DOI: 10.1002/cbic.200900597
A Prochelator Activated by Hydrogen Peroxide Prevents Metal-Induced
Amyloid b Aggregation
[
a]
Marina G. Dickens and Katherine J. Franz*
Alzheimer’s is a progressive and fatal brain disease that is the
most common form of dementia. Its characteristic pathology
includes extracellular amyloid plaques that form as a result of
abnormal clearance and/or increased production of amyloid-b
peptides (Ab) that are released from the amyloid precursor
Metal chelating agents have appeared as a compelling strat-
[20]
egy for Alzheimer’s therapies. In particular, 8-hydroxyquino-
line (8HQ) derivatives clioquinol and PBT2 have shown promis-
ing results in mouse models and phase IIa clinical trials of Alz-
[21,22]
heimer’s patients.
These compounds inhibit metal-induced
[
1,2]
+/2+
2+
protein (APP).
Metal ions, particularly Cu
, have been implicated in two processes related to
Ab pathology: peptide aggregation and formation of reactive
and Zn , but
Ab aggregation and ROS generation. While these reports en-
courage further development of metal-targeted compounds
for neurodegenerative disease, there remain significant con-
2
+/3+
also Fe
[
3]
[23,24]
oxygen species (ROS).
It is speculated that both APP and Ab might have normal
cerns about manipulating metal distribution in the brain.
Given the complexity of the metallobiology in Alzheimer’s, it is
particularly challenging to design metal-binding agents that
can mitigate the damaging effects of metals while preserving
their beneficial properties. In our laboratory, we are developing
[
4,5]
roles in copper homeostasis.
It has also been shown in vitro
that Ab can act as an antioxidant by quenching free radicals
[
6,7]
and/or by chelating copper.
Other evidence, however, sug-
gests that Ab–Cu complexes are pro-oxidant and directly cul-
prochelators that are designed to bind metals only under con-
[
8]
[25–27]
pable of neurotoxicity. In vitro, Ab in the presence of copper
ditions of oxidative stress.
The indications that elevated
[9–11]
or iron and reducing agents like ascorbate produces H O ,
production of H O by deviant Cu–Ab interactions might trig-
2 2
2
2
which can subsequently react with the reduced metal ions to
ger neurodegeneration suggested to us that prochelators acti-
[
12,13]
produce OHC via the Fenton reaction [Eq. (1)].
ated H O generation appears at an early stage during in vitro
Metal-medi-
vatable by H O2 could be beneficial for managing a metal
2
burden at locations of disease progression without stimulating
widespread metal redistribution. Here, we present a boronic
ester-masked 8-hydroxyquinoline derivative called QBP that
converts to 8HQ in the presence of H O . Once converted to
2
2
[
10,11]
Ab aggregation,
which supports the notion that soluble
Ab–Cu species are responsible for the oxidative damage that is
one of the earliest pathological events in Alzheimer’s dis-
2
2
[
14]
ease. Furthermore, copper has been shown to intensify Ab
8HQ, it is available for coordinating metal ions, as shown in
[
9,10,15]
2+
2+
2+
toxicity in primary cortical neurons.
Like Cu , Zn also
Scheme 1 for Cu . The protecting group is ultimately released
[28,29]
promotes Ab aggregation in vitro, but the Zn-induced aggre-
as pinanediol and nontoxic boric acid.
[
16–18]
gates could be neuroprotective.
þ
2þ
ꢀ
Cu þ H O ! Cu þ OH þ OHC
ð1Þ
2
2
One hypothesis to reconcile the seemingly contra-
dictory evidence related to metals, Ab, and oxidative
stress is that metal binding and Ab aggregation
might represent an initial, protective response to
dampen production of ROS. Excessive H O and an
2
2
overburden of copper could eventually push the
system into a vicious cycle that switches Ab–Cu ac-
[
19]
tivity from antioxidant to pro-oxidant. During this
2
+
stage, metal exchange with Zn could promote fur-
ther Ab aggregation as a defense against copper-
induced damage. While chelating agents are known
2 2
Scheme 1. Oxidation of QBP by H O and subsequent binding of copper by 8-hydroxy-
quinoline (8HQ).
to reverse metal-induced aggregates, this model suggests that
disaggregating plaques alone could have the unintended con-
QBP was synthesized by reacting commercially available
quinoline boronic acid (QBA) with pinanediol in a Dean Stark
apparatus. The X-ray crystal structure is shown in Figure 1. QBP
is stable in aqueous solution between pH 5–8 over the course
of 10 h, although some hydrolysis to QBA occurs at lower and
higher pH values, as monitored by UV/Vis and mass spectrom-
etry (data not shown).
[
19]
sequence of exacerbating oxidative damage.
[
a] M. G. Dickens, Dr. K. J. Franz
Department of Chemistry, Duke University
P.O. Box, 90346 Durham, NC 27708 (USA)
Fax: (+1)919-660-1605
With the phenol of 8HQ masked by the pinanediol boronic
ester, the QBP prochelator should have little to no affinity for
metal ions. Comparison of the UV/Vis spectra in Figure 2 of
E-mail: katherine.franz@duke.edu
Supporting information for this article is available on the WWW under
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/cbic.200900597.
ChemBioChem 2010, 11, 59 – 62
ꢀ 2010 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
59