X.-L. Wei et al. / Catalysis Communications 61 (2015) 48–52
51
Table 3
environments [27]. As shown in Supplementary Fig. S3, the shoulder
line at 650 cm−1 in the LRS spectrum corresponds to internal vibrations
of C\S bonds. For Co–HM-50, the intensity of this shoulder peak is
significantly weaker than that of HM-50, further revealing the coordina-
tion of organic –SH groups with cobalt ions. The scanning electron
micrographs (SEM) of samples in Fig. 2 indicate the irregular morphol-
ogies of samples composed of the particles with the size of 300 nm–
1 μm. TG curves of HM and Co–HM materials are illustrated in Supple-
mentary Fig. S4, in which the weight loss between room temperature
and 350 °C was due to the evaporation of water and the decomposition
of organics in the materials, and that between 350 and 700 °C was at-
tributable to the combustion of organics occluded in the molecular
sieve.
Effect of different metals on the epoxidation of styrene.
Reaction conditions: styrene (3 mmol), DMF (10 g), catalyst (0.1 g), initiator (TBHP,
0.3 mmol), time (5 h), temperature (90 °C), and flow rate of air (40 ml/min).
Catalyst
Conv. (mol%)
Selectivity (%)
Epoxide
Phen.
Ben.
Others
Co–HM-50
Cr–HM-50
Mn–HM-50
Fe–HM-50
Ni–HM-50
Cu–HM-50
Zn–HM-50
95.8
10.0
7.9
16.8
9.4
89.2
75.8
79.2
73.5
69.3
80.0
72.6
3.4
1.8
0.9
0
0
0.7
1.2
4.7
16.5
18.9
20.1
24.8
16.5
19.9
2.7
5.9
1.0
6.4
5.9
2.8
6.3
14.9
7.5
3.2. Catalytic epoxidation of styrene with air
indicative of the initiating effect of TBHP on the titled reaction, as has
been reported by other works [28,29].
3.2.1. Effect of different catalysts and reaction conditions
The effect of various solvents on the epoxidation of styrene with air
is shown in Table S2 (Supplementary data). Obviously, the solvent plays
an important role in the epoxidation reactions. The conversion of
styrene decreases in the sequence of DMF (95.8 mol%) N 1,4-dioxane
(45.6 mol%) N MIBK (41.6 mol%) N acetylacetone (12.8 mol%) N toluene
(10.4 mol%) N pyridine (0). After the reaction was completed, we quan-
titatively detected that only 0.1–0.2% of DMF was oxidized, indicating
that DMF was not a real reductant in this reaction. Our previous studies
by means of UV spectrum and cyclic voltammetry (CV) analyses, had re-
vealed the coordination of DMF to Co(II) [31]. Such a coordination could
affect the binding ability of O2 to Co(II) as well as their redox potential,
further leading to the activation of O2 in the epoxidation.
The influence of reaction temperature on the epoxidation of styrene
over Co–HM-50 is depicted in Supplementary Fig. S5. The conversion
and selectivity gradually increase with the rise of temperature from 50
to 90 °C. At 90 °C, the optimal activity is achieved with 95.8 mol% con-
version of styrene and 89.2% selectivity of epoxide. However, at 100 °C
the selectivity of epoxide drops to 85.2%. This means that too high tem-
perature will accelerate the oxidation of benzaldehyde to benzoic acid,
leading to the drop of epoxide selectivity.
The catalytic activity of different Co–HM-x samples for the epoxida-
tion of styrene is compared in Table 2. These catalysts are considerably
active for the titled epoxidation, achieving more than 80.6 mol% conver-
sion of styrene, notably higher than those of the parent HM (7.8 mol%)
and the blank test (7.2 mol%). The conversion of styrene decreases in the
order of Co–HM-50 (95.8 mol%) N Co–HM-60 (91.4 mol%) N Co–HM-40
(87.2 mol%) N Co–HM-30 (80.6 mol%), similar to the decreasing se-
quence of the epoxide selectivity: Co–HM-60 (89.4%) ≈ Co–HM-50
(89.2%) N Co–HM-40 (88.9%) N Co–HM-30 (84.5%). This arrangement
can be correlated with the cobalt content (in Table 1) and the high crys-
tallinity of HM-50 (in Fig. 1). As shown in Table 3, among all the transi-
tion metal catalysts Co–HM-50 exhibits the best activity with 95.8 mol%
conversion and 89.2% selectivity of epoxide. Note that even if pure
Co(Ac)2·4H2O is used as the catalyst, only 16.0 mol% conversion is
achieved. When comparing the UV–Vis spectra of HM-50, Co–HM-50
and Co(Ac)2·4H2O, we can observe that after the coordination, the
d–d transition absorption peak of Co shifts from 509 nm to 367 and
678 nm, due to the change of Co coordination environment. Thus, elec-
tronic transition of cobalt(II) ions becomes more active in the oxidation
reaction to result in an outstanding performance in the epoxidation of
styrene. Other transition metal-containing HM-50 catalysts merely
achieved low conversions of b16.8 mol%, which could be explained by
the difference of the ability to activate molecular oxygen in agreement
with our previous reports [28–30].
Table S1 (Supplementary data) presents the effect of various
oxidants on the epoxidation of styrene with dry air over Co–HM-50 at
90 °C. Almost no oxidation occurs with NaClO or under inert N2 atmo-
sphere without any oxidant. The oxidants like H2O2, TBHP and NaIO4
show very low activities for the epoxidation of styrene, for which
16.8–20.4 mol% conversions and 60.6–82.8% selectivities are achieved.
However, when only dry air is used as unique oxidant, 65.9 mol% con-
version of styrene and 79.6% selectivity of epoxide are obtained, higher
than those obtained by usual oxidants. When air is used as the oxidant
together with a small amounts of TBHP as the initiator, 95.8 mol% con-
version of styrene and 89.2% selectivity of epoxide can be harvested,
3.2.2. Recycling studies of Co–HM-50
Catalyst recycling experiments were performed with the repeated
uses of Co–HM-50 at 90°C. It can be seen from Fig. 3 that when
Co–HM-50 is reused five times, the conversion of styrene is kept almost
unchanged, while the selectivity of epoxide maintains a small fluctua-
tion of 86.9–89.2%. XRD patterns testified that the recovered catalyst
that had been used 5 recycles still retained the structure of fresh sample
(Fig. 1), but the intensity of peaks decreased, probably due to the
removal of partial Al species from the framework of zeolite during
recycling, further leading to the reduction of Co content from 1.780 to
1.719% a little bit.
Table 2
Effect of different materials on the epoxidation of styrene.
Reaction conditions: styrene (3 mmol), DMF (10 g), catalyst (0.1 g), initiator (TBHP,
0.3 mmol), time (5 h), temperature (90 °C), and flow rate of air (40 ml/min).
Catalyst
Conv. (mol%)
Selectivity (%)
Epoxide
Phen.
Ben.
Others
No catalyst
Co(Ac)2·4H2O
HM-50
Co–HM-30
Co–HM-40
Co–HM-50
Co–HM-60
7.2
16.0
7.8
80.6
87.2
95.8
91.4
75.8
83.4
79.2
84.5
88.9
89.2
89.4
2.4
4.8
1.7
4.6
3.6
3.4
3.2
13.6
6.8
10.4
6.0
5.0
4.7
8.2
5.0
8.7
4.9
2.5
2.7
2.9
4.5
Fig. 3. Recycling studies of catalysts.