B
dx.doi.org/10.1021/ic3025183 | Inorg. Chem. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX

Inorganic Chemistry
Communication
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
■
The authors are thankful to Dr. Anita Dutt for helpful scientific
discussion. J.A.S. and A.A. acknowledge CSIR for their JRF
fellowship. S.G. thanks IISER Bhopal for the Ph.D. fellowship.
S.K. thanks DST, Government of India (Project No. SR/FT/CS-
016/2010) and IISER Bhopal for generous financial and
infrastructural support.
REFERENCES
■
(1) (a) Zheng, Y. Z.; Evagelisti, M.; Tuna, F.; Winpenny, R. E. P. J. Am.
Chem. Soc. 2012, 134, 1057−1065. (b) Zheng, Y. Z.; Pineda, E. M.;
Helliwell, M.; Winpenny, R. E. P. Chem.− Eur. J. 2012, 18, 4161−4165.
(c) Thompson, M. E. Chem. Mater. 1994, 6, 1168−1175.
(2) (a) Glaser, T.; Liratzis, I.; Ako, A. M.; Powell, A. K. Coord. Chem.
Rev. 2009, 253, 2296−2305. (b) King, P.; Stamatatos, T. C.; Abboud, K.
A.; Christou, G. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2006, 45, 7379−7383. (c) Zhang,
L.; Clerac, R.; Heijboer, P.; Schmitt, W. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2012, 51,
3007−3011.
Figure 6. Temperature dependence of χMT measured at 0.1 T and
magnetization curves (inset graphs) measured at 3, 5, and 7 K for
complex 1 (top) and 2 (bottom).
(3) (a) Clearfield, A. Metal Phosphonate Chemistry. In Progress in
Inorganic Chemistry; Karlin, K. D., Ed.; John Wiley & Sons: New York,
1998; p 371 and references therein. (b) Clearfield, A.; Wang, Z. Dalton
Trans. 2002, 2937−2947.
increase to 5.16 cm3Kmol−1 at 2.3K before dropping sharply to
4.73 cm3Kmol−1 at 1.8 K. The gradual decline at higher
temperatures may be attributed to the presence of intramolecular
antiferromagnetic interaction in the molecules. Further decrease
of χMT values at lower temperatures for both compounds could
be due to the presence of intercage antiferromagnetic
interactions and/or zero field splitting of the ground state.
Above 55 K (for 1) and 150 K (for 2), the magnetic
susceptibilities follow a Curie−Weiss behavior with C = 28.12
cm3 mol−1 K and C = 22.5 cm3 mol−1 K, respectively. The M vs H
plots for compounds 1 and 2 from 3 to 7 K (inset of Figure 6)
show a steady increase that reaches 21.3 and 17.4 μB, respectively,
at 7 T and 3 K without any saturation. These values are
inconsistent with 15 and 12 uncoupled CoII ions, and it can be
assumed that the CoII ions are strongly antiferromagnetically
coupled in both cases. The unsaturated behavior of the plots can
be explained by assuming strong magnetic anisotropy of the ions
present with high nuclearity resulting in many spin states
populated at low temperature.10 The entropy changes (ΔSm) and
hence the MCE for both compounds were performed according
to the Maxwell equation ΔSm(T)ΔH =∫ [∂M(T,H)/∂T]H dH.
In conclusion, an attempt has been made to explore the
geometry of the core of two serendipitously formed metal-
phosphonate cage compounds. The slight variation of the
coligand ratio in the synthesis resulted in a dramatic change in the
core structure. Therefore, exploring symmetry and regular
geometry of the paramagnetic core is very important in terms
of understanding the magnetic properties of the molecular
systems. Further work along this line is in progress in our group.
(4) (a) Chandrasekhar, V.; Kingsley, S. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2000, 39,
2320−2322. (b) Chandrasekhar, V.; Nagarajan, L.; Clerac, R.; Ghosh,
S.; Verma, S. Inorg. Chem. 2008, 47, 1067−1073. (c) Maheswaran, S.;
Chastanet, G.; Teat, S. J.; Mallah, T.; Sessoli, R.; Wernsdorfe, W.;
Winpenny, R. E. P. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2005, 44, 5044−5048.
(d) Tolis, E. I.; Helliwell, M.; Langley, S.; Raftery, J.; Winpenny, R. E. P.
Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2003, 42, 3804−3808. (e) Walawalker, M. G.;
Roesky, H. W.; Murugavel, R. Acc. Chem. Res. 1999, 32, 117−126.
(f) Konar, S.; Bhuvanesh, N.; Clearfield, A. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2006, 128,
9604−9605. (g) Yao, H. C.; Li, Y. Z.; Song, Y.; Ma, Y. S.; Zheng, L. M.;
Xin, X. Q. Inorg. Chem. 2006, 45, 59−65. (h) Konar, S.; Clearfield, A.
Inorg. Chem. 2008, 47, 3489−3491. (i) Konar, S.; Clearfield, A. Inorg.
Chem. 2008, 47, 5573−5579. (j) Zheng, Y. Z.; Evangelisti, M.;
Winpenny, R. E. P. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2011, 50, 3692−3695.
(k) Chandrashekhar, V.; Dey, A.; Senapati, T.; Sanudo, E. C. Dalton
Trans. 2012, 41, 789−803. (l) Yang, C. I.; Song, Y. T.; Yeh, Y. J.; Liu, Y.
H.; Tseng, T. W.; Lu, K. L. Cryst. Eng. Commun. 2011, 13, 2678−2686.
(m) Speed, S.; Vicente, R.; Aravena, D.; Ruiz, E.; Roubeau, O.; Teat, S.
J.; Fallah, M. S. E. Inorg. Chem. 2012, 51, 6842−6850.
(5) (a) Harvey, R. G.; Desombre, E. R. Top. Phosphorus Chem. 1964, 1,
57−111. (b) Redmore, D. J. Org. Chem. 1976, 41, 2148−2150.
(c) Chaboussant, G.; Basler, R.; Gudel, H. U.; Ochsenbein, S. T.; Parkin,
A.; Parsons, S.; Rajaraman, G.; Sieber, A.; Smith, A. A.; Timco, G. A.;
Winpenny, R. E. P. Dalton Trans. 2004, 2758−2766.
(6) Liu, W.; Thorp, H. H. Inorg. Chem. 1993, 32, 4102−4105.
(7) Coxall, R. A.; Harris, S. G.; Henderson, D. K.; Parsons, S.; Tasker,
P. A.; Winpenny, R. E. P. J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans. 2000, 2349−2356.
(8) (a) Muller, A.; Sarkar, S.; Shah, S. Q. N.; Bogge, H.; Schmidtmann,
̈
̈
Sh.; Sarkar, M.; Kogerler, P.; Hauptfleisch, B.; Trautwein, A.;
̈
Schunemann, V. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl. 1999, 38, 3238−3241.
(b) Muller, A.; Hovemeier, J.; Rohlfing, R. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl.
1992, 31, 1192−1195. (c) Kortz, U.; Muller, A.; Slageren, J.; Schnack, J.;
Dalal, N. S.; Dressel, M. Coord. Chem. Rev. 2009, 253, 2315−2327 and
references therein.
̈
̈
̈
ASSOCIATED CONTENT
■
S
* Supporting Information
(9) (a) Chesman, A. S. R.; Turner, D. R.; Moubaraki, B.; Murray, K. S.;
Deacon, G. B.; Batten, S. R. Dalton Trans. 2012, 41, 3751−3757.
(b) Powell, G. W.; Lancashire, H. N.; Brechin, E. K.; Collison, D.; Heath,
S. L.; Mallah, T.; Wernsdorfer, W. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2004, 43,
5772−5775. (c) Tasiopoulos, A. J.; Vinslava, A.; Wernsdorfer, W.;
Abboud, K. A.; Christou, G. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2004, 43, 2117−
2121. (d) Khanra, S.; Helliwell, M.; Tuna, F.; McInnes, E. J. L.;
Winpenny, R. E. P. Dalton Trans. 2009, 6166−6174.
X-ray crystallographic data in CIF format, synthesis of both
compounds, crystallographic data, BVS calculations, and PXRD
patterns. This material is available free of charge via the Internet
at http://pubs.acs.org.
AUTHOR INFORMATION
■
Corresponding Author
(10) Ma, Y. S.; Song, Y.; Tang, X. Y.; Yuan, R. X. Dalton Trans. 2010,
39, 6262−6265.
*E-mail: skonar@iiserb.ac.in.
Notes
The authors declare no competing financial interest.
C
dx.doi.org/10.1021/ic3025183 | Inorg. Chem. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX