10.1002/anie.201916124
Angewandte Chemie International Edition
COMMUNICATION
which PEG presents a sufficient spacer between albumin and the
glucuronic acid.
Table 1. Toxicity related IC50 data for the glucuronide prodrugs against
triple-negative human MDA-MB-231 breast adenocarcinoma cells in the
absence or presence of β-glururonidase (- Enz / + Enz, respectively).
QIC50 denotes the toxicity ratio between non-activated and enzyme
activated prodrug: QIC50 = IC50 (- Enz) / IC50 (+ Enz). Toxicity of MMAE in
these experiments was 1.1±0.5 nM.
For successful i-EPT, the envisioned mechanism of prodrug
bioconversion relies on the endogenous, rather than the
externally administered enzyme. We verified if the enzymatic
repertoire of the cancer cells is sufficient for prodrug
bioconversion. Cancer xenografts based on triple-negative MDA-
MB-231 breast adenocarcinoma cells were explanted from mice
and incubated in PBS in the presence of resorufin-β-D-
glucuronide (ResoGlcA), a fluorogenic probe employed such that
increase in fluorescence intensity indicates enzymatic
bioconversion of the probe. Explanted xenografts became well
fluorescent when cultured in the presence ResoGlcA, providing
an ex vivo validation of i-EPT (imaging modality) (Figures
S7,10,11). This was also true in the case of xenografts based on
non-invasive human breast adenocarcinoma MCF-7 cells (ER+,
PR+, HER2-, luminal subtype A) [27] and these too afforded reliable
conversion of the fluorogenic glucuronide (Figures S7,10,11).
Thus, in vivo grown cancerous tissue is capable of converting
glucuronide prodrugs, which is the most important pre-requisite
for the success of i-EPT.
Prodrug R=
Alkyne (4)
H (5)
IC50 (- Enz)
IC50 (+ Enz)
QIC50
255
260
9.4
0.6
2.2
5.4
1.5
2.4
3.3
67.4
425
118
1,7
7
77
175
47
PEG3k (7)
PEG20k (8)
DSPE-PEG (9)
Tr-PEG (10)
AlbuTag (11)
10.5
184
579
1746
prodrugs (9-11) are designed such as to benefit from the
beneficial pharmacokinetic characteristics of albumin, including
extended blood residence time and potential increased tumor
accumulation. [18]
HPLC release studies revealed that all synthesized
glucuronide prodrugs exhibit high stability in physiological buffer
(phosphate buffered saline) for at least 24 h at 37ºC, a feature
that is highly important to minimize the non-specific drug release
(Figure 1C and D and supplementary materials for the remaining
prodrugs). All prodrugs released MMAE quantitatively in presence
of β-glucuronidase, revealing that protraction arms R do not
hinder enzymatic prodrug activation.
Cell culture evaluation of the prodrugs was conducted using
highly metastatic triple-negative (oestrogen receptor (ER)-,
progesterone receptor (PR)-, human epidermal growth factor
receptor 2 (HER2) negative; claudin-low subtype) MDA-MB-231
human breast adenocarcinoma cells
responsiveness (Figure S7 and Table 1). For each prodrug,
toxicity was monitored in the presence or absence of the
activating enzyme, allowing 72 h for the toxin to exert its effect.
Under these conditions, over multiple independent runs, pristine
MMAE revealed an IC50 value of 1.1±0.5 nM. In agreement with
their design, the extended scaffold glucuronides were significantly
less toxic than MMAE whereas toxicity was restored via
enzymatic bioconversion and ensuing drug release, with QIC50
values as high as 425. Interestingly, prodrug structure and
specifically the protraction arm R had a profound effect on the IC50
of the prodrugs, their ability to undergo enzymatic bioconversion,
and the resulting QIC50 values. The first observation is that
PEGylated prodrugs (7, 8), surprisingly, were the least effective
in masking toxicity of MMAE and exhibited IC50 values around 10
nM. Corresponding values for all other prodrugs, including the
albumin-affine DSPE-PEG (9) and Tr-PEG (10), were well over
In vivo anticancer effects mediated by the prodrugs were
quantified in the subcutaneous (s.c.) MDA-MB-231 ectopic
xenografts. We employed a once-weekly s.c. administration of the
prodrugs in line with the growing understanding that this route of
administration considerably decreases treatment costs while
providing patient convenience (home vs hospital administration).
[28] Pristine MMAE, in agreement with prior reports on the subject,
[5a]
proved to be highly toxic and exhibited no curative effects
[27]
with limited treatment
(Figure 2 A1,B1). Molecular prodrug (R=H, 5) significantly masked
systemic toxicity of MMAE and was well tolerated, as evidenced
by the survival rate and the body weight of mice, (Figure 2 A1, B1)
but afforded no discernible anticancer effect (Figure 2 C1, D1).
Same holds true for the majority of macromolecular (PEG3k (7))
and supramolecular (DSPE (9), AlbuTag (11)) prodrugs tested in
this work, and while toxicity of treatment was much improved over
MMAE monotherapy, improvement in the therapeutic effect was
not observed (Figure 2C1,2,D1,2). This observation was rather
surprising and indicates that otherwise successful tools of
[23a]
[10b]
nanomedicine, such as DSPE-PEG,
PEG, and AlbuTag
failed to facilitate translocation of the glucuronide prodrugs to the
tumor in sufficient quantities required for a successful i-EPT, at
least with the chosen sparse drug administration schedule.
Worthy of note, the prodrug with a PEG20k (8) protraction arm
exhibited statistically significant suppression of the tumor growth
rate and this prodrug scaffold deserves further optimization.
Our study reveals an unexpected lead formulation that
afforded statistically significant suppression of tumor growth,
namely the Tr-PEG glucuronide prodrug 10 (Figure 3C1,2,D1,2).
The prodrug based on Tr-PEG (10) was highly active in vivo while
its close analogue without an albumin binding group (R = PEG3k
(7)) was not, providing evidence that albumin binding is key to the
observed anticancer effect. However, prodrugs based on DSPE-
PEG (9) and AlbuTag (11), both albumin affine, were ineffective,
100 nM. PEGylation is
a validated method to minimize
translocation of drugs across biological membranes (e.g.
Naloxegol is a PEGylated, peripherally active opioid).[15] Apparent
increase in toxicity for PEGylated glucuronides 7, 8 (compared to
the simplified, parent prodrugs alkyne (4), R=H (5)) is therefore
surprising. From a different perspective, our data demonstrate
that all the prodrugs underwent efficient bioconversion, which
resulted in the restored cytotoxicity of MMAE. However, the
AlbuTag-functionalized glucuronide stands out as the prod rug
with impeded bioconversion, as evidenced by a relatively high
IC50 = 67 nM observed for the prodrug in the presence of β-
glucuronidase. A likely explanation to this is that AlbuTag is a
relatively short spacer, in which case albumin creates a steric
shield and hinders enzymatic activity on the prodrug. This effect
was not observed for DSPE-PEG (9) or Tr-PEG (10) prodrugs for
signifying that albumin affinity as such is not sufficient for success.
[10, 23a]
Our results, and those from others,
suggest that albumin
binders are not the same with regards to the in vivo performance
of the resulting supramolecular adducts, be it for delivery of
vaccines or anticancer drugs. Most importantly, it appears that in
vitro toxicity screens fail to provide predictive knowledge and
nominate a priori leads for in vivo evaluation. Specifically, in our
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.