ACS Catalysis
Research Article
results, transmetalation (i.e., aniline binding and deprotonation)
is likely the slowest step in the catalytic cycle.26
Table 3. Selected Calculated Bond Distances in the Oxidative
Addition Complexes (I)
a
A computational study was undertaken to compare
AlisonPhos (4o) with 4g, ligands sharing a common biaryl
backbone but having different phosphacycle substitution.
Previous reports involving C−N coupling have noted that the
formation of the N-bound Pd complex and the energy required
to do so are indicative of catalyst performance.27 With that in
mind, the ΔG values were calculated for each step of the catalytic
cycle: oxidative addition (ΔGox), aniline binding (ΔGbind),
deprotonation (ΔGdepro), and reductive elimination (ΔGred)
(Table 1). 1-Bromo-2-methylbenzene, 1-chloro-2-methylben-
zene, and aniline 6 were chosen as representative substrate
combinations for calculations. Ground state geometries were
optimized using DFT (B3LYP-D3/LANL2DZ/6-31G**), with
thermal corrections calculated at the same level of theory.
Single-point energies were calculated using DFT (B3LYP-D3/
LANL2DZ/6-311++G**/COSMO-SMD(dioxane)) and had
thermal corrections applied.
complex
P−Pd
Pd−X
ipso C−Pd
I-4g-Cl
I-4g-Br
I-4o-Cl
I-4o-Br
2.42
2.43
2.32
2.33
2.38
2.56
2.38
2.56
2.62
2.63
2.67
2.67
a
Distances reported in units of angstroms (Å) taken from optimized
geometries.
The ΔGox values for forming the oxidative addition complexes
I-4g-Br, I-4o-Br and I-4g-Cl, I-4o-Cl are comparable,
respectively. However, a large difference in ΔGbind is observed.
The binding of aniline to I-4g-Br is 11 kcal/mol less favorable
than to I-4o-Br, and binding to I-4g-Cl is 10 kcal/mol less
favorable than to I-4o-Cl.28 The oxidative addition complexes
show endergonic binding to aniline, suggesting relatively low
equilibrium concentrations of the aniline-bound Pd complexes;
the calculated Keq values are ∼10−10 for I-4g-Br and I-4g-Cl and
for calculations). Although both deprotonation and reductive
elimination steps are thermodynamically favored for 4g-bound
Pd complexes, 4o forms a superior catalyst. The higher
effectiveness of 4o is likely due to the calculated ∼107 higher
effective concentration of the aniline-bound Pd complexes II-
4o-Br and II-4o-Cl in comparison to II-4g-Br and II-4g-Cl.
To further understand the difference in ΔGbind, the
coordination of aniline to the oxidative addition complex as a
two-step process was investigated: first, the formation of a three-
coordinate complex from the oxidative addition complex, and
second, the binding of aniline to this coordinatively unsaturated
complex to form the aniline-bound complex (Table 2).
Formation of the three-coordinate complex is less energetically
unfavorable for 4o than for 4g (ΔGdesat). Aniline binding to the
three-coordinate complex is favored for 4o over 4g
(ΔGbind, Ib‑II). Further analysis of the oxidative addition
complexes shows that the P−Pd bond length is shorter in I-
4o-Br and I-4o-Cl than in I-4g-Br and I-4g-Cl (Table 3), and
the interaction between the ipso carbon of the biaryl backbone
and Pd is weaker (evidenced by a slightly longer C−Pd distance
in 4o-bound complexes). Contrary to expectation, this suggests
that 4o is more electron-donating than 4g. The reduced steric
bulk of 4o allows for better coordination of the phosphorus atom
to Pd, which produces an apparent increase in electron donation
over 4g (Table S30).29 These steric and electronic factors
stabilize the three-coordinate complex of 4o, leading to the
lower energetic cost for desaturation in comparison to 4g.
More favorable aniline binding to the 4o-bound three-
coordinate complex over the 4g-bound complex also results
from the decreased steric bulk of 4o. Steric interactions between
the biaryl backbone and phosphorinane substituents of 4g
destabilize both the three-coordinate intermediate (Ib-4g-Br)
and the aniline-bound complex (II-4g-Br). Ib-4g-Br shows
significant hindrance of the Pd atom that is not present in Ib-4o-
Br, which likely inhibits aniline coordination (Figure 7). In
summary, the more favorable ΔGbind value for 4o in comparison
Figure 7. (left) Three-coordinate complex Ib-4o-Br, in a view along the
Pd−(o-tolyl) bond. (right) Three-coordinate complex Ib-4g-Br, in a
view along the Pd−(o-tolyl) bond. Pd atoms are shown in teal. Both the
dimethylamino and methoxy subunits of 4g are in closer proximity to
the aniline coordination site in the ground state geometry.
to that for 4g arises from (1) increased electron donation from
4o to the Pd center and (2) decreased steric hindrance in the
three-coordinate and aniline-bound Pd complexes of 4o.
CONCLUSION
■
In summary, we have developed a general and high-yielding
procedure for the synthesis of biaryl phosphorinanes by the
double phospha-Michael addition of primary biaryl phosphines
to 1,4-dien-3-ones under relatively mild conditions. HFIP was
found to be a uniquely effective solvent for the phospha-Michael
addition. Unlike previous reports where at least 4 equiv of
dienone was required at elevated temperatures (150−160 °C),
only 1.2−2.0 equiv of the dienone at 23−110 °C was sufficient.
Several phosphorinanes (4a,c,d,j), known to be effective for C−
15015
ACS Catal. 2020, 10, 15008−15018