Boosting Interfacial Charge-Transfer Kinetics for Efficient Overall CO2Photoreduction via Rational Design of Coordination Spheres on Metal-Organic Frameworks

Article abstract of DOI:10.1021/jacs.0c05530

The recombination of electron-hole pairs severely detracts from the efficiency of photocatalysts. This issue could be addressed in metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) through optimization of the charge-transfer kinetics via rational design of structures at atomic level. Herein, a pyrazolyl porphyrinic Ni-MOF (PCN-601), integrating light harvesters, active catalytic sites, and high surface areas, has been demonstrated as a superior and durable photocatalyst for visible-light-driven overall CO2 reduction with H2O vapor at room temperature. Kinetic studies reveal that the robust coordination spheres of pyrazolyl groups and Ni-oxo clusters endow PCN-601 with proper energy band alignment and ultrafast ligand-to-node electron transfer. Consequently, the CO2-to-CH4 production rate of PCN-601 far exceeds those of the analogous MOFs based on carboxylate porphyrin and the classic Pt/CdS photocatalyst by more than 3- and 20-fold, respectively. The reaction avoids the use of hole scavengers and proceeds in a gaseous phase which can take full advantage of the high gas uptake of MOFs. This work demonstrates that the rational design of coordination spheres in MOF structures not only reconciles the contradiction between reactivity and stability but also greatly promotes the interfacial charge transfer to achieve optimized kinetics, providing guidance for the design of highly efficient MOF photocatalysts.

Full text of DOI:10.1021/jacs.0c05530

Subscriber access provided by Uppsala universitetsbibliotek
Article
Boosting Interfacial Charge-Transfer Kinetics for Efficient
2
Overall CO Photoreduction via Rational Design of
Coordination Spheres on Metal-Organic Frameworks
Zhi-Bin Fang, Ting-Ting Liu, Junxue Liu, Shengye Jin, Xin-Ping Wu, Xue-
Qing Gong, Kecheng Wang, Qi Yin, Tian-Fu Liu, Rong Cao, and Hong-Cai Zhou
J. Am. Chem. Soc., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/jacs.0c05530 • Publication Date (Web): 21 Jun 2020
Downloaded from pubs.acs.org on June 21, 2020
Just Accepted
“Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted
online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical
Society provides “Just Accepted” as a service to the research community to expedite the dissemination
of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in
full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully
peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are citable by the
Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore,
the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After
a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web
site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes
to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and
ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or
consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W.,
Washington, DC 20036
Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society.
However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works
produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course
of their duties.

Page 1 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
!!"#$%& '%#()*+,$+- ./+)&(01)+%"*() 2$%(#$," *!) 3**$,$(%#
45()+-- .46 7/!#!)(89,#$!% 5$+ :+#$!%+- ;("$&% !*
.!!)8$%+#$!% <=/()(" !% >(#+-04)&+%$, ?)+@(A!)B"
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
!"#$%#& '(&)*+ ,#&)$,#&) -#.*/ 0.&1.2 -#.*3 4"2&)52 0#&*3 6#&$7#&) 8.*/ 6.2$9#&) :;&)*/ <2="2&)
8(&)* 9# >#&*+ ,#(&$'. -#.+* ?;&) @(;*+* A (&B C;&)$@(# !";.
+4D(D2 <25 -(E;F(D;F5 ;G 4DF.=D.F(H @"2I#JDF5* '.K#(& L&JD#D.D2 ;G ?2J2(F=" ;& D"2 4DF.=D.F2 ;G M(DD2F* @"#&2J2 A=(B2I5 ;G
4=#2&=2J* '.N";. OPQQQR* 7S ?S @"#&(
/ <25 -(E;F(D;F5 G;F ABT(&=2B M(D2F#(HJ* @2&DF2 G;F @;IU.D(D#;&(H @"2I#JDF5* ?2J2(F=" L&JD#D.D2 ;G L&B.JDF#(H @(D(H5J#J*
V(JD @"#&( W&#T2FJ#D5 ;G 4=#2&=2 (&B ,2="&;H;)5* 4"(&)"(# RQQROX* 7S ?S @"#&(
34D(D2 <25 -(E;F(D;F5 ;G M;H2=.H(F ?2(=D#;& Y5&(I#=J (&B @;HH(E;F(D#T2 L&&;T(D#;& @2&D2F ;G @"2I#JDF5 G;F V&2F)5
M(D2F#(HJ* Y(H#(& L&JD#D.D2 ;G @"2I#=(H 7"5J#=J* @"#&2J2 A=(B2I5 ;G 4=#2&=2J* Y(H#(& ZQRO* 7S ?S @"#&(
Y2U(FDI2&D ;G @"2I#JDF5* ,21(J A[M W&#T2FJ#D5* @;HH2)2 4D(D#;&* ,21(J* XX\]R$OQ R* W4A
W&#T2FJ#D5 ;G @"#&2J2 A=(B2I5 ;G 4=#2&=2J* %2#K#&)* QQQ]^* 7S ?S @"#&(
!"#$%&'( )*+,+-.,./01213 $456.// 7$8 %59:-,2+;3 <5,./=$6>.;2- ?6.@5A+6B13 7++692;.,2+; 'C*56513 7*.6>5 2;5,2-1
A !"#A$"% ,"2 F2=;IE#&(D#;& ;G 2H2=DF;&$";H2 U(#FJ J2T2F2H5 B2DF(=DJ D"2 2GG#=#2&=5 ;G U";D;=(D(H5JDJS ,"#J #JJ.2 =;.HB E2
(BBF2JJ2B #& I2D(H$;F)(&#= GF(I2_;F`J aMb'Jc D"F;.)" ;UD#I#N(D#;& ;G D"2 ="(F)2$DF(&JG2F `#&2D#=J =(& E2 ;UD#I#N2B T#( F(D#;&(H
B2J#)& ;G JDF.=D.F2J (D (D;I#= H2T2HS C2F2#&* ( U5F(N;H5H U;FU"5F#&#= d#$Mb' a7@d$ZQ c* #&D2)F(D#&) H#)"D "(FT2JD2FJ* (=D#T2
=(D(H5D#= J#D2J* (&B "#)" J.FG(=2 (F2(J (HH #& ;&2* "(J E22& B2I;&JDF(D2B (J ( J.U2F#;F (&B B.F(EH2 U";D;=(D(H5JD G;F T#J#EH2$H#)"D$
BF#T2& ;T2F(HH @bR F2B.=D#;& _#D" CRb T(U;F (D F;;I D2IU2F(D.F2S <#&2D#= JD.B#2J F2T2(H D"(D D"2 F;E.JD =;;FB#&(D#;& JU"2F2J ;G
U5F(N;H5H )F;.UJ (&B d#$;1; =H.JD2FJ 2&B;_ 7@d$ZQ _#D" UF;U2F 2&2F)5 E(&B (H#)&I2&D (&B .HDF(G(JD H#)(&B$D;$&;B2 2H2=DF;&
DF(&JG2FS @;&J2e.2&DH5* D"2 @bR$D;$@C] UF;B.=D#;& F(D2 ;G 7@d$ZQ G(F 21=22BJ D";J2 ;G D"2 (&(H;);.J Mb'J E(J2B ;& =(FE;15H(D2
U;FU"5F#& (&B D"2 =H(JJ#= 7Df@B4 U";D;=(D(H5JD E5 I;F2 D"(& O (&B RQ D#I2J F2JU2=D#T2H5S @;&JU#=.;.JH5* D"2 F2(=D#;& (T;#BJ D"2
.J2 ;G ";H2 J=(T2&)2FJ* (&B UF;=22BJ #& ( )(J2;.J U"(J2 _"#=" =(& D(`2 G.HH (BT(&D()2 ;G D"2 "#)" )(J .UD(`2 ;G Mb'JS ,"#J _;F`
B2I;&JDF(D2J D"(D D"2 F(D#;&(H B2J#)& ;G =;;FB#&(D#;& JU"2F2J #& Mb' JDF.=D.F2J &;D ;&H5 F2=;&=#H2J D"2 =;&DF(B#=D#;& E2D_22&
F2(=D#T#D5 (&B JD(E#H#D5 E.D (HJ; )F2(DH5 UF;I;D2J D"2 #&D2FG(=#(H ="(F)2 DF(&JG2F D; (="#2T2 ;UD#I#N2B `#&2D#=J* UF;T#B#&) ).#B(&=2
G;F D"2 B2J#)& ;G "#)"H5 2GG#=#2&D Mb' U";D;=(D(H5JDJS
M2D(H$;F)(&#= GF(I2_;F`J aMb'Jc* ( =H(JJ ;G U;F;.J
'C1:4;D.1'4C
=F5JD(HH#&2 I(D2F#(HJ B2I;&JDF(D#&) )F2(D U;D2&D#(HJ #&
Q
T(F#;.J (UUH#=(D#;&J #& )(J JD;F()2*^ J2&J#&)* =(D(H5J#J*
bT2F(HH U";D;=(D(H5D#= @bR F2B.=D#;&* I#I#=`#&) D"2 &(D.F(H
U";D;J5&D"2J#J #& UH(&DJ* =(& =(UD.F2 (&B DF(&JG;FI
)F22&";.J2 @bR _#D" CRb #&D; T(H.2$(BB2B UF;B.=DJ* _"#="
"(J (DDF(=D2B DF2I2&B;.J F2J2(F=" #&D2F2JDJ #& D"2 U(JD
(&B J; ;&* (F2 (BT(&D()2;.J #& F2)(FB D; D"2 =(U(E#H#D5 ;G
UF2=#J2H5 B2J#)&#&) (&B D(#H;F#&) JDF.=D.F2J (D (D;I#= H2T2H
R$ P
G;F G.&=D#;&(H I;D#GJS
,"2J2 G2(D.F2J 2&B;_ Mb'J _#D"
$O
J2T2F(H 52(FJS %2J#B2J E2#&) D"2FI;B5&(I#= (HH;_2B G;F
D"2 .&#e.2 ;UU;FD.&#D5 D; ;FB2FH5 #&D2)F(D2 H#)"D "(FT2JD2FJ*
=(D(H5D#= J#D2J* (&B "#)" J.FG(=2 (F2(J (HH #& ;&2 (&B
J#I.HD(&2;.JH5 ;UD#I#N2 E;D" D"2 D"2FI;B5&(I#=J (&B
`#&2D#=J G;F 2GG#=#2&D )(J2;.J @bR =(UD.F2 (&B F2(=D#;&S 8#D"
D"#J &;D#;& #& I#&B* J2T2F(H Mb' =(D(H5JDJ E(J2B ;& U";D;$
E;D" @bR (&B CRb "(HG$F2(=D#;&J* (& 2GG#=#2&D U";D;=(D(H5JD
G;F ;T2F(HH @bR U";D;F2B.=D#;& "(J D; E2 J.U2F#;F #& I(&5
`#&2D#= (JU2=DJ* J.=" (J F2(=D(&DJ (BJ;FUD#;& (&B (=D#T(D#;&*
="(F)2 J2U(F(D#;& (&B DF(&JG2F* (J _2HH (J D"2 J.EJ2e.2&D
="(F)2 .D#H#N(D#;&S AUU(F2&DH5* =;&DF;HH#&) D"2J2 =;IUH#=(D2B
`#&2D#= UF;U2FD#2J #J ="(HH2&)#&)S ';F DF(B#D#;&(H
J2I#=;&B.=D;F$E(J2B U";D;=(D(H5JDJ* J;I2 JDF(D2)#2J "(T2
E22& 21UH;F2B D; ;UD#I#N2 D"2J2 `#&2D#= E2"(T#;FJ* 2S)S*
"2D2F;$=;IU;&2&D #&=;FU;F(D#;&*] G(=2D (&B B2G2=D
2&)#&22F#&)*P$Z (&B I;FU";H;)5 F2).H(D#;&SX$\ C;_2T2F*
D"2J2 JDF(D2)#2J (F2 .J.(HH5 F2JDF#=D2B E5 D2B#;.J J5&D"2D#=
UF;=2B.F2J (&B H;JJ ;G (D;I#=$J=(H2 =;&DF;H* "(IU2F#&) D"2
#IUF;T2I2&DJ ;& D"2 U";D;=(D(H5D#= U2FG;FI(&=2S
F2JU;&J#T2 ;F)(&#= H#)(&BJ "(T2 E22& G(EF#=(D2B (&B (UUH#2B
Z$R
G;F @bR U";D;F2B.=D#;& F2=2&DH5S
L& D"2J2 Mb'
=(D(H5JDJ* "#)" T(H2&D I2D(H #;&J a2S)S !F]g* AHOgc (&B
=(FE;15H )F;.UJ (F2 .J.(HH5 2IUH;52B D; (="#2T2 "#)"
JD(E#H#D5* _"#="* ";_2T2F* #&B.=2 "#)" 2&2F)5 E(FF#2FJ G;F
F2(=D(&DJ (=D#T(D#;& ;& I2D(H &;B2JRR* I(`#&) D"2 H#)(&B$D;$
&;B2 ="(F)2 DF(&JG2F 2&2F)2D#=(HH5 .&G(T;F2BSRO$RZ
@;&T2FJ2H5* Mb'J _#D" =;;FB#&(D#;& JU"2F2J =;&J#JD2B ;G
F2(=D#T2 I2D(H JU2=#2J a2S)S d#aLLc*RX @;aLLcR\ (&B @.aLLcR^c
(&B =(FE;15H )F;.UJ (F2 J2T2F2H5 J.GG2F#&) GF;I D"2
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 2 of 11
="(HH2&)#&) 2#)"D$2H2=DF;& "(HG$F2(=D#;& a@bR g \Cg g \2$ !
JDF.=D.F(H H(E#H#D5 2T2& #& (IE#2&D (DI;JU"2F2SOQ LD #J =H2(F
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
D"(D D"2 U";D;=(D(H5D#= U2FG;FI(&=2J ;G Mb'J (F2 .J.(HH5
H#I#D2B E5 D"2 =;&DF(B#=D#;& E2D_22& JD(E#H#D5 (&B F2(=D#T#D5S
A&;D"2F ="(HH2&)2 G;F ;T2F(HH @bR U";D;F2B.=D#;& #J D"2
`#&2D#=(HH5 JH.))#J" &(D.F2 ;G D"2 I.HD#$2H2=DF;&$#&T;HT2B
@bR F2B.=D#;& "(HG$F2(=D#;&S ,; .&#H(D2F(HH5 (DD(#&
=;&J#B2F(EH2 (=D#T#D#2J G;F @bR F2B.=D#;&* ";H2 J=(T2&)2FJ ;F
2H2=DF;& B;&;FJ (F2 =;II;&H5 .J2B D; F(U#BH5 =;&J.I2
U";D;$)2&2F(D2B ";H2J #& J#D. (&B J.UUH5 (E.&B(&D GF22
2H2=DF;&JS d2T2FD"2H2JJ* D"2J2 ;U2F(D#;&J (F2 .&2=;&;I#=(H
(&B _#HH =;&G#&2 D"2 F2(=D#;&J D; H#e.#B U"(J2 F(D"2F D"(&
)(J2;.J @bR (DI;JU"2F2* (&B "2&=2 D"2 "#)" )(J .UD(`2J ;G
Mb'J (F2 ;G &; (T(#HS ,;_(FBJ (& ;T2F(HH @bR
U";D;F2B.=D#;& #& D"2 )(J U"(J2* ( E;;JD2B =(D(H5D#=
U2FG;FI(&=2 =(& E2 (&D#=#U(D2B #G ;&2 =(& ())F2)(D2 "#)"H5
(=D#T2 =(D(H5D#= JU2=#2J G;F E;D" "(HG$F2(=D#;&J #& F;E.JD
=;;FB#&(D#;& JU"2F2J (&B D"(D U2FI#D ( G(=#H2 H#)(&B$D;$&;B2
="(F)2 DF(&JG2F #& D"2 JDF.=D.F2S
@C] g RCRbcS ,"2 ;1#B(D#;& UF;B.=D ;G CRbR _(J (HJ;
B2D2=D2B aRCRb g R"g !RCg g CRbRcS ,; D"2 E2JD ;G ;.F
`&;_H2B)2* D"#J _;F` #J D"2 G#FJD F2U;FD ;& J;H2$Mb'$
212=.D#&) ;T2F(HH @bR U";D;$F2B.=D#;& #& )(J$J;H#B
=;&B#D#;&S d;D(EH5* D"2 @C] UF;B.=D#;& F(D2 ;G 7@d$ZQ G(F
21=22BJ D";J2 ;G (&(H;);.J U;FU"5F#&#= Mb'J (&B D"2 _2HH$
`&;_& 7Df@B4 J5JD2I E5 (D H2(JD O (&B RQ D#I2J*
F2JU2=D#T2H5S ,"2 @bR$D;$@C] =;&T2FJ#;&J .&B2F T#J#EH2
H#)"D a QS iI;Hj"$ j)$ c (&B J#I.H(D2B J;H(F #FF(B#(D#;&
aA9> k RS \lc (F2 (I;&) D"2 JD(D2$;G$D"2$(FD =(J2J G;F
F;;I$D2IU2F(D.F2 @bR U";D;F2B.=D#;& GF22 GF;I ";H2
J=(T2&)2FJS
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
:3<DE1 AC; ;'<.D<<'4C
!&'()*+,+ -'. /)-0-/(*0,1-(,2'+ 23 4$56789: 7@d$ZQ
a'#).F2 (c _(J J5&D"2J#N2B (==;FB#&) D; D"2 H#D2F(D.F2OR (&B
D"2 U"(J2 U.F#D5 _(J T2F#G#2B E5 76?Y U(DD2F&J a'#).F2 EcS
,"2 I#=F;U;F;J#D5 ;G D"2 J(IUH2 _(J =;&G#FI2B E5 dR
J;FUD#;& #J;D"2FI a'#).F2 =c _#D" ( %V, J.FG(=2 (F2( ;G
^ \SX =IOf) _"#=" #J T2F5 =H;J2 D; D"2 D"2;F2D#=(H T(H.2 a^Z^
IRf)c =(H=.H(D2B E5 D"2 D5+EE J;GD_(F2OOS ,"2 .UD.F& #& D"2
"#)"$UF2JJ.F2 F2)#;& =(& E2 (J=F#E2B D; D"2 (U2FD.F2 #&B.=2B
E5 D"2 ())H;I2F(D#;& ;G &(&;U(FD#=H2J aPQ m QQ &I (J
C2F2#&* _2 "(T2 F2(H#N2B D"#J "5U;D"2J#J E5 2IUH;5#&) (
Mb' aB2&;D2B (J 7@d$ZQ c* =;IU;J2B ;G F2(=D#T2 d#$;1;
=H.JD2F &;B2J (&B H#)"D$"(FT2JD#&) I2D(HH;U;FU"5F#& H#)(&BJ
=;&&2=D2B T#( U5F(N;H5H )F;.U* (J ( =(D(H5JD G;F )(J$U"(J2
;T2F(HH @bR U";D;F2B.=D#;& _#D" CRb T(U;F (D F;;I
D2IU2F(D.F2S L& =;&DF(JD D; D"2 =(FE;15H(D2 ="2H(D#&) )F;.UJ
#& D"2 =;&T2&D#;&(H Mb' U";D;=(D(H5JDJ* D"2 U5F(N;H5H
)F;.UJ #& ;.F =(J2 U;JJ2JJ ( H(F)2F h$=;&K.)(D#;& J5JD2I*
(&B =(.J2 "#)"2F h$B ;FE#D(H ;T2FH(UJ _#D" d#$;1; &;B2JSO
,"#J (HD2F(D#;& (HH;_J .J D; #&D2)F(D2 =(D(H5D#= (=D#T2 JU2=#2J
#&D; ( F;E.JD GF(I2_;F`* (&B =;&J2e.2&DH5 F2=;&=#H2 D"2
=;&GH#=D E2D_22& JD(E#H#D5 (&B F2(=D#T#D5 G;F Mb'$E(J2B
U";D;=(D(H5JDJS M;JD #IU;FD(&DH5* J.=" ( =;;FB#&(D#;&
JU"2F2 BF(I(D#=(HH5 (==2H2F(D2J D"2 H#)(&B$D;$&;B2 2H2=DF;&
DF(&JG2F (&B 2GG2=D#T2H5 J.UUF2JJ2J D"2 ="(F)2
F2=;IE#&(D#;&* ;GG2F#&) J.GG#=#2&D 2H2=DF;&J G;F D"2 F2B.=D#;&
UF;=2JJ (D D"2 F2(=D#T2 d#$;1; &;B2JS ,"2J2 G2(D.F2J UF;I#J2
7@d$ZQ D; E2 (& 2GG#=#2&D (&B B.F(EH2 U";D;=(D(H5JD G;F D"2
;T2F(HH @bR F2B.=D#;&S ,"2 UF2B;I#&(&D F2B.=D#;& UF;B.=D
_(J B2D2FI#&2B D; E2 @C]* (==;IUH#J"#&) D"2 `#&2D#=(HH5$
F2T2(H2B #& 4VM #I()2* '#).F2 BcS ,"2 C$dM? JU2=DF( ;G
U;FU"5F#& H#)(&B aC],77c (&B (=#B$B#)2JD2B Mb'J _2F2
=;IU(F2B D; =;&G#FI D"2 I2D(HH#N(D#;& ;G d#Rg #& D"2
U;FU"5F#& =2&D2FS AJ J";_& #& '#).F2 2* D"2 U2(`J (D n k $
RSXR UUI aRC (D U;FU"5F#& =;F2c (&B n k OSZO UUI a]C (D
G;.F U5F(N;H2 EF(&="2Jc UF2J2&D2B #& C],77 _2F2 (EJ2&D #&
D"2 B#)2JD2B 7@d$ZQ * #&B#=(D#&) D"2 B2UF;D;&(D#;& ;G
U;FU"5F#& =2&D2FJ (&B U5F(N;H2 )F;.UJ F2JU2=D#T2H5S ,".J*
D"2 D(F)2D 7@d$ZQ _#D" d# I2D(HH;U;FU"5F#& =2&D2FJ (&B
U5F(N;H2$d#b1 =;;FB#&(D#;& JU"2F2J "(J E22& J.==2JJG.HH5
=;&JDF.=D2BS
")*0;2.&'-;,/ 3*-+,<,=,(& 320 $>? 0*.@/(,2' -'.
A?> 2B,.-(,2': 7@d$ZQ B#JUH(5J ( _#B2$F(&)2 T#J#EH2$
H#)"D (EJ;FE(&=2
-
<
.
/
*
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
R

Page 3 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 4 of 11
=;;FB#&(D#;& JU"2F2JS L& 7@d$RRR* D"2 "#)" T(H2&D !F$;1; &;B2J #&D; D"2 GF(I2_;F`* #D I(`2J ( J2T2F2 =;IUF;I#J2 ;&
1
2
3
4
I2D(H &;B2J* U2FI#DD#&) D"2 GF(I2_;F` F;E.JD&2JJ D";.)"
aE(J2B ;& D"2 C(FB (&B 4;GD A=#B (&B %(J2 D"2;F5c* B;2J &;D
G(=#H#D(D2 D"2 =(D(H5D#= F2(=D#;& E2=(.J2 ;G #DJ "#)" 2&2F)5
E(FF#2FS AHD";.)" d#O,@77 #&D2)F(D2J (=D#T2 d#$;1; I2D(H
="2I#=(H JD(E#H#D5S Y#GG2F2&D GF;I D"2 =(FE;15H(D2 )F;.UJ #&
D"2 (E;T2 D_; Mb'J* D"2 U5F(N;H5H )F;.UJ #& 7@d$ZQ
U;JJ2JJ ( H(F)2F h$=;&K.)(D#;& J5JD2I (&B H2(B D; ( "#)"2F
B2)F22 ;G h$B ;FE#D(H ;T2FH(UJ _#D" d#RgS
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
C,D@0* N: 7";D;=(D(H5D#= U2FG;FI(&=2J ;G 7@d$ZQ G;F @bR F2B.=D#;&o E-F ,#I2$F2J;HT2B @b aH2GDc (&B @C] aF#)"Dc UF;B.=D#;&Jp E<F M(JJ
JU2=DF.I ;G UF;B.=2B O@C] T#( #J;D;U2 O@bR F2B.=D#;& .&B2F T#J#EH2 H#)"D a#&J2Do JD(&B(FB I(JJ JU2=DF.I ;G @C] #& B(D( H#EF(F5cp E/F
@"F;I;)2&#= B2D2=D#;& ;G CRbR (GD2F Q ";.FJu U";D;=(D(H5J#J E5 D"2 Y7Y ad* d$B#2D"5H$ *]$U"2&5H2&2B#(I#&2cf7bY a";FJ2F(B#J"
U2F;1#B(J2c I2D";Bp E.F :(J 5#2HBJ ;G P F2(=D#;& =5=H2J aPQ ";.FJ #& D;D(Hc (&B =;FF2JU;&B#&) UF;B.=D J2H2=D#T#D5p E*F @;IU(F#J;& ;G @b
aH2GDc (&B @C] aF#)"Dc UF;B.=D#;& F(D2 ;G 7@d$ZQ (&B ;D"2F F2U;FD2B U";D;=(D(H5JDJp E3F @;IU(F#J;& ;G D"2 I;H2J ;G U";D;$)2&2F(D2B
2H2=DF;&J .D#H#N2B #& @bR F2B.=D#;&S
,"2J2 G2(D.F2J _;.HB =(.J2 JDF;&)2F =;;FB#&(D#;& E;&BJ (&B
G(JD2F H#)(&B$D;$I2D(H #&D2FG(=#(H ="(F)2 DF(&JG2FS AJ ( F2J.HD*
7@d$ZQ )(T2 "#)"2F @b (&B @C] UF;B.=D#;& F(D2J D"(& D"2
;D"2F D_; Mb'J a'#).F2 O2cS d;D(EH5* D"2 @C] UF;B.=D#;&
F(D2* QS iI;Hj"$ j)$ a S O i-j"$ U2F PI)c #J (HI;JD O D#I2J
(&B X D#I2J "#)"2F D"(& D";J2 ;G 7@d$RRR (&B d#O,@77*
F2JU2=D#T2H5S ,; U.D D"2 UF2J2&D _;F` #&D; ( EF;(B2F =;&D21D*
_2 (HJ; 2T(H.(D2B D"2 (=D#T#D5 ;G 7@d$ZQ .&B2F J#I.H(D2B
J;H(F #FF(B#(D#;& aAM SP:c* _"#=" )(T2 F#J2 D; ( "#)"2F
@C] UF;B.=D#;& F(D2 ;G ^RSQ iI;Hj"$ j)$ a QSO i-j"$ U2F
PI)* '#).F2 4 ZcS ,"2 (UU(F2&D e.(&D.I 5#2HB aA9>c G;F
@C] UF;B.=D#;& .&B2F D"#J =;&B#D#;& _(J =(H=.H(D2B D; E2
RS \lS ,; D"2 E2JD ;G ;.F `&;_H2B)2* D"2 @bR$D;$@C]
=;&T2FJ#;& E5 7@d$ZQ F2U;FD2B "2F2 #J (I;&) D"2 D;U
F2=;FBJ #&=H.B#&) (HH$#&;F)(&#= U";D;=(D(H5JD J5JD2IJ
_#D";.D ";H2 J=(T2&)2FJ .&B2F 2#D"2F T#J#EH2 H#)"D ;F
J#I.H(D2B J;H(F H#)"D (D F;;I D2IU2F(D.F2 a,(EH2 4]cS ,"2
=;IU(F#J;& ;G D"2 I;H2J ;G 2GG2=D#T2 2H2=DF;&J #& D"2
F2(=D#;& =(D(H5N2B E57@d$ZQ * 7@d$RRR (&B d#O,@77 (J
_2HH (J l7Df@B4 F2T2(HJ D"(D 7@d$ZQ .D#H#N2B G(F I;F2
U";D;$)2&2F(D2B 2H2=DF;&J _"#=" I;JDH5 =;&DF#E.D2B D; D"2
@C] UF;B.=D#;& a'#).F2 OBcS AGD2F B2JDF;5#&) D"2 U5F(N;H2$
d#b1 =;&&2=D#;& E5 (=#B DF2(DI2&D* D"2 @C] UF;B.=D#;& F(D2
;G 7@d$ZQ J"(FUH5 BF;UJ GF;I QS iI;Hj"$ j)$ D; SP
iI;Hj"$ j)$ _"#H2 D"2 @b UF;B.=D#;& F2I(#&J (D D"2 J(I2
H2T2H a'#).F2 4 XcS ,"#J G.FD"2F #&B#=(D2 D"2 T#D(H F;H2 ;G
U5F(N;H2$d#b1 =;;FB#&(D#;& JU"2F2 G;F @bR U";D;F2B.=D#;&*
2JU2=#(HH5 D"2 @C] 2T;H.D#;&S
OBR=20-(,2' 23 /)-0D* (0-'+3*0 R-()T-&+ -'.
)-0Q*+(,'D +,(*+: ,; )(#& ( B22U2F #&J#)"D #&D; D"2 ="(F)2
DF(&JG2F E2"(T#;FJ #& 7@d$ZQ * D"2 DF(&JG2F U(D"_(5J (&B
"(FT2JD#&) J#D2J ;G U";D;$)2&2F(D2B 2H2=DF;&J (&B ";H2J _2F2
#&T2JD#)(D2BS VH2=DF;& U(F(I()&2D#= F2J;&(&=2 aV7?c
JU2=DF( ;G D"2 I#1D.F2 ;G 7@d$ZQ J.JU2&B2B #&
,VbAf(=2D;&#DF#H2 J;H.D#;& a,VbA (=D2B (J ";H2 J=(T2&)2Fc
_2F2 =;HH2=D2B _#D" (&B _#D";.D H#)"D #FF(B#(D#;&S AJ J";_&
#& '#).F2 4 \* #& =;&DF(JD D; D"2 T2F5 _2(` J#)&(HJ B2D2=D2B
#& B(F` =;&B#D#;&* T#J#EH2$H#)"D #FF(B#(D#;& #&B.=2B I.="
2&"(&=2B d#aLc J#)&(HJ (D )"k RSQP (&B )#k RS ]Z$]\S ,"2
;F#)#& ;G D"2 d#aLc J#)&(H =(&&;D E2 #B2&D#G#2B E5 D"2 V7?
F2J.HD (H;&2* (J d# (D;IJ 21#JD #& E;D" D"2 H#)(&B (&B D"2
I2D(H &;B2 #& 7@d$ZQ S :#T2& D"#J F2(J;&* D"2;F2D#=(H
=(H=.H(D#;&J _2F2 U2FG;FI2B D; (=e.#F2 I;F2 #&G;FI(D#;&S L&
D"2 .&#D =2HH ;G 7@d$ZQ * D"2 vd#\abCc]aCRbcRw aB2&;D2B (J
vd#\w &;B2Jc =;;FB#&(D2J _#D" D_2HT2 U;FU"5F#& H#)(&BJ T#(
U5F(N;H2 )F;.UJ #& D"F22 B#F2=D#;&J aB2&;D2B (J - * -R (&B
-O* F2JU2=D#T2H5* '#).F2 ](cS ,"2 =(H=.H(D2B U(FD#(H B2&J#D5
;G JD(D2J a7Yb4c F2T2(H D"(D D"2 H;=(D#;& ;G D"2 H;_2JD
.&;==.U#2B I;H2=.H(F ;FE#D(H a-WMbc ;G vd#\w &;B2 #J
&2(FH5 #B2&D#=(H D; D"(D ;G U;FU"5F#& H#)(&B a=;&DF#E.D2B E5
-Oc* _"#H2 D"2 "#)"2JD ;==.U#2B I;H2=.H(F ;FE#D(H aCbMbc
;G U;FU"5F#& H#)(&B a=;&DF#E.D2B E5 - (&B -Rc #J
J#)&#G#=(&DH5 "#)"2F D"(& D"(D ;G vd#\w &;B2 a'#).F2 ]E (&B
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
]

Page 5 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
m]RQ &I B.2 D; D"2 JD(D2$G#HH#&) 2GG2=D =(.J2B E5 U";D;$
)2&2F(D2B 2H2=DF;&J (&B ";H2J a'#).F2 Z* 4R]cS %5 UF;E#&)
D"2 (EJ;FUD#;& #&D2&J#D5 (D r k ] \ &I* D"2 `#&2D#= =.FT2J ;G
:4% F2=;T2F5 _2F2 (=e.#F2BS L& UF#&=#UH2* D"2 :4%
F2=;T2F5 =;FF2JU;&BJ D; D"2 B2=F2(J2 ;G 21=#D2B JD(D2J*
_"#=" =(& E2 #&B.=2B E5 2#D"2F ="(F)2 F2=;IE#&(D#;& ;F
="(F)2 J2U(F(D#;& (&B DF(&JG2FS ';F D"2 J;H2 C],77ad#c
_#D";.D H#)(&B$D;$&;B2 ="(F)2
Page 6 of 11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
C,D@0* H: E-F @"(F)2 I;E#H#D#2J ;G 7@d$ZQ (&B 7@d$RRR
F2T2(H2B E5 )(J$J2&J#&) =.FF2&DJ I2(J.F2B #& AF GH;_p E<F
4;H#B$JD(D2 7- JU2=DF( ;G 7@d$ZQ (&B 7@d$RRR 21=#D2B (D r k
]RR &IS
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
C,D@0* 7: ,A JU2=DF( ;G J(IUH2J B#JU2FJ2B #& YM'o E-F C],77ad#c* E<F 7@d$ZQ p E/F @;FF2JU;&B#&) &;FI(H#N2B ,A `#&2D#= =.FT2J UF;E2B
(D ] \ &Ip E.F d;FI(H#N2B ,A `#&2D#= =.FT2J ;G 7@d$ZQ * 7@d$RRR* (&B d#O,@77 aUF;E2 (D r k ] \ &Icp E*F @F5JD(H JDF.=D.F2J (&B
=;;FB#&(D#;& JU"2F2J ;G 7@d$ZQ aD;Uc* 7@d$RRR aI#BBH2c* (&B d#O,@77 aE;DD;IcS
DF(&JG2F* D"2 ;EJ2FT2B :4% F2=;T2F5 J";.HB I(#&H5 (F#J2
GF;I D"2 ="(F)2 F2=;IE#&(D#;&S '#).F2 Z($= J";_J D"(D
7@d$ZQ _#D" D"2 H#)(&B$D;$&;B2 2H2=DF;& DF(&JG2F U(D"_(5
21"#E#DJ J#I#H(F ,A JU2=DF(H G2(D.F2J D; D"(D ;G D"2 H#)(&B E.D
( I.=" G(JD2F :4% F2=;T2F5S ,; T2F#G5 _"2D"2F 2H2=DF;&
DF(&JG2F ;F ="(F)2 F2=;IE#&(D#;& UH(5 D"2 `25 F;H2 D; D"2
G(JD2F :4% F2=;T2F5 #& 7@d$ZQ * _2 21(I#&2B D"2 ,A
`#&2D#=J ;G C],77ad#c H#)(&B _#D" D"2 (BB#D#;& ;G vZ*Zw$
U"2&5H$@Z $E.D5F#= (=#B I2D"5H 2JD2F a7@%M* ( _2HH$`&;_&
2H2=DF;& (==2UD;F I;H2=.H2c G;F =;IU(F#J;&S LD D.F&J ;.D D"(D
D"2 (BB#D#;& ;G 7@%M #&B.=2B ( G(JD2F :4% F2=;T2F5 D"(&
D"2 J;H2 C],77ad#c J5JD2I a'#).F2 Z=* 4R](cS ,"2F2G;F2* _2
=(& (DDF#E.D2 D"2 (==2H2F(D2B :4% F2=;T2F5 #& 7@d$ZQ D;
D"2 2GG#=#2&D H#)(&B$D;$&;B2 2H2=DF;& DF(&JG2FSP] ,; =;IU(F2
D"2 2H2=DF;& DF(&JG2F F(D2J #& 7@d$ZQ * 7@d$RRR (&B
d#O,@77* D"2 (T2F()2 :4% F2=;T2F5 D#I2J _2F2 =(H=.H(D2B
E5 G#DD#&) D"2 `#&2D#= =.FT2J _#D" 21U;&2&D#(H B2=(5
G.&=D#;&J*PP _"#=" _2F2 XR UJ G;F 7@d$ZQ * R P UJ G;F
7@d$RRR* (&B R\Z UJ G;F d#O,@77* F2JU2=D#T2H5 a'#).F2
ZB* ,(EH2 4XcS ,"2 G(JD2JD :4% F2=;T2F5 ;G 7@d$ZQ
B2I;&JDF(D2J D"2 I;JD 2GG#=#2&D H#)(&B$D;$&;B2 2H2=DF;&
DF(&JG2F (I;&) D"2J2 D"F22 Mb'J*PZ =;&G#FI#&) D"2
J.U2F#;F#D5 ;G U5F(N;H2$d#b1 =;;FB#&(D#;& JU"2F2 D"(&
=(FE;15H$!Fb1 (&B =(FE;15H$d#b1 =;&G#).F(D#;&J a'#).F2
Z2cS
")* -33,',(,*+ -'. -/(,Q-(,2'+ 320 0*-/(-'(+: ,"2
(GG#&#D#2J E2D_22& F2(=D(&DJ (&B =(D(H5JDJ* (& #IU;FD(&D
(JU2=D #& `#&2D#=J 2JU2=#(HH5 G;F ( "2D2F;)2&;.J )(J$J;H#B
F2(=D#;&* _2F2 2T(H.(D2B #& 7@d$ZQ S AJ B#JUH(52B #&
'#).F2 X(* =;IU(F2B _#D" I(&5 G(I;.J J;H2$Mb'
U";D;=(D(H5JDJ a,(EH2 4Zc* 7@d$ZQ 21"#E#DJ
( "#)"
(EJ;FUD#;& =(U(=#D5 a\RS] =IOf) (D RXO<* (DIc (&B (
I;B2F(D2 (BJ;FUD#;& 2&D"(HU5 aR SX `0fI;Hc G;F @bR*
B2I;&JDF(D#&) D"2 B2J#F2B @bR (GG#&#D5 G;F U";D;=(D(H5J#JS
AJ B2J=F#E2B (E;T2* #& dR (DI;JU"2F2* V7? JU2=DF( ;G 7@d$
ZQ J";_2B ="(F(=D2F#JD#= d#aLc J#)&(HJ a) k RSQP (&B )#
k
RS c .&B2F T#J#EH2$H#)"D #HH.I#&(D#;&S ,"2J2 J#)&(HJ H(JD2B
G;F ;T2F RQ I#&.D2J 2T2& (GD2F D.F&#&) H#)"D ;GG* J.))2JD#&)
D"(D D"2 "(FT2JD2B 2H2=DF;&J _2F2 "(FBH5 B2H#T2F2B D; dR
a'#).F2 XEcS C;_2T2F* _#D" ( J.EJD#D.D#;& ;G dR G;F @bR*
D"2J2 J#)&(HJ B#J(UU2(F2B* _"#=" E2 21UH(#&2B E5 D"2 G(=D
D"(D D"2 2H2=DF;& (D d#aLc I#)F(D2B D; @bR G;F #&#D#(H
(=D#T(D#;& (&B D"2& d#aLc D.F& E(=` #&D; B#(I()&2D#= d#aLLcS
M2(&_"#H2* D"2 Y', =(H=.H(D#;&J ;G D"2 7@d$ZQ I;B2H
a'#).F2 4RPc J";_ D"(D @bR I;H2=.H2J _2F2 UF2G2F2&D#(HH5
(BJ;FE2B (D D"2 d# (D;IJ ;G D"2 d#$;1; =H.JD2F _"2F2 I;JD
;G D"2 U";D;$21=#D2B 2H2=DF;&J H;=(H#N2BS A&B D"2 (BJ;FUD#;&
2&2F)5 aV(BJc _(J 2&"(&=2B _#D" D"2 UF2J2&=2 ;G U";D;$
21=#D2B 2H2=DF;&* _"#=" =;.HB E2&2G#D D"2 (=D#T(D#;& ;G @bR
a,(EH2 4\cS ,"2 (GG#&#D5 G;F CRb* D"2 ;D"2F F2(=D(&D #&
;T2F(HH
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Z

Page 7 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 8 of 11
?2J2(F=" 7F;)F(I ;G 'F;&D#2F 4=#2&=2 @A4 a9>!Y0$448$
!P" :0% J'( S0,% a'( A*3,% J'( R0+,-% &'( a$,-% )'( :0% X'(
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
4-CQ]PcS
#$% )' A, +;$,36C0,94$/,+5$^3@ 4$4+,$0; ;34+56/8-+,$9
C8+;3</8= N*/4/9+4+5B?4 <$4* K$?$L5365$-*46$,@093@
+94$K$4B C/8 A7E 83@094$/,' AA>&C" ,2&1" @A%" ; " !" % =5%
QQPO'
:3?3:3C.3<
!" #$% &'( )*+,-% .'( )*/0% 1' 234+5678-+,$96
:8+;3</8=6>+?3@ A+4+5B?4? C/8 D*/4/83@094$/, /C A7E'
A !" #$%&'" !"#% ()% !FGHH!E'
!F" :+433K+% A'( A*+438% D' A'( b835+,@% A' D'( I+*$8% A' A'(
1*$;B+=% J' )'( .$N38% D' `'( a+8<3,4% U' &'( &/??3$,?=B%
E" I0% .'( )*/0% J'( )/0% )' D*/4/9+4+5B4$9 9/,K38?$/, /C
A7E $,4/ 83,3<+L53 *B@8/9+8L/, C035?M ?4+436/C64*36+84
+99/;N5$?*;3,4% 9*+553,-3?% +,@ N8/?N394?' A !" #$%&'"
!"$% *+% OPGF'
2' U'
A <+4386?4+L53 N/8N*B8$,6L+?3@ ;34+56/8-+,$9
C8+;3</8= +94$K3 C/8 K$?$L5365$-*4 N*/4/9+4+5B?$?' AA>&C"
,2&1" @A%" ; " !" % =5% FOOG'
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
!T" X0% R' _'( R0% U'( .+,-% a'( #$% )'( )*+,-% _'( #0/% J'(
J0% S' R'( U$+,-% R' #' `$?$L536#$-*4 D*/4/83@094$/, /C A7E
$, + 234+5678-+,$9 :8+;3</8=M >//?4$,- Y53948/,6R/53
S3N+8+4$/, K$+ Y53948/, I8+N S4+43?' 0" A1" ,2&1" -34"
!")% 5(D% !QOOG'
Q" #$% 1'( D3,-% >'( D3,-% I' &393,4 A@K+,93? $,
R3438/-3,3/0? D*/4/9+4+5B4$9 A7E A/,K38?$/, 4/ S/5+8
:035?' A,- ,$%$." !"%% +% FOTH'
O" #/<% U'( J0% U'( U+8/,$39% 2'( .+-3*% S'( A56V*+;@$% A'
A' R3438/W0,94$/, D*/4/9+4+5B?4?' A !" #$%&'" !"&% */'
H" J0% U'( #/<% U'( X$+/% .'( )*/0% D'( U+8/,$39% 2'
Y,*+,93@ N*/4/9+4+5B4$9 A7E683@094$/, +94$K$4B /C
+,+4+?3 I$7E LB 9/3ZN/?3@ [GG!\ +,@ [!G!\ C+934?' 0" A1"
,2&1" -34" !"$% 5(+% TTQ]'
!]" A*3,% Y' X'( _$0% 2'( )*+,-% J' :'( )*0% J' S'( #$0% #'
J'( S0,% J' J'( >0% X'( )*+,-% U'( #$,% _' A9$@ +,@ >+?3
&3?$?4+,4 )$89/,$0; D/5BN*3,/5+436234+55/N/8N*B8$,
S9+CC/5@? C/8 YCC$9$3,4 A7E D*/4/83@094$/,' A !" #$%&'"
!"&% 5D)E(::'
P" R/9*% #' >'( S^B;+,?=$% D'( V*0;+,% 1' 1'( R3% #'(
#$+/% 1'( _$+/% _'( &3B3?% #' 2'( )*0% J'( Y56S+B3@% 2' A'(
S$,-*% A' `'( 7^$,% V' A' A+88$38 @B,+;$9? +,@ 4*3 8/53 /C
?08C+93 @3C394?M a3?$-,$,- + N*/4/9+4+5B?4 C/8 -+?6N*+?3
A7E 83@094$/,' 6'34" 7$%." A4$ " -48" !"%% 55(% YTG!!'
F" #$0% _'( )*/0% J'( 1/0% U'( A*3,% X'( I$+,% )'( V+/% U'(
J+,% S'( )/0% )' R$-*6B$35@ ?B,4*3?$? /C 0548+5/,- +,@
0548+4*$, ),EV37O ,+,/8$LL/,? 4/<+8@ $;N8/K3@
N*/4/9+4+5B4$9 83@094$/, /C A7E $,4/ 83,3<+L53
*B@8/9+8L/, C035' 0" A1" ,2&1" -34" !"!% 5(*% !OQTH'
T" .+,-% S'( V0+,% >' J'( #0% J'( #/0% X' .' a' :/8;+4$/,
EG" S0,% a'( :0% J'( #$0% .'( J3% #'( .+,-% a'( J+,-% #'(
:0% X'( #$% )' S40@$3? /, N*/4/9+4+5B4$9 A7E 83@094$/, /K38
cRE6e$/6PP )8" +,@ $4? @38$K+4$K3?M 4/<+8@? + L34438
0,@38?4+,@$,- /C N*/4/9+4+5B?$? /, ;34+56/8-+,$9
C8+;3</8=?' ,2&1" ;<'" 0" !"(% 5/% !OEF]'
E!" )*+,-% R'( .3$% U'( a/,-% U'( #$0% V'( S*$% #'( A,% D'(
)*+/% V'( 1/,-% U'( .+,-% X'( 23,-% X'( )*+,-% U'( J3% U'
YCC$9$3,4 `$?$L536#$-*46a8$K3, A+8L/, a$/Z$@3 &3@094$/,
LB + S$,-536A4/; b;N5+,43@ 234+5678-+,$9 :8+;3</8='
AA>&C" ,2&1" @A%" ; " !"%% ==% !OQ!G'
EE" a$9=3,?% A' :'( 2/,4/B+% U' R'( 105=+8,$% A' &'(
>+W@$9*% 2'( cf8?=/K% U' 1' A, 353948/,$9 ?48094083
@3?98$N4/8 C/8 /ZB-3, 83+94$K$4B +4 ;34+5 +,@ ;34+56/Z$@3
?08C+93?' -<'F$4& -48&A4& !"'% +:5% !EE'
/C
R$38+89*$9+5
b,ESQ6A@b,ESO
R3438/?48094083@
c+,/40L3? C/8 YCC$9$3,4 +,@ S4+L53 `$?$L53 #$-*4 A7E
&3@094$/,' 0" A1" ,2&1" -34" !"&% 5(/% !FQGH'
]" #$% U' &'( S90553B% U'( )*/0% R' A' 234+56/8-+,$9
C8+;3</8=? C/8 ?3N+8+4$/,?' ,2&1" 9&!" !" % 55*% TP]'
!G" 183,/% #' Y'( #3/,-% 1'( :+8*+% 7' 1'( A553,@/8C% 2'(
`+, a0B,3% &' D'( R0NN% U' I' 234+56/8-+,$9 C8+;3</8=
;+438$+5? +? 9*3;$9+5 ?3,?/8?' ,2&1" 9&!" !" % 55*% !!GH'
!!" #33% U'( :+8*+% 7' 1'( &/L384?% U'( S9*3$@4% 1' A'(
c-0B3,% S' I'( R0NN% U' I' 234+56/8-+,$9 C8+;3</8=
;+438$+5? +? 9+4+5B?4?' ,2&1" -34" 9&!" !!'% (:% !OHG'
!E" #+5/,@3% 2'( >08B% .'( 1+8+-$+8$@$% 7'( >8/<,% )'(
R0NN% U' I'( :+8*+% 7' 1' I8+,?;34+5+4$/,M 8/043? 4/ ;34+5
3Z9*+,-3 <$4*$, ;34+5d/8-+,$9 C8+;3</8=?' 0" #$%&'"
,2&1" A !"(% 5% HOHQ'
EQ" #33% J'( 1$;% S'( 1+,-% U' 1'( A/*3,% S' 2'
D*/4/9+4+5B4$9 A7E 83@094$/, LB + ;$Z3@ ;34+5 )8gI$"%
;$Z3@ 5$-+,@ ;34+56/8-+,$9 C8+;3</8= 0,@38 K$?$L53
5$-*4 $88+@$+4$/,' ,2&1" ,311<A" !")% =5% HFQH'
EO" a3 `/?% A'( R3,@8$9=Z% 1'( `+, a38 `//84% D'( `+,
SN3BL8/39=% `'( #3W+3-*383% 1' 2$??$,- #$,=38?M A,
A5438,+4$K3 D+4*<+B 4/ e$76PP Y53948/,$9 S48094083
Y,-$,338$,-' ,2&18?%'B 3F 1$%&'8$.? !"&% */% QGGP'
EH" .0% X' D'( V+-5$+8@$% #'( I80*5+8% a' V' A38$0; 234+56
78-+,$9 :8+;3</8= C/8 D*/4/9+4+5B?$?' 0" A1" ,2&1" -34"
!"#% 5E)% F]GO'
EP" .0% X'6D'( V+-5$+8@$% #'( I80*5+8% a' V' 234+5 @/N$,-
$, 938$0; ;34+56/8-+,$9 C8+;3</8=? C/8 K$?$L53683?N/,?3
<+438 ?N5$44$,- N*/4/9+4+5B?4?' 0" ,2&1" 62B?" !"'% 5=)%
GO!FG!'
!Q" #+,% J' _'( #$% S' #'( U$+,-% R' #'( X0% _' I+$5/86;+@3
;34+56/8-+,$9 C8+;3</8=? C8/; C0,94$/,+5$^3@ ;/53905+8
L0$5@$,- L5/9=? +,@ 53,-4*6+@W0?4+L53 /8-+,$9 5$,=38? LB
?43N<$?3 ?B,4*3?$?' ,2&1" ;<'" 0" !" % 5:% TGFP'
EF" V/,-% 2'( .+,-% a'6J'( A*3,% A'6A'( R<+,-% >'6U'(
a+$% R' A ;$,$ 83K$3< /, ,$9=356L+?3@ 353948/9+4+5B?4? C/8
+5=+5$,3 *B@8/-3, 3K/504$/, 83+94$/,' 7$A3 9&?" !")% /%
ET'
!O" R/@% b'( S+;N?/,% 2' a'( a38$+% D'( 10L$+=% A' D'(
:+8*+% 7' 1'( R0NN% U' I' :36D/8N*B8$,6>+?3@ 234+5d
78-+,$9
:8+;3</8=
:$5;?
+?
R$-*6S08C+93
A+4+5B?4? C/8
A/,93,48+4$/,%
R3438/-3,3/0?
ET" 1+,+,% 2' .'( S083,@8+,+4*% J'( c/938+% a' V'
A/L+546N*/?N*+43 /ZB-3,63K/5K$,- 9/;N/0,@' ,2&1" -34"
9&!" !!'% (:% !G]'
Y53948/9*3;$9+5 &3@094$/, /C A7E' A,- ,$%$." !")% =%
PQGE'
!H" V0/% V'( J+/% J'( .0% 1'( .0% #'( R0+,-% U' S40@$3? /,
4*3 S480940836S3,?$4$K3 :0,94$/,+5 2+438$+5?' 6'3>'&?? @A
,2&18?%'B !!"% 5(% !H!'
E]" &+,% U'( U+8/,$39% 2'( _$+/% S' )' A/9+4+5B?4? $,
S3;$9/,@094/86L+?3@ D*/4/9+4+5B4$9 A7E &3@094$/,M
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
\

Page 9 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
A9*$3K3;3,4?% A*+553,-3?% +,@ 7NN/840,$4$3?' A !"
OQ" .+,-% )'( 2+% .'( A*3,% A'( U$% R'( )*+/% U' D8/L$,-
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
#$%&'" !"#% ()'
N+8+;+-,34$9 ?N39$3? $, 4$4+,$+6L+?3@ *3438/-3,3/0?
N*/4/9+4+5B?$? LB 353948/, ?N$, 83?/,+,93 YS&"
?N3948/?9/NBiA ;$,$ 83K$3<' ,2&1" ;A>" 0" !""% 5D)%
QHQ'
QG" J0+,% S'( _$,% U' S'( #/55+8% A' I'( )*/0% R' A' S4+L53
234+5678-+,$9 :8+;3</8=? <$4* V8/0N O 234+5?M A0883,4
S4+40? +,@ I83,@?' A,- ,&A%" -48" !"#% E% OOG'
Q!" A0L83B% 2' #'( .$38?% >' 2'( A,@83<?% S' A'( S+=08+$%
I'( &3B3?6#$55/% S' Y'( R+;3@% S' 2'( J0% A' U'( a+8+-/% #'
Y'( 2+?/,% U' A'( >+3-% U' 7'( V8+,@W3+,% :'( #/,-% V' U'(
S3=$% S'( c3+4/,% U' >'( J+,-% D'( #/,-% U' &' Y53948/,
@35/9+5$^+4$/, +,@ 9*+8-3 ;/L$5$4B +? + C0,94$/, /C
83@094$/, $, + ;34+56/8-+,$9 C8+;3</8=' 7$%" #$%&'" !"#%
5D% PEH'
OO" J+,-% J'( )*+,-% J'( :+,-% )'( )*+,-% #'( )*3,-% )'(
.+,-% )'( :3,-% .'( .3,-% S'( )*+,-% S'( #$0% D'
S$;054+,3/0? &3+5$^+4$/, /C Y,*+,93@ D*/4/+94$K$4B +,@
D8/;/43@ D*/4/?4+L$5$4B LB 2054$5+B383@ 2/SE A/+4$,-
/, A@S c+,/<$83 S48094083 K$+ A/;N+94 A/+4$,-
234*/@/5/-B' A,- AGG." #$%&'" @A%&'F$4&? !"&% /% P]HG'
OH" a33,+@+B+5+,% 2' S'( S*+8;+% c'( `38;+% D' 1'(
c+-+8+W+% A' 2' `$?$L536#$-*46A??$?43@ D*/4/9+4+5B4$9
&3@094$/, /C c$48/+8/;+4$9? LB &39B95+L53 c$ bb"6
D/8N*B8$, 234+5678-+,$9 :8+;3</8= 27:" +4 &I' @A3'>"
,2&1" !"%% ==% HQEG'
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
QE" .+,-% 1'( #K% X' #'( :3,-% a'( #$% U'( A*3,% S'( S0,% U'(
S/,-% #'( X$3% J'( #$% U' &'( )*/0% R' A' DB8+^/5+436>+?3@
D/8N*B8$,$9
234+5678-+,$9
:8+;3</8=
<$4*
YZ48+/8@$,+8B >+?36&3?$?4+,93' 0" A1" ,2&1" -34" !"%%
5(:% ]!O'
OP" Y56I+L5% A' S'( S*+=@/C+% 2' 2' Y'( Y56S3$@B% A' 2' A'
SB,4*3?$? +,@ ?N3948/?9/N$9 9*+8+9438$^+4$/, /C ,$9=35 bb"%
9/L+54 bb" +,@ 9/NN38 bb" 9/;N53Z3? /C @$/Z$;3 5$-+,@?'
-1$'% 7$A3431G3?8%&? !""% *% !EF'
QQ" .$553;?% I' :'( &B98/C4% A' R'( 1+^$% 2'( 23^+% U' A'(
R+8+,9^B=% 2' A5-/8$4*;? +,@ 4//5? C/8 *$-*64*8/0-*N04
-3/;348B6L+?3@ +,+5B?$? /C 98B?4+55$,3 N/8/0? ;+438$+5?'
#84'3G3'3<? $A #&?3G3'3<? #$%&'8$.? !" % 5E/% !QO'
QO" J+/% 2' S'( I+,-% .' X'( .+,-% V' Y'( c+4*% >'( X0% V'
27: I*$, :$5;6A/+43@ 234+5 7Z$@3 c+,/<$83 A88+BM
OF" R/55$-38% A'( D$38$=% A' U'( &3$W38?3% Y' U'( R+-3,% .' &'
A ?N3948/353948/9*3;$9+5 ?40@B /C C+94/8 :OQG ,$9=35 bbgb"
C8/; ;34*+,/-3,$9 L+9438$+ $, +j03/0? ?/504$/,' 0" A1"
,2&1" -34" "''(% 55=% HPH!'
S$-,$C$9+,45B
b;N8/K3@
A*3;$83?$?4/8
S3,?/8
D38C/8;+,93' A !" #$%&'" !"%% *:% HEE]'
OT" #/K399*$/% :' `'( V/83% Y' S'( >0?9*% a' R' 7Z$@+4$/,
+,@ 83@094$/, L3*+K$/8 /C ;+98/9B95$9 9/;N53Z3? /C
,$9=35' Y53948/9*3;$9+5 +,@ 353948/, ?N$, 83?/,+,93
?40@$3?' 0" A1" ,2&1" -34" "'&$% /+% Q!G]'
QH" )*+,-% U' R'( A5+8=% a' U'( >8+,4% U' A'( S$,+-8+% A' .'%
Q8@( 1$;% J' S'( U+,-% U' b'( A$4=3,% U' A' b,C8+83@ ,/,5$,3+8
/N4$9+5 N8/N384$3? /C 5$4*$0;69/,4+$,$,- @$+;/,@65$=3
?3;$9/,@094/8? #$E),V3S3O +,@ #$E),S,S3O' H$.%3A I'$A?"
!")% EE% !!E!E'
O]" 235+,@38% 2'( U/,??/,% Y' 7'( 2/843,?3,% U' U'( `3--3%
I'( V+89$+ #+?48+% U' 2' b;N53;3,4+4$/, /C A/,?48+$,3@
a:I C/8 A/;N04$,- A*+8-3 I8+,?C38 &+43? <$4*$, 4*3
D8/W394/8 A0-;3,43@ .+K3 234*/@' 0" ,2&1" I2&3'B"
,31G<%" !"%% 5*% HQPF'
QP" a$389=?% A' S'( #$0% J'( A/8@/K+% 1' Y'( J+-*$% 7' 2'
I*3 8/53 /C 834$905+8 9*3;$?48B $, 4*3 @3?$-, /C A7E
83@094$/, 9+4+5B?4?' 7$%" #$%&'" !"#% 5D% QG!'
QF" V/;3? S$5K+% A'( #0^% b'( #5+L83? $ X+;3,+% :' X'(
HG" >3,@38% U' A'( &+0538?/,% Y' 1'( #$% X'( V/5@^+=% I'( X$+%
D'( `+, `//8*$?% I'( I+,-% 2' #'( &/L384?% S' I' S08C+93
S4+43? 23@$+43 I8$N534 Y,38-B I8+,?C38 $, c+,/98B?4+56
A93,3 A/;N/?$43 SB?43;?' 0" A1" ,2&1" -34" !"#% 5E)%
FHOQ'
A/8;+%
A'(
V+89$+%
R'
.+438
?4+L53
)86
L3,^3,3@$9+8L/ZB5+43 ;34+56/8-+,$9 C8+;3</8=? +?
N*/4/9+4+5B?4? C/8 *B@8/-3, -3,38+4$/,' ,2&1" ;<'" 0"
!"!% 5+% !!!QQ'
QT" a+,6R+8@$% 2'( S3883% A'( :8/4% I'( &/^3?% #'( 2+08$,%
V'( S+,9*3^% A'( :383B% V' A ,3< N*/4/+94$K3 98B?4+55$,3
*$-*5B N/8/0? 4$4+,$0; b`" @$9+8L/ZB5+43' 0" A1" ,2&1"
-34" !!'% 5(5% !GTHF'
H!" A+,,$,-% A'( A*+0@*8B% A'( >/049*=/% &'( V8f,L39*6
U3,?3,% c' :$8?46N8$,9$N53? ?40@B /C 50;$,3?93,93 $, A36
@/N3@ $,/8-+,$9 ?9$,4$55+4/8?' 62B?" 9&!" K !""% :('
HE" R3% R'( )+N/5% D'( A084$??% #' A' A I*3/834$9+5 S40@B
/C A7E A,$/,? /, A,+4+?3 !G!" S08C+93' 0" 62B?" ,2&1" ,
!"!% 55E% E!OFO'
Q]" S*$% #'( #$% D'( )*/0% .'( .+,-% I'( A*+,-% 1'( )*+,-%
R'( 1+=/% I'( #$0% V'( J3% U' ,64BN3 L/8/, N*/?N*$@3 +? +
*$-*5B ?4+L53% ;34+56C833% K$?$L5365$-*46+94$K3 N*/4/9+4+5B?4
C/8 *B@8/-3, 3K/504$/,' 7$A3 ;A&'>B !"%% *:% !HT'
OG" :0% U'( U$+,-% 1'( _$0% X'( J0% U'( #$0% 2' D8/@094
?35394$K$4B /C N*/4/9+4+5B4$9 A7E 83@094$/, 83+94$/,?'
#$%&'8$.? I3 $B ! !% (*% EEE'
HQ" J+,-% #'( #$% X'( )*+,-% V'( A0$% D'( .+,-% X'( U$+,-%
X'( )*+/% U'( #0/% J'( U$+,-% U' A/;L$,$,- N*/4/9+4+5B4$9
*B@8/-3, -3,38+4$/, +,@ 9+N?053 ?4/8+-3 $, -8+N*3,3
L+?3@ ?+,@<$9* ?48094083?' 7$%" ,311<A" !"&% :% !PGO]'
HO" U$,% S'( I+-5$+^099*$% 2'( S/,% R'6U'( R+88$?% &' a'(
A80@+% 1' 7'( .3$,L38-% a' U'( c3N/;,B+?*9*$$% A' >'(
:+8*+% 7' 1'( R0NN% U' I'( .3$??% Y' A' Y,*+,93;3,4 /C 4*3
J$35@ /C D*/4/$,@093@ A*+8-3 S3N+8+4$/, $, )$,9
O!" )*+,-% 1'( #$0% U'( .+,-% #'( U$,% >'( J+,-% X'( )*+,-%
S'( D+8=% U' R' c3+86A/;N5343 S0NN83??$/, /C 7ZB-3,
YK/504$/, C/8 D*/4/353948/9*3;$9+5 RE7 7Z$@+4$K3 RE7E
SB,4*3?$?' 0" A1" ,2&1" -34" ! !% 5E*% TPO!'
D/8N*B8$,d_0+,40;
a/4
A/;N53Z3?
LB
+
OE" >+@38% R'( S408^3,3--38% `'( R/$-,h% U' D*/4/;348$9
;34*/@ C/8 4*3 @3438;$,+4$/, /C 5/< 9/,93,48+4$/,? /C
*B@8/-3, N38/Z$@3 LB 4*3 N38/Z$@+?3 9+4+5B^3@ /Z$@+4$/,
/C c%c6@$34*B56N6N*3,B53,3@$+;$,3 aDa"' J$%&' 9&?"
"'##% **% !!G]'
>$? @$4*$/9+8L+;+43" #$,=+-3' 0" 62B?" ,2&1" , !")% 55/%
H!]H'
HH" J+,% )' R'( a0% 2' R'( #$0% U'( U$,% S'( .+,-% A'(
)*0+,-% V' #'( 1/,-% X' U'( #/,-% #' S'( )*3,-% #' S' D*/4/6
-3,38+43@ @$,0953+8 [Y0 bb"\E +94$K3 ?$43? C/8 ?35394$K3 A7E
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
^

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 10 of 11
83@094$/, $, + N*/4/?3,?$4$^$,- ;34+56/8-+,$9 C8+;3</8='
1
7$%" ,311<A" !"#% /% QQHQ'
2
3
HP" :+,-% X'( S*+,-% _'( .+,-% J'( U$+/% #'( J+/% I'( #$% J'(
)*+,-% _'( #0/% J'( U$+,-% R' #' S$,-53 D4 A4/;? A/,C$,3@
4
$,4/
+
234+5678-+,$9 :8+;3</8= C/8 YCC$9$3,4
5
D*/4/9+4+5B?$?' A !" #$%&'" !"#% ()'
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Q

Page 11 of 11
Journal of the American Chemical Society
1
,(EH2 ;G @;&D2&DJ
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment